The charm of an old home is in the details, and 7309 Brighton Road, Ben Avon, has plenty. But they weren’t always so obvious. The contrasting hardwood floors and 19th-century paneling were hidden under layers of paint and linoleum flooring.

“The house had been painted in the 1950s when the third owner did a huge renovation,” said Peter Herchenroether.  “I suppose that is what one did in the ′50s — paint dark wood.”

When he and his wife, Susan, bought the house in 1989, they set out to restore it to its 1867 grandeur. The most dramatic change came when they stripped black and white linoleum from the floor in the front hall and found three different types of wood done in alternating designs.

“That is how they would create a pattern in the 1860s,” said Mr. Herchenroether. “The original builders created different patterns using pine or oak or cherry.”

Advertise with us

After 33 years of caring for this historic Italianate-style home and raising two children there, the Herchenroethers have put it on the market. “It is just time to simplify and downsize,” he said.

The four-bedroom, 2½-bath home with five fireplaces is listed for $600,000 (MLS. No. 1507228) with Betsy Wotherspoon of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices (www.thepreferredrealty.com or 412-379-6764).

In addition to restoring the woodwork, the couple researched and installed custom, period wallpaper and added a sunroom in the back of the house.

“It’s a modern living space but it also respects the historical nature of the house,” he said of the addition.

The Herchenroethers also replaced broken transoms with stained-glass windows.

Advertise with us

“The front stained glass features the house as it looked when it was built along with the name of the original owners,” he said. “It is respecting the family that lived here for 90 years and built the house.”

They also put back the turret that had been removed by previous owners.

“We think it was removed in the 1940s or ’50s, but we had a photo of the original home and our architect used that to work up the dimensions and replace it.

“When it was lopped off it just looked ridiculous, like a widow’s walk, and we felt the house deserved to look the way it did when it was built.”

Mr. Herchenroether grew up in Ben Avon and remembers his parents working on their home. “I was kind of used to older homes as a kid.”

Advertise with us

He liked that this house had five fireplaces. “Two are gas and three are decorative,” he noted.

Despite the house’s age, it has a poured-concrete basement instead of stone or cinder block.

“It was one of the original houses in the area when Ben Avon was first subdivided and the house was moved to build Ohio River Boulevard,” he explained.  “There is a lot of structural integrity to this house.”

One positive result of the 1950s renovations was the installation of central air-conditioning and complete rewiring.

“The guts are up to date and we have a whole-house generator that keeps everything operating if the power goes out,” Mr. Herchenroether said.

Advertise with us

The Allegheny County property assessment is $219,700. Over the last three years, two houses have sold in the 7300 block of Brighton Road for $489,950 in September 2018 and $505,050 in November 2020 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/realestate/GeneralInfo.aspx?).

The couple plan to spend more time at their house in Arizona. They are proud of the work they have done on this house.

“It is a very livable 21st-century home in terms of its mechanics and it is centrally located in a very nice neighborhood,” he said.

“Our feeling was the house and the details needed to be respected and that is what we have tried to do.”

Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com.