An ambitious crime-fighting strategy aimed at reducing the city's homicide rate is too narrowly focused on gang violence and needs to widen its scope, according to researchers at the University of Pittsburgh's Center on Race and Social Problems.

A draft report points to several flaws in both the concept and the execution of the Pittsburgh Initiative to Reduce Crime, a comprehensive approach that enlists law enforcement, social services and community leaders in an effort to quell gang gunplay, which police have said accounts for most of the city's violence. However, the city's homicide rate has not declined since the program started.

The message of the program is simple. Police and victims confront gang members at a "call-in" meeting and tell them to stop killing or face massive group punishment the next time someone pulls a trigger. Service providers then offer an array of help.

The city-commissioned report is not the final assessment of the program. Ralph Bangs, the center's associate director and the lead author on the report, described it as an internal draft that has not been released to the public and is subject to change. He declined to comment.

Advertise with us

City officials said many changes already have been proposed for the program.

Among their findings, researchers wrote that Pittsburgh police have focused too narrowly on gang members listed in a "tightly guarded central gang database" and not enough on members of other groups that are at risk for violence, such as parolees.

City police, for example, hardly relied on a report by the University of Cincinnati Policing Institute that identified 35 "violent groups" in Pittsburgh and determined that 69 percent of the city's homicides from 2007 to early 2010 were "group-related."

The PIRC law enforcement team instead relied on its own intelligence that showed only two of the 12 homicides that happened in the city during the first quarter of 2011 were "gang-related."

"If PIRC only tries to address 17 percent of the homicide problem, it will most likely have little impact," the researchers wrote.

Advertise with us

"Focusing on gangs and gang members for call-ins is a major deviation from the model. The effect is that violent groups that are not gangs and group members not in gangs are being missed in the call-ins, which means that they may not be getting the PIRC message," the draft report said.

Introduced in 2008, the program was touted for its track record of dramatic success in other U.S. cities, such as Chicago and Boston. City officials, including Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, lauded the program even as it had problems getting off the ground.

In announcing the effort, the mayor said PIRC would show results on the street within six months.

At the first call-in session nearly two years later, the program's architect, David Kennedy, a professor and director of the Center for Crime Prevention and Control at New York's John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said, "We sometimes see results tomorrow."

But police bureau statistics don't show a decrease in homicides, which was the program's main task. There were 39 killings in the city in 2009, 57 in 2010 and 17 so far this year, which the medical examiner's office said is about on pace with last year's murder rate.

Advertise with us

The city has earmarked $400,000 for the program and appears poised to keep it running.

"We want to see those homicides reduced, and the reality is we're not there yet," said the city's Public Safety Director Michael Huss, who plans to have more involvement in the program's implementation. "If parts of this program need to be tweaked, that's what we need to do."

A host of changes are already in the works, said Councilman Ricky Burgess, whose legislation was the impetus for PIRC and who sits on the program's governing board. He declined to give specifics but said they include "a new form of police response to call-ins," "management changes" and an expanded focus on group violence, rather than gangs alone. In light of the fixes, he said, the draft report is "obsolete."

He said changes will also be made to police "crackdowns," the far-reaching law enforcement response prescribed as a way to punish members of a particular group after a killing.

The report says the crackdowns, which have happened several times around the city, have been too general and do not always pinpoint targeted offenders. The crackdowns have resembled traditional "saturation patrols," the ramped-up police presence in a neighborhood after a spate of crime, and not the more creative forms of punishment the program calls for.

Advertise with us

Among PIRC's successes, researchers said the program has fostered cooperation among law enforcement agencies and among social service providers, though a noticeable disconnect remains between the groups. The researchers' recommendations include bettering communication and involving non-law enforcement agencies in gathering intelligence and responding to violence.

Mr. Kennedy, who was in Pittsburgh last week to discuss changes to the program with city officials and police, said other cities where the program has thrived also encountered their share of rough spots.

"For Pittsburgh to weigh in and fix that when it's called for is good news," he said.