A federal judge in Philadelphia has denied the state Republican Party’s bid to allow poll watchers to cross county lines on Election Day, calling the request a “judicial fire drill.”
As a result of U.S. District Judge Gerald Pappert’s 28-page opinion Thursday, poll watchers — partisan observers who monitor voting places and can challenge voters — must serve in the county where they are registered to vote.
The state GOP filed suit to lift that requirement so registered Pennsylvania voters could serve anywhere in the state. The party argued that doing so would “bolster the public’s confidence in the process” by allowing it to import watchers into counties where there are few voters to draw from.
But critics feared the change could bog down the balloting process with spurious challenges, depressing turnout in Democratic strongholds such as Philadelphia. Nonpartisan watchdog groups sharply questioned the timing of the lawsuit, which was filed just over two weeks before the Nov. 8 election.
Judge Pappert, a Republican appointed by President Barack Obama, agreed: Pennsylvania Republicans, he wrote, were seeking “an extraordinary remedy” he would not grant in part “[b]ecause they have unreasonably delayed in doing so.”
By law, poll watchers must be authorized by a county. “As county workers focus on myriad critical tasks in the final days before the election,” he wrote, compelling counties to credential an influx of non-residents at the last minute risked “increasing their workload (perhaps to the point of impossibility).”
Read More
The opinion was at times withering. Republicans claimed that poll watching was a fundamental First Amendment right, he wrote, but during a hearing last week GOP lawyers “admitted that this was ‘not [their] strongest argument.’ They are correct in this regard.”
Republicans argued that their own voting rights would be diminished by cheating elsewhere, but Judge Pappert dismissed as “speculation” the idea that cross-county poll watching would stop fraud, assuming it even took place.
Pennsylvania’s Department of State, which administers the election and whose secretary was named as a defendant in the suit, hailed the ruling. “Judge Pappert’s ruling appropriately denied this attempt to change state law immediately before the election,” it said in a statement.
The state Republican Party called the ruling “a blow to openness and transparency in our electoral system. … We will continue to advocate for an open and fair electoral process and will review our legal options moving forward.”
But independent good-government groups were pleased.
“I think it’s the best outcome possible,” said Suzanne Almeida, who heads the League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania. “There really wasn’t time to implement changes, and in this hyper-partisan climate, it’s important to be able to look at policies on their face, rather than as political theater.”
“Election Day can be chaotic enough at the precincts, so I’m really glad about the decision,” agreed Allegra Chapman, director of voting and elections for Common Cause.
But Ms. Chapman’s organization also released a report Thursday, “Protecting the Vote in 2016,” which argued that Pennsylvania poll watchers still have too much power.
Poll watchers are among those who can challenge a voter’s identity or residence at the polls, a process the report says can “result in chaos and intimidation at polling places.” In 2004, such challenges, undertaken by Republican lawyers, caused long lines among University of Pittsburgh students trying to vote in Oakland. Many students registered to vote on campus, even though their driver’s licenses or other ID often identified them at their parents’ address. Under such circumstances, challenged voters are required to find another voter registered in the district to vouch for them.
“It shouldn’t have to be this way,” the Common Cause report argues, “but we encourage voters … to go to the polls with a friend or family member from the district.”
“The law places the burden on the voter, not the person making the challenge,” said Ms. Chapman, who said Election Day challenges should be undertaken only by election officials, rather than by partisan poll watchers.
Otherwise, she said, “What you see, more often than not, is political parties coming out with challenges for the purpose of discouraging or intimidating people.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.