The best place for humans to live on the moon might just be a pit in the "Lake of Death."

"There's a chance that it connects to a cave or an overhang that we could use for shelter," said Jordan Ford, a recent Carnegie Mellon University doctoral student, who designed a robot to search for alcoves that could protect astronauts from radiation and bullet-like mini-meteorites.

With the right camera, a glimpse into the potentially life-sustaining alcoves could also offer scientists a history of the moon's formation, Mr. Ford said. So far, the only images of pits have come from orbital satellites, which can only make out rough contours.

Unlike impact craters formed by falling meteors, pit craters are believed to have formed when lava tubes or magma chambers collapsed. Similar formations can be seen on Earth at the Hawaii Volcanoes National Park and in Iceland.

Advertise with us

On the moon, pits might connect to caves that could be made into homes for astronauts. The dwellings would be naturally insulated to a comfortable 63 degrees Fahrenheit, compared to the surface, where temperatures fluctuate between boiling and that of liquid nitrogen, about minus 320 F.

But even if the pits are habitable, getting into them poses a significant challenge. That’s what makes the Lake of Death pit such a prime candidate, Mr. Ford said. It appears to have a sloping ramp of about 28 degrees, shallow enough for a rover to drive down.

NASA was not immediately willing to fund that exploration. Earlier this year the agency turned down a proposal to include CMU's pit-searching technology on future missions, despite initially funding its development through a series of NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts beginning in 2011.

The NIAC program is designed for ideas that may never see implementation on real missions. CMU’s most recent proposal was to NASA’s competitive Payloads and Research Investigations on the Surface of the Moon (PRISM) program. A broader mission from the University of Central Florida to explore domes was approved through that program last year for $35 million.

"The fulfillment of these things occurs in their time and when opportunity presents itself," said Red Whittaker, Mr. Ford’s advisor at CMU and a pioneer of space technology.

Advertise with us

The professor is no stranger to having his ideas sidelined. In the 1990s NASA turned down his proposal for a $100 million discovery program to study lunar ice. A similar lunar pit discovery proposal from NASA's own jet propulsion laboratory was "flatly rejected," Mr. Whittaker said.

"You keep hammering on it till you get it," he said. "Things worth doing are never quick and they are never easy."

NASA’s initial development funding allowed Mr. Ford to travel to a crater in Utah, where he accidentally demonstrated exactly what the agency may be worried about.

"I showed them pictures of us standing on the edge of the pit, and they were like, 'Oh, my God, don't do that,'" he said. "Anytime you're getting near a pit, there's a pretty strong risk of falling in."

Of the 300 pits mapped by Arizona State University, fewer than a dozen seemed to be potential candidates for habitation, Mr. Ford said. "Most of them are not that interesting."

Advertise with us
Jordan Ford, a recent Carnegie Mellon University graduate student, peers over the edge of a pit in Utah with a robot designed to see if similar pits on the moon could be habitable for astronauts. span> (Courtesy of Jordan Ford)

Lacus Mortis, Latin for Lake of Death, is on the northeast side of the moon's Earth-facing side. Astrobotic's Peregrine lander was originally expected to touch down there. It is now aiming for the Gruithuisen Domes in the moon’s darkest spot, the Oceanus Procellarum, or Ocean of Storms.

Researchers say permanent human settlements on the moon will likely depend to some degree on the location of natural resources, especially frozen water, which appears to exist in permanently shadowed regions on the moon's south pole.

Astrobotic's second lander is targeting the south pole next year, carrying a NASA rover that will search for ice.

Mr. Ford said pits might also have permanently shadowed areas containing water ice, though that theory has not been proven. Future CMU students could answer that question if subsequent NASA funding comes through.

It's "absolutely inevitable" that humans will one day explore lunar pits, Mr. Whittaker said. The question is when.

Advertise with us

Recent billionaire investments in space exploration and the growing commercial space sector are improving the chances for pit discoveries, said Robert Wagner, a researcher at Arizona State who pioneered the mapping of lunar pits in 2014.

“With commercial missions there are a lot more opportunities to fly,” he said. “It’s likely that somebody will be interested to pay a commercial provider to go there.”

As opportunities emerge, the pool of pit researchers is also growing, leading to a variety of approaches.

A German team recently built an autonomous sphere-shaped robot packed with instruments that was designed to rappel into a lunar cave, then detach and roll around inside of it.

Evan Robinson-Johnson: ejohnson@post-gazette.com or @sightsonwheels