There's a growing cadre of computer users who want to save their Windows.

Many consumers are calling upon Microsoft to rethink its plans to retire Windows XP in favor of Vista, the current version of its operating system. The company had planned to pull Windows XP off store shelves in January, but then decided to continue retail sales through June. Now, however, a "Save XP" campaign has emerged, led by a technology journalist who felt that Microsoft should accommodate users who do not want to upgrade to Vista.

Galen Gruman posted a notice on the Web site of Infoworld, one of several computer magazines published by IDG, asking readers to sign a petition calling for Microsoft to continue selling and supporting Windows XP until the next version of Windows becomes available.

That was one week ago. As of Friday morning, that petition had garnered 164,817 signatures.

Advertise with us

Local IT execs and business owners say that, while they have not signed the petition -- some had not even heard of it -- they are taking their time in uprgrading to Vista, and sticking with XP for as long as they can.

Ken Doerbecker, founder and chief executive officer of Perfection Services Inc., a computer consultancy serving small businesses, said that there are several reasons why people are sticking with XP.

For starters, he said, "much of the application software might be specially written and come from a custom developer" who might not adapt it for Vista.

A second problem with Vista is a lack of drivers, the small software programs that enable devices such as printers or sound cards to work with a particular operating system. Drivers that work with Windows XP often do not work with Vista, and manufacturers have been slow to produce drivers specifically for Vista.

Finally, Vista has been described as a "resource hog," needing at least 3 gigabytes of memory to run well. With anything less, performance can be sluggish.

Advertise with us

Jinx Walton is director of computing services and systems development at the University of Pittsburgh. In that capacity she oversees some 7,000 university computers, as well as the provision of software for 32,000 students and 12,000 faculty and staff to use on their personal machines.

Vista accounts for about 60 percent of the software distributed to those students, faculty and staff in the past year, she said. But XP still runs about 70 percent of the university's computers. Pitt has no systemwide procedure for upgrading those machines, she said.

"It's up to individuals" to decide when they would like to upgrade, she said. "It's not even department-wide."

That being said, "We typically recommend that people hold off on upgrading ... to give us time to sort through any potential problems."

Mr. Doerbecker said that in a recent meeting with some 300 computer professionals who provide computer for small and medium sized businesses, a Microsoft representative asked how many were "actively recommending and installing Vistas on your accounts."

Advertise with us

"Only one of us raised his hand." Actually, "he kinda half raised it and took it back down again."

Christopher F. Hayes is among those who are not convinced about Vista. He is the vice president of information technology for Net Health Systems, Inc., a South Side-based provider of clinical information systems. He said that Net Health was an early adopter of Windows XP, installing it soon after its 2002 release. But not so with Vista.

"Our goal would be to stick with XP for as long as we can."

That is partly because of "the unfavorable response that the market has shown towards Vista," he said, but it is also because of a reluctance to upset a funcioning apple cart.

"We'd reather support one OS rather than multiple OSes," he said, "It's just easier for us to stick with what we've been doing securely until we have some to time to look into it."

Advertise with us

Dr. Ronald Meisberger, tecnology coordinator for the Pine-Richland School District, said that 60 percent of the district's 2,000 computers are Windows-based PCs, all of which run XP (the rest are Macs). While not familiar with the campaign, he said that he felt that Microsoft should continue supplying and supporting XP "at least until the bugs get worked out of Vista."

Users should be able to upgrade "as their enterprise operation allows, as opposed to being dictated to by the providers of the product," he said.

"For you to tell me you're no longer supporting my automobile that I'm driving, where does that leave me?" he said "I have to go out and buy a new car. I might not have the resources to do that."

The next version of Windows is slated for release in 2010, but Mr. Doerbecker said "the scuttlebutt of the industry is that the next version of Windows will be out by this time next year."

For those who are skeptical about Vista, but who need to buy new machines, Microsoft is offering a "downgrade" option. This option is not available on machines purchased from industry leaders such as Dell and HP; it is restricted to smaller computer companies, the so-called "white-box" computer sellers.

Advertise with us

With this option, the computer is sold as having Vista Business installed, but in fact, the machine is actually running XP Pro, and comes with a Vista CD included for future use.

Answer Computer Technology in Carnegie builds computers for "white-box" computer sellers. But head tech Keith Miller is not in the "save XP" camp. While the idea of holding on to an operating system because it is compatible with old software has a certain logic, he said "if you follow that logic we should all still be on DOS."

Mr. Miller said the big problem with Vista is that there are eight different versions of the OS, generating confusion in the marketplace: Home, Home Premium, Business, and Ultimate each have a 32-bit version and a 64-bit version. Since it has been nearly five years since AMD introduced the first 64-bit processor (July 2003), and no one makes 32-bit machines anymore, it may be time to leave 32-bit software behind.

"The software's following the hardware," he said.

For local tech execs, the bottom line regarding operating systems seems to be, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." As long as XP meets their needs, they intend to keep using it, while waiting for Vista to become more usable.

Advertise with us

"The longer you wait, the more new versions of software come out that more compatible, and peripherals," Mr. Doerbecker said. "It just gets better the longer you wait."

Unless a business is committed to maximizing the power of 64-bit processing, in which case it may be time to take a deep breath and plunge into Vista.

In any case, businesses that run their computers on XP should take advantage of Microsoft support of XP now because, petition or no petition, XP is definitely fading from the copmany's radar.

As Ms. Walton put it, "Microsoft is gonna do what Microsoft is gonna do ... they're really marching to their strategic plan, and not influenced as greatly as we like to think they are by users."