Since the Shell petrochemical complex in Beaver County began churning out plastic pellets in November 2022, it has generated a lot of emissions and a lot of emission data — more public data than any other facility in the region.
Some of that disclosure is required by the federal Clean Air Act; some, such as fenceline monitoring, was secured through agreements with environmental groups.
It’s how the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection knows that Shell has blown past its 12-month limit for smog-forming nitrogen oxide emissions every month since startup — yielding numerous notices of violations and a $10 million fine for pollution during its start-up period — but has stayed within permit parameters for hazardous air pollutants and volatile organic compounds since the fall of 2023.
It’s how the public knows, albeit sometimes weeks or months later, what was spewed out by the large flare that lights up the sky around Potter if there’s a malfunction at the plant.
Emissions data will form the basis of public meetings scheduled for March 19 and April 7 at Penn State Beaver as state environmental regulators weigh approval of some changes at the plant, and later as they consider Shell’s application for a major air permit under the federal Title V program.
It’s in this context that Shell, its state regulators, and an environmental group find themselves debating what actually constitutes emissions data.
Read More
‘Confidential and proprietary’
The Washington, D.C.-based Environmental Integrity Project routinely submits public records requests for files related to Shell’s plant, where liquid ethane is processed into lentil-sized polyethylene pellets, a feedstock for plastic products.
Last year, the Environmental Integrity Project asked for documents related to Shell’s flaring — it has several low pressure and high pressure systems designed to burn up unwanted gasses.
When the documents arrived, some data was redacted — namely, how much gas was flowing through the equipment, and what was in that gas.
Shell has argued in this and other cases that such data can be used by competitors to reverse-engineer its processes and design of the furnace.
The Environmental Integrity Project has argued that under the Clean Air Act, when emissions are calculated using formulas, what goes into those formulas is also emissions data and cannot be marked confidential.
“Shell is saying, ‘Trust us. We don’t have to show our work,’” said Lisa Hallowell, an attorney with EIP who argued before state Commonwealth Court on Wednesday during a hearing on the group’s appeal of the redactions.
Christina McKinley, an attorney with Blank Rome who represented Shell during the hearing before the full court, argued that emissions are “what comes out of the stack.”
“When we talk about what goes into the stack — process data, as Shell calls it — that’s not emission data,” she said.
When asked where in a complicated chemical plant one should draw the line between internal and external data, neither side wanted to answer.
“Shell’s position remains that each piece of information submitted to PADEP must be evaluated in context to ascertain whether it is emission data,” Shell spokeswoman Natalie Gunnell said in a follow-up email. “The information related to the appeal before the Commonwealth Court [on Wednesday] is not emission data, is confidential and proprietary and is entitled to protection.”
‘Chemicals is not where it needs to be’
If it seems like an argument over words, that obscures the context of the dispute.
Residents of Beaver County who are skeptical of Shell, or those who welcomed the plant but grew concerned after unfamiliar smells and noises and flares reflecting orange in the clouds, worry what secrets the global energy giant is hiding.
Even if they themselves won’t look at the redacted numbers, they feel uneasy about the fact that the numbers are being obscured.
Shell, whose chemical business is now the company’s problem child, has argued that it discloses a tremendous amount of data about its operations, including detailed monthly air emission reports, daily continuous air monitoring charts, and even the gas composition data at issue in case in hourly averages.
Shell is weighing what to do with the Beaver County plant and the rest of its chemicals business, which has facilities worldwide.
“Chemicals is not where it needs to be,” Shell’s CEO Wael Sawan said during the company’s Feb. 2 call with investors. “While we know where we want to go with it, we do not want to be selling at bottom-of-cycle conditions.”
As it explores potential opportunities, Mr. Sawan said the business segment will cut costs to “avoid the bleeding in free cash flow.”
McKinsey & Co., a global consulting firm, predicted in December that the global chemicals business may be in for a prolonged downturn, with too much capacity competing over thinning margins.
This is likely to come up during the public meetings scheduled over the next few weeks.
On March 19, the DEP and Shell will give a presentation on changes that Shell is making to its facility that will increase some emissions and decrease others.
Potential emissions of carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides would increase, but hazardous air pollutants and ammonia emissions would go down.
The meeting is being held in advance of the April 7 public hearing on the same proposal to give people in the region, designated as an environmental justice area, more time to be heard.
To register, email Emily Green, Southwest Regional Environmental Justice Coordinator at emgreen@pa.gov or call 412-442-4042 at least 24 hours before the hearings.
Correction: A previous version of this story had an incorrect date for the DEP public hearing. It is April 7.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.