April has been a good news/bad news month for Appalachian fossil fuel producers as the impacts of various tariffs and global economic gyrations work their way through corporate balance sheets and operating plans.

In the sigh-of-relief column is a much less aggressive plan to put tariffs on Chinese-made and Chinese-owned shipping vessels that transport a significant portion of Appalachian coal, gas and natural gas liquids to the rest of the world.

Such port fees — which could have arrested U.S. fossil fuel exports, producers warned — now have special carveouts for liquified natural gas tankers and for ships that arrive at U.S. ports “in ballast”, i.e. basically empty, in order to load American coal and chemicals for transport abroad.

In less welcome news for oil and gas producers, U.S. and China over the past few weeks have step-laddered their way into tariffs amounting to 145% on Chinese goods entering the U.S., and 125% of U.S. goods arriving in China.

Advertise with us

And, unlike the trade war that brewed during President Donald Trump’s first term, this time China did not exempt U.S. energy imports.

Ships and tariffs

The investigation into whether China has unfairly fostered its own shipbuilding industry to achieve a dominant position in the world began under the Biden administration in response to a petition by five labor unions. They argued that China has deliberately undercut competition in order to win market share, disadvantaging U.S. companies and their workers who would otherwise be building these large vessels.

Read More

The proof is in the pudding, they said. Where in 1999, less than 5% of the tons traveling globally were on Chinese-made ships, by 2023 that number was more than 50%. Nearly all new shipping containers in production are coming from China today.

In January, the U.S. Trade Representative issued a report agreeing with the labor unions.

The agency proposed assessing a $1.5 million fee for each instance of a Chinese-made or Chinese-owned vessel docking at a U.S. port.

Advertise with us

Even ships that were not made in China but were part of a fleet that also included Chinese-made vessels would be penalized under this proposal, which drew widespread alarm and opposition from shippers, exporters and importers.

“Every time our people travel internationally to promote U.S. energy exports, they get the same question — can we depend on the U.S.? This action tells the world that they cannot,” warned Enterprise Products Partners, a pipeline company that exported more than 70 million barrels of hydrocarbons in December 2024.

It’s not possible to shift this trade to U.S.-built or U.S.-flagged vessels, the company said. There are no U.S. vessels that can transport natural gas liquids or liquefied natural gas, it said. There aren’t even any shipyards in the U.S. capable of building a vessel that could carry LNG, Enterprise claimed.

“This action would inadvertently guarantee that there will be no ‘drill baby drill,’ ” the company wrote. “ ’The liquid gold’ under our feet would stay in the ground.”

Coal companies were similarly alarmed.

Advertise with us

During an appearance at the Washington County Chamber of Commerce earlier this month, Paul Lang, CEO of Core Natural Resources, said the proposed port tariffs were top of mind for the Canonsburg-based coal miner.

“This business is an export business now,” he said.

That’s what drove Mr. Lang’s former company, Arch Resources to merge with Consol Energy Inc. to form Core in January — “the logistics of the two companies [and] their ability to export coal.”

He said half of the bulk vessel fleet — the kind used to transport commodities like coal and grain — was built in China.

“The issue is, it’s not really targeting China,” said Ernie Thrasher, CEO of the Latrobe-based coal broker and shipper XCoal Energy & Resources, who warned of “catastrophic” consequences to coal mining regions if the port fees were enacted. “It’s targeting the U.S. companies shipping on those vessels.”

Advertise with us

The heat dissipated when the U.S. Trade Rep released a pared-down version of the tariff plan last week.

The new rule proposes a $150 per ton fee on Chinese-made and Chinese-owned vessels docking at U.S. ports, but it doesn’t penalize entire fleets, and it specifically excludes ships that come to the U.S. empty and load products to export. That effectively relieves coal of such duties.

Mr. Thrasher called the new rule “quite logical and practical.”

The rule also exempts LNG vessels from the tariff for three years and then requires an escalating portion of LNG to travel on U.S.-built ships, from 1% in 2028 to 15% in 2047.

The U.S. is the world’s largest LNG exporter.

Advertise with us

Natural gas liquids

It’s also among the top global suppliers of natural gas liquids, such as propane and ethane. These are components of the gas that comes out from the Marcellus and Utica shales in large swaths of this region. Companies don’t drill for them specifically. Instead, these molecules are separated from the gas stream and sold separately, increasingly to other countries that use them to make chemicals.

Since China’s reciprocal tariffs went into effect, propane prices dropped 15%, said Kristen Holmquist, a senior analyst with RBN Energy.

And while the majority of the propane and ethane headed to China come from producers in the Permian Basin in Texas and New Mexico, Ms. Holmquist noted that commodity markets are global. Moreover, the prices that Marcellus producers fetch for their liquids are pegged to what happens at the Gulf Coast trading hub.

“The producers in the Marcellus are more sensitive to the price of liquids than in the rest of the country,” she said.

That’s because they have the option to shift their production to areas with fewer liquids. If liquids prices collapse and the cost to extract them from the gas stream and sell them separately can’t be justified, they could leave some of them in the gas.

Advertise with us

Range Resources Corp., a Texas-based firm that is among the largest natural gas drillers in the Marcellus, was among the first to export natural gas liquids a decade ago when it signed a deal with the European chemical firm INEOS.

Today, about 80% of Range’s propane and butane is exported to Europe. It’s separated here, then fed into the Mariner East pipelines that take it to a facility near Philadelphia.

Asked about tariffs in general on a recent company call with analysts, Range’s CEO Dennis Degner noted this isn’t the first time a wrench has been thrown into an already cyclical business.

“We think regardless of how the tariff dust settles here in the weeks or months ahead, we see demand remaining relatively strong,” he said.

Chemical facilities abroad that rely on propane and ethane to make plastics — just as the Shell petrochemical plant in Beaver County uses Marcellus natural gas liquids as its feedstock — have built up capacity in recent years, Mr. Degner said. That global demand may be be redistributed by the tariffs, but he expects it won’t cease.