The wife of a man killed in an explosion at the Clairton Coke Works last year has filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Nippon Steel and two other entities.
Danielle Menefee, in a filing with the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas last week, alleges that negligence by Nippon Steel, MPW Industries and Valves, Inc. combined to cause the Aug. 11 blast that killed her husband, 52-year-old Steven Menefee.
Ms. Menefee’s lawsuit mirrors one filed a day earlier by Trisha Lynn Quinn, sister of Timothy Quinn, the other man killed in the explosion. Both lawsuits allege negligence and wrongful death.
The companies named in the filing could not immediately be reached for comment.
Mr. Menefee worked in the area near Batteries 13 and 14 as a heater — an operator responsible for the heating system that keeps the coke ovens running. That job, the lawsuit states, put him “in close proximity” to the failed valve that ultimately caused the blast.
The area between the batteries is what’s known as the “transfer area,” which housed two controls rooms, a break room and other employee space. The control rooms, called reversing rooms, are where operators worked during their shifts.
Read More
Beneath the transfer area is “the basement,” where piping that feeds the processed coke to the batteries is located. That piping includes a gas isolation valve, which is used to stop the flow of gas. The reversing rooms and breakroom, the lawsuit notes, were only about 10 to 20 feet above the basement. The lawsuit alleges that the setup violated industry guidance.
“These buildings were ordinary industrial structures providing weather protection and workspace — not blast-resistant structures designed to withstand explosions,” according to the filing.
Evaluation teams recommended in 2003 that U.S. Steel perform a study to determine whether the buildings were located a safe distance from any explosion hazards. The lawsuit alleges Clairton management rejected the recommendation by claiming the coke oven gas system was explicitly covered by an Occupational Safety and Health Administration regulation.
Even when OSHA updated its regulations 10 years later to specifically subject coke oven gas systems to that regulation, the lawsuit alleges, “the physical layout of Battery 13/14 remained unchanged.”
Nippon Steel, the lawsuit alleges, should have been aware of all of this when it finalized its acquisition of U.S. Steel in June 2025 — either through its own review of operations or through safety records.
Officials should have known that employees were working in buildings inside the blast zone — defined in the lawsuit as “the area subject to catastrophic overpressure and structural destruction in the event of a vapor cloud explosion” — but Nippon Steel continued business as usual in Clairton, according to the lawsuit.
The lawsuit also names Aliquippa-based Valves, Inc., which refurbished the gas isolation valve that failed in 2013. The company should have known, according to the lawsuit, that the valve needed to be replaced rather than refurbished.
MPW Industrial Services, a Hebron, Ohio-based company that provides industrial cleaning services, was contracted to flush residue from the valve at issue after a leak was discovered July 8. An outage was scheduled for Aug. 19 so MPW could perform the work, but MPW employees instead arrived at the facility Aug. 11 — the morning of the explosion. The lawsuit alleges the MPW employees had never been briefed on coke oven gas system hazards.
The lawsuit claims MPW employees failed to recognize several warning signs that something was going wrong. The gas isolation valve ruptured, according to the lawsuit, which ultimately led to the explosion.
“Walls collapsed, the roof was lifted and blown away, and structural elements disintegrated under the explosive overpressure,” according to the lawsuit. “[Steve Menefee] was consumed by the force of this explosion at close range, suffering … fatal smoke inhalation and burn injuries.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.