President Donald Trump is coming to the Pittsburgh region on Friday to hold a rally at U.S. Steel’s Irvin Works in West Mifflin.
He announced the visit on May 23 in a social media post that appeared to greenlight the long-proposed merger between U.S. Steel and Tokyo-based Nippon Steel.
Trump called it a “planned partnership” between the steelmakers and said the deal would keep U.S. Steel in America and its headquarters in Pittsburgh.
“This will be a planned partnership between United States Steel and Nippon Steel, which will create at least 70,000 jobs, and add $14 Billion Dollars to the U.S. Economy. The bulk of that Investment will occur in the next 14 months,” Trump wrote.
But in making the announcement, Trump left many questions unanswered — including whether the partnership was the acquisition Nippon has long sought, or simply a massive investment in the iconic Pittsburgh company by a foreign entity.
Nippon has always maintained it would not invest such huge sums of money without owning the assets.
Read More
“What I know to date is a lot of unknowns,” West Mifflin Mayor Chris Kelly said the day after the social media post.
As Trump plans to take the stage for his “BIG rally” at 5 p.m. Friday, here’s what we know:
What was the original deal for U.S. Steel?
In December 2023, U.S. Steel and Nippon announced the acquisition, valued at $14.9 billion. Both companies’ shareholders approved the deal.
Over time, as political opposition mounted, Nippon upped its investment pledges, saying it would spend increasing billions of dollars on existing U.S. Steel facilities.
The money, which stood at $11 billion as of last week to be spent over the next three years, will be invested in overhauling and modernizing existing facilities, not just in the Mon Valley but across the other states where U.S. Steel operates, including Indiana, Alabama, Arkansas and Minnesota.
Nippon has also reportedly vowed to spend at least $1 billion and up to $4 billion on a new steel mill with an electric arc furnace on a greenfield site yet to be determined.
How is that different from Trump’s ‘planned partnership’
That’s still unclear.
While Nippon had already committed to U.S. Steel having a board of directors with American citizens in the majority, Trump’s plan appears to involve the U.S. government owning a golden share in the company. That would give the government veto power over certain business decisions.
Further details have yet to emerge about what the president meant, creating a sense of uncertainty in the Mon Valley.
The language of “partnership” as opposed to “acquisition” harkens back to Trump’s comments earlier this year when he sought to reframe the relationship between Nippon and U.S. Steel.
“They've agreed to invest heavily in U.S. Steel, as opposed to own it,” Trump said in February.
In April, he reiterated the point during a news conference in the Oval Office. The president said he “rejected the deal,” adding: “Now, they’ve come back in a different form. They’re coming back as an investor.”
Trump then added: “I know the thinking ... they’ll invest and somebody else maybe is sitting in this chair and they will no longer have an investment — they’ll have the whole thing. You know, that’s the way it works. They’re very smart.”
Do the steelworkers support the deal?
The United Steelworkers union, which represents about 11,000 employees at U.S. Steel facilities, has long opposed the deal.
In a statement issued Wednesday, it appears little has changed among union leadership.
“We have received calls and messages from many of our members and local union leaders who do not support the merger asking what the rumored ‘partnership’ means,” the union said. “At this time, we cannot say whether the ‘planned partnership’ described in Friday’s message on Truth Social or news reports since then represents any meaningful change from the merger proposed in 2023, under which Nippon Steel would acquire U.S. Steel and make it a wholly owned subsidiary.
“Our core concerns about Nippon Steel — a foreign-owned corporation with a documented history of violating U.S. trade laws — remain as strong and valid today as ever, and that is so whether U.S. Steel and Nippon adhere to the same deal that they have pursued since December 2023 or whether they tweak the terms to satisfy concerns in Washington.”
Many rank-and-file workers have split from union leaders to support the deal, saying it’s the only way to ensure jobs stay in the Mon Valley.
In September, workers rallied Downtown in support of the deal, and some union members have traveled to Washington to personally lobby Trump and Vice President JD Vance for their support.
Do politicians support the deal?
On the campaign trail, Trump and former President Joe Biden, and then-Democratic candidate Kamala Harris all came out against the deal.
Mr. Biden blocked the deal in January after a review by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, or CFIUS, deadlocked over possible national security concerns.
Trump later ordered a second review. He posted his apparent approval of the deal the day after CFIUS’ deadline to submit its report. (CFIUS reports are not made public.)
Locally, a group of five Mon Valley mayors, who call themselves the “Fab Five,” strongly support the deal.
“I don’t know the straight details, but I will tell you that this is protecting over 11,000 jobs and it’s going to create another 14,000 jobs,” said North Braddock Mayor Cletus Lee, who called it an “awesome” achievement to keep U.S. Steel in the Mon Valley.
“We said ‘let’s get it done’ — it got done,” Braddock Mayor Delia Lennon-Winstead said, referring to a late-2024 advertisement she and four other Mon Valley mayors took part in to show support for the deal.
“U.S. Steel is Braddock, and Braddock is U.S. Steel, and I’m just so excited that it’s moving forward,” she said.
How did Nippon and U.S. Steel react to Trump’s announcement?
U.S. Steel issued a three-sentence statement that evening:
“President Trump is a bold leader and businessman who knows how to get the best deal for America, American workers and American manufacturing. U.S. Steel will remain American, and we will grow bigger and stronger through a partnership with Nippon Steel that brings massive investment, new technologies and thousands of jobs over the next four years.
“U.S. Steel greatly appreciates President Trump's leadership and personal attention to the futures of thousands of steelworkers and our iconic company.”
Nippon also used the word “partnership” in its statement.
“The partnership between Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel is a game changer,” Nippon said, “for U.S. Steel and all of its stakeholders, including the American steel industry and the broader American manufacturing base.”
Neither company expounded on the structure of the deal that Trump touted or what is meant by the word “partnership.”
With U.S. Steel and Nippon both public companies, neither has disclosed any changes to the shareholder-approved deal in which Nippon would buy all U.S. Steel stock at a price of $55 per share, take the company private and merge it into its U.S. subsidiary, Nippon Steel North America.
In a document that Nippon posted on Tuesday — in advance of its annual shareholder meeting later this month — the company said: “We continue to engage in discussions with the CFIUS and the United States government to obtain approval for the Merger.”
What is a ‘golden share’?
On Tuesday, Pennsylvania Sen. Dave McCormick said that the deal is “an investment and it’s a partial ownership, but it will be controlled by the U.S.A.”
It would also come with a golden share, “which will essentially require U.S. government approval of a number of the board members. And that will allow the United States to ensure that production levels aren’t cut,” he said during an interview on CNBC.
Golden shares have been granted to governments in places such as the U.K. and Brazil when national companies are being privatized. They typically restrict government approval to a specific set of business decisions, such as the sale of a substantial portion of assets or the transfer of sensitive technology.
“I don’t think this is a model for every transaction, but it could be a model for transactions that really affect our national security,” Mr. McCormick said. “In this particular case, it’s such a sensitive industry. The domestic steel industry is so important.”
The Japanese steelmaker has previously said it would not invest in U.S. Steel without the takeover it negotiated in December 2023, when it sealed the deal for a $55 per share buyout.
Nippon has not publicly commented on the possibility of a “golden share.”
Who will be at the rally?
Besides Trump, the “Fab Five” mayors will attend.
U.S. Steel’s CEO David Burritt and Nippon’s Vice Chairman Takahiro Mori are expected to speak, as well as local steelworkers.
Speeches begin at 3:30 with Trump expected at the podium at 5 p.m.
The White House has not issued a lineup of speakers and it’s not clear if Mr. McCormick or Sen. John Fetterman will be there.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.