Running an electric grid is essentially a math problem.
“And it’s not calculus. It’s just arithmetic,” said Tim Gallagher, president and CEO of Reliability First, a Cleveland-based organization that audits utilities and advises on grid reliability efforts.
“The supply of electricity has to exactly match the demand for electricity at all times, no exceptions.”
On the morning last month that Mr. Gallagher spoke inside Acrisure Stadium at an event organized by Pittsburgh Works Together, the city was a snow globe. Public schools were canceled.
Already, grid wonks buzzed with predictions for an upcoming nor’easter that PJM Interconnection, the grid operator for 13 states including Pennsylvania, said might break its all-time winter peak electricity demand record. (The record was broken on Jan. 22, uneventfully.)
PJM had a cushion between how much electricity customers needed that day and how much was at the ready. That cushion is expected to narrow later this decade as large new energy guzzlers come online — think data centers, manufacturing plants, electric vehicles — and more fossil fuel power plants come offline.
Read More
The grid warned there might be shortfalls as soon as two years from now.
“If we get back to that arithmetic problem,” Mr. Gallagher said, “if the demand side is going up, then the supply side should go up, right?
“That's not what's happening. We're not adding things as fast as we are taking them away.”
This has been the question preoccupying people who usually pay attention to grid dynamics — such as utility analysts and power plant operators — and those who typically don’t — including state governors, labor unions, and, increasingly, utility customers.
The question is: What is the right way to add more power to the grid?
Lawsuits and letters
Gov. Josh Shapiro has made this a recent focus. In December, he filed a complaint against PJM with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, charging that the grid operator wasn’t properly incentivizing more generation to get built and, in the meantime, allowing costs to increase for electricity consumers with nothing to show for it.
Two weeks later, Mr. Shapiro sent a letter to PJM’s CEO wondering why Pennsylvania shouldn’t leave the organization if it didn’t heed its calls for reform.
Mr. Shapiro was responding to the latest capacity auction that PJM ran in July.

The auctions work like this: PJM, which coordinates the flow of electricity between power makers and power takers within its territory, projects how much energy it might need to meet peak demand three years in the future. Power generators then bid to be available to provide that energy. Those who make the cut receive capacity payments, or retainer fees for promising to be at the ready. This is separate from the money they make selling electricity. Both costs are passed on to electricity consumers, with energy payments comprising a larger chunk than capacity payments. On a customer utility bill, both of these show up in the “price to compare” or generation charge.
The three-year-from-now timeframe is intended to be a forward-looking signal to power generators: If payments are high, it suggests generation is at a premium and would encourage building new plants; if payments are lower, less efficient and less economical generation might want to retire.
In recent years, however, PJM has been holding auctions much closer to the year that they are supposed to secure.
The July auction was for capacity between June 2025 to June 2026. That means electric utility customers in the PJM region will see their bills rise this summer to account for the record-breaking auction price of $269.92 per megawatt per day. The previous auction resulted in a $28.92 per megawatt per day price. For a power plant with a capacity of 1,000 megawatts — about the size of Tenaska’s natural gas power station in Westmoreland County — this year’s payment was around $28,100 per day, while next year’s will be nearly $270,000 per day. That’s the difference between $10 million a year and almost $100 million.
What it means for an electric consumer is less clear — but the costs will be passed through.
And when electric bills rise, consumers aren’t going to be calling PJM or the large power plants that scored in the capacity auction, said David Fisfis, vice president and general counsel at Downtown-based utility Duquesne Light.
“No, they’re calling Duquesne Light. And they’re calling their elected officials,” Mr. Fisfis said during the grid panel at Acrisure on Jan. 16.
In the breast pocket of his jacket was a folded-up copy of the governor’s letter to PJM.
Mr. Fisfis particularly liked the phrase “vast wealth transfer,” which is how Mr. Shapiro described the billions of dollars that utility customers in PJM’s grid would be paying to generators in the future if PJM didn’t agree to cap the price for the upcoming 2026-2027 year auction.
Last week, Mr. Shapiro said PJM assented to a cap of $325 per megawatt per day for the next two years.
The most recent auction spreads $14.7 billion in capacity payments across utility customers in PJM’s footprint.
But as Mr. Fisfis argued during the panel, his customers’ power won’t be any different this year than last year.
“Our customers are paying a lot of money and they’re not getting much for it” he said.
‘We’re all overreacting’
The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, which does not regulate power plants but does oversee electric utilities, held a conference in November to see how it could influence the discussion. The agency invited energy companies like Constellation, which plans to restart the Three Mile Island nuclear power station under a power supply deal with Microsoft, and officials from PJM, environmental groups, and utilities.
“We are all overreacting,” said Marjorie Philips, a senior vice president at LS Power Development LLC, when the conversation inevitably turned to high capacity prices.
“The market looked great when we were in excess,” she said. “Now everybody is trying to tinker with the rules because we’re in a shortage.”
But that’s the whole point, Ms. Philips argued. Power producers won’t build new generation without high prices that show it’s needed.
And sure, new power plants won’t spring up in the next year, she conceded. But generators that might have otherwise shut down could delay their exit, giving the grid more time to rebalance.
“We should not let panic drive the process,” another power producer, Invenergy, wrote in comments following the PUC meeting. “The ‘problem’ is the lack of capacity, not the price signal.”
Pennsylvania itself isn’t lacking power, it was noted during the conference. The state is a major exporter of electricity. If it were its own grid, it would be just fine.
“The question that we have to confront is how do we ensure that … Pennsylvania gets Pennsylvania’s energy first,” said Patrick Cicero at the PUC meeting in November. Mr. Cicero has since resigned as the state’s consumer advocate.
It’s not easy to build power plants anywhere these days — permitting is arduous, construction expensive, and the wait for a new steam turbine takes years, project developers say. Adding salt to the wound is the time it takes PJM to evaluate how proposed projects would impact the grid. Generation, mostly new solar projects, has been stuck in the PJM process for years.
Last month, PJM proposed to create a fast lane for 50 shovel-ready projects that could enhance the reliability of the grid, a step that many believe would favor new natural gas plants.
Mr. Shapiro is fan of the idea, too. Last week, he announced plans to form an energy-siting board to streamline the permitting process for energy projects. He is also proposing a Reliable Energy Investment Tax Credit that would make up to $100 million a year available to new projects for their first three years of operation.
Energy saving
Power generators aren’t the only ones that get paid for their contributions to the grid. A relatively small portion of the reserve that PJM secures during the capacity auction comes from demand response — that is, customers who agree to decrease or halt their electricity use if called upon.
Last year’s auction was a “tremendous windfall” for those participants, said Shawn Troxell, an account executive with CPower Energy, which aggregates demand response resources across the U.S.
Since the auctions and much about grid planning revolves around peak demand — predicting the very maximum load that could show up on the very busiest or coldest or hottest day of the year — conservation advocates have been pushing for curtailment to have a greater role in meeting those peaks.
Demand response programs have been around for years and are used mostly for economic reasons — to keep prices from spiking during high demand times.
But any energy user that can show it has the ability to curtail its electricity on demand can be a capacity resource and earn money for the promise. The grid hasn’t asked much of those that participate, Bill Oosterom, a sales director with CPower, said during a webinar last week.
Since 2011, there have been only five instances of PJM calling on demand response participants to lighten their load, two of them during a storm in 2022, CPower’s data showed.
“The reality is, most years it’s a pretty light lift to generate revenue,” he said.
It’s less politically appealing to emphasize that a grid can be held together by those promising not to use it than by boasting of ample, reliable generation that doesn’t require behavior changes in times of stress.
Both are needed, but only one typically gets the attention.
“There’s a lot that can be done with what we have today,” Jeaneen Zappa, executive director of the Keystone Energy Efficiency Alliance, told the PUC during its meeting in November.
“I almost feel like I’m at a conference for people who [run] gyms, and everyone is saying, ‘Buy more machines,’ and I’m saying, ‘Do more reps. Do more energy efficiency reps.’”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.