President-elect Donald Trump is unlikely to reverse President Joe Biden’s decision earlier this month to block the sale of Pittsburgh’s U.S. Steel to Japan’s Nippon Steel, several trade experts said, though a fresh campaign to woo the Republican is starting to take shape.

“It's been an ongoing discussion,” U.S. Rep. Dan Meuser said in an interview with the Post-Gazette. “And now we're at a point where the offer (by Nippon) is the best I think it's ever been.”

The Pennsylvania Republican called Mr. Biden’s Jan. 3 decision to block the deal “politically motivated” and damaging to Pennsylvania and American steel, adding, “We hope President Trump can save U.S. Steel for the second time and have Japan pay for it.”

But it remains unclear what it would take to change the incoming president’s mind — and many are skeptical.

Advertise with us

Judge Glock, research director at The Manhattan Institute, said blocking the foreign acquisition of the iconic Pittsburgh-based steelmaker would “probably fall in line with a lot of Trump's overall goals of protecting domestic industry.”

“I see little likelihood that he would reverse that decision,” he said, “especially if he's also going to be simultaneously talking about tightening the tariffs on steel.”

Many Trump advisers for his second White House term are anti-deal, said William Chou, a Japan expert at the Hudson Institute, a Washington think tank that hosted union workers from U.S. Steel last fall.

“This is also just something that's more controversial than he would like to deal with, given his other priorities,” Mr. Chou said. “So I'm sure that he'll be glad that Biden has taken this off his lap.”

‘Things will move faster’

Still, a fresh campaign to change Trump’s mind began in earnest last weekend, though both companies had also tried to sway him last year on the campaign trail.

Advertise with us

Some workers who campaigned for Trump had tried to convince him that Japanese investment was good for their job security, an argument that was bolstered earlier this month when Nippon promised to preserve steel capacity for 10 years, with any cuts subject to government approval.

“The 10-year work guarantee is huge for us,” said Glenn Thomas, a 26-year employee at the Edgar Thomson Works in Braddock. “I think that the chances are pretty high that [Trump] reverses the decision. It will take some time to sort out the lawsuits (but) after he is inaugurated things will move faster.

“The majority of the rank and file in the Mon Valley will definitely lobby for that.”

On Monday, Nippon Steel’s vice chairman, Takahiro Mori, met with workers at U.S. Steel Irvin Works and strategized at the home of West Mifflin Mayor Chris Kelly, hoping to keep a yearlong campaign alive.

There was cake and a spirit of optimism, workers said. Mr. Kelly agreed to rally mayors who had previously written to Mr. Biden to arrange a meeting with Trump, either at Mar-A-Lago in Florida or in Washington.

Advertise with us

“I’ll go anywhere,” he told the Post-Gazette.

While workers and others move on Trump, lawmakers may take aim at the regulatory review that preceded Mr. Biden’s block.

The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States — a federal panel created to screen deals for national security risks and deliver a recommendation to the president — punted the decision last month to President Biden after it failed to reach a consensus on the deal’s national security threats. Mr. Biden then blocked the deal, citing national security concerns.

Mr. Meuser, who previously said the review of Nippon’s acquisition was “subordinated to political interests,” was named chairman of the financial services committee’s oversight and investigations subcommittee on Thursday — newly empowering him to pursue those concerns.

“CFIUS will come under our scrutiny as to how it operates, how it comes to its conclusions, and if there's been persuasion on this deal and others from the current White House,” Mr. Meuser told the Post-Gazette.

Advertise with us

‘Focused on other issues’

Trump, who first came out against the $14.9 billion transaction last February, has said little about Mr. Biden’s decision other than to suggest steel tariffs would be enough to make the Pittsburgh company great again. Workers in Pennsylvania immediately pushed back against that assertion, arguing that direct investments are needed to modernize dated facilities in the Mon Valley.

Without the Japanese investment, U.S. Steel has signaled that it would be forced to abandon Pennsylvania — a position disputed by the United Steelworkers union and some analysts who point out the company has relatively strong financials.

Trump’s new appointees are expected to support an aggressive tariff agenda that will further promote domestic industry, and not necessarily foreign investment, officials in his former administration said.

Still, the president-elect has welcomed investment from Japan’s Softbank and promised to clear red tape for other foreign deals.

Trump also changed his stance on TikTok, the Chinese social media platform that he previously said threatened national security but now sees as a “unique medium for freedom of expression.” The app is poised to be banned in the U.S. unless the Supreme Court tosses it a lifeline.

Advertise with us

At an Oct. 15 event at the Economic Club of Chicago, Mr. Trump appeared to provide an opening, suggesting he might not block the deal with Nippon if it was finalized by the time he took office. “I would stop it if it hasn’t been completed by the time I’m president,” he said.

But in December, a month after winning the election, he repeated a vow to block the sale.

Mr. Chou of the Hudson Institute said the only way Trump would take a second look is if the companies are able to win their appeal in court, forcing a second regulatory review. Japanese officials quickly came out against Biden’s decision, but Mr. Chou doesn’t expect that pressure to continue either.

“They will be focused on other issues with the Trump administration,” he said.

The impact of tariffs

Republicans, meanwhile, already are lining up to support Trump’s “America First” strategy, which some trade groups describe as reversing a trend of the U.S. sacrificing its own economy to foreign policy objectives.

Advertise with us

“He's been pretty robust that what we have to do is defend U.S. industry,” said Jeff Ferry, chief economist at the Coalition for a Prosperous America, a group that supports trade restrictions. “And it may not be what some of the steel workers at U.S. Steel want to hear today, but what that means is we need to keep it American.”

“U.S. Steel cannot and should not be sold,” Mr. Ferry said. “So I don't see this changing.”

Mr. Glock of The Manhattan Institute countered that Trump’s tariffs would likely further a trend of protectionism that will not make U.S. Steel more competitive.

“If there's one thing we've learned over the last 50, 60 years of international economic history, it’s that protecting companies from international competition does not make them more efficient, it makes them more incapable of facing the rest of the world,” he said.

Pennsylvania Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, a Westmoreland County Republican, made a similar argument.

Advertise with us

“Trump is saying he wants to make U.S. Steel great again. He is going to have some incentives through policy and tariffs, but it does require investment. It requires more,” she said.

Mike Pompeo, Trump’s former secretary of state, acknowledged that “tariffs might achieve an outcome that was something akin to” Nippon’s proposed investment, but said the “most direct way” to protect the industry is “just to let this move through.”

Nippon Steel hired Mr. Pompeo to lobby in support of the deal last summer, but Trump did not offer him a Cabinet position this term.

A handful of Republicans share the hope that Trump will reconsider, including Sam DeMarco, who on Tuesday announced he will leave Allegheny County Council to become Sen. Dave McCormick’s southwestern Pennsylvania regional director after five years as chair of the county’s Republican committee. Mr. DeMarco urged the incoming president on Friday to “do better by the men and women of Western Pennsylvania’s legacy industries.”

Democrats were split on the transaction, and those who supported it appeared to be less influential than United Steelworkers union President David McCall.

Advertise with us

U.S. Sen. John Fetterman, a Democrat who lives across the street from U.S. Steel’s Edgar Thomson Works in Braddock, was scheduled to meet with Trump in Mar-A-Lago this weekend. He has been a staunch opponent of the sale to Nippon, siding instead with Mr. McCall.

Dick Gephardt, the former Missouri congressman and U.S. Steel board member who was brought in by Nippon to try to sway Mr. McCall last year, said he does not expect his voice to carry in the new administration.

“I don't think Donald Trump is going to listen to me or be interested in what I have to say,” he told the Post-Gazette this week.

So far, U.S. Steel CEO Dave Burritt and Nippon’s vice chairman, Takahiro Mori, have not met with the president-elect. Some steelworkers said they could play to his ego by arguing that Mr. Biden made the wrong call.

“The president can step in now and undo the wrongful, shameful, corrupt actions of Biden,” Mr. Burritt said Tuesday on CNBC.

But he acknowledged it will be an uphill battle: “We understand what his current views are, but he’s a smart guy. He has the opportunity to have fresh eyes and do what’s right, and I believe strongly he will.”