Twenty miles upstream of Pittsburgh, in a community known as the “city of prayer,” steelworkers in Clairton have spent the past year praying for closure on the embattled U.S. Steel takeover by Japan’s Nippon Steel.

As presidential hopefuls vowed to keep the once-dominant Pittsburgh steel company in American hands, workers increasingly wondered whether they’d be better off with the Japanese suitor who promised job security, plant improvements — even a $5,000 bonus for every worker once the deal closed.

But on Friday, President Joe Biden dashed that prospect, blocking Nippon’s $14.9 billion proposal over what he said was a threat to national security. The president’s decision came after top government officials tasked with vetting foreign investment could not agree on the level of risk Nippon posed.

It marks the first time a president has ever used such authority to derail a deal with an American ally and signals the remarkable influence of the United Steelworkers union, whose Cleveland-based leader refused to concede to Japan.

Advertise with us

The proposed merger, announced in December 2023, would have made for a globally competitive steelmaker with access to Japanese technology and an American market buoyed by the Biden administration’s infrastructure spending.

The operation would also have threatened Cleveland-Cliffs, a competitor in Ohio, which lobbied against the deal.

As news of the presidential block started to spread through the mills early Friday, workers who had come to support Nippon began to worry about the future.

“The more I learned the more I changed my mind — it was the same for the vast majority of my coworkers,” said Bob Rudnik, 41, a steelworker at U.S. Steel Irvin Works. “If we were named anything else but U.S. Steel, this deal would have been approved months ago.“

Mr. Rudnik said Irvin “desperately” needs a new hot mill, which Nippon had promised to fund. Without the investment, he said, “I’ll be surprised if we make it past next contract” which expires in September 2026.

Advertise with us

In announcing the block, Mr. Biden said it was his “solemn responsibility” to ensure that the U.S. has a strong, American-owned steel industry.

“It is a fulfillment of that responsibility to block foreign ownership of this vital American company. U.S. Steel will remain a proud American company,” he said Friday morning in a White House statement. “We need major U.S. companies representing the major share of U.S. steelmaking capacity to keep leading the fight on behalf of America’s national interests.”

In a joint statement Friday morning, U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel said company officials were “dismayed” by Mr. Biden’s decision and again signaled that they intend to challenge the block legally.

“Blocking this transaction means denying billions of committed investment to extend the life of U.S. Steel’s aging facilities and putting thousands of good-paying, family-sustaining union jobs at risk,” the statement read. “We believe that President Biden has sacrificed the future of American steelworkers for his own political agenda.”

Mr. Biden’s move is a broad blow to a key ally in Japan as he sided with top union leadership who have encountered growing pushback from workers rallying in support of the Japanese steelmaker’s bid.

Advertise with us

The fate of thousands of workers in Western Pennsylvania now hangs in the balance, as U.S. Steel has said it would not invest in the region’s dated Mon Valley Works without the takeover, and could move jobs, mills and the company headquarters out of Pittsburgh.

“Without this deal with Nippon Steel, we will be the last generation to work here at this historic steel plant,” Brian Pavlack, a third-generation steelworker in Clairton said at a rally supporting the deal last month.

But union leadership opposed the deal from the start. And on Friday, they applauded Mr. Biden’s decision.

“Without domestic steel production and domestic steel workers, our nation is less strong and less secure,” the United Steelworkers said in a statement. “Now that President Biden blocked the deal, we can and must focus on the future.”

What that future looks like is wildly uncertain.

Advertise with us

‘Harming our company’s future’

Since the deal was first announced in December 2023, it has faced constant political opposition from Mr. Biden, President-elect Donald Trump and members of Western Pennsylvania's congressional delegation.

But support began to mount, driven in part by multiple Nippon concessions and investment pledges, and goodwill tours by Nippon Steel vice chairman Takahiro Mori.

West Mifflin Mayor Chris Kelly, who represents the community around U.S. Steel’s Irvin Works, emerged as a key Nippon supporter who welcomed Mr. Mori into his home and mobilized other mayors throughout Pennsylvania.

On Friday morning, he woke up before 1 a.m. to learn that Mr. Biden planned to block to sale.

“I'm really disappointed that our communities are going to suffer because of politics,” he said. “High profile individuals said this is not a national threat ... it comes down to the international [union] ties with the current administration, so it's sad that this is the route that's developed.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kelly said he struggled to understand the president’s conclusion that foreign investment would somehow hurt the domestic sector.

“The deal that Nippon put on the table created more jobs, it created cleaner energy — everything was positive. ... And just to turn your backs on it, without further discussion or talk to the people that it's affecting? The people that supported President Biden and his agenda deserve better.”

Mr. Kelly, who noted that many Western Pennsylvania communities are already underserved, was particularly angered that Mr. Biden seemed out of touch with local sentiment.

“I know the president can't go everywhere. I understand that, and it's a multi-task job every day, but somebody from his administration could have come out here and talked to the workers,” he said.

Other responses were less forgiving.

Advertise with us

“President Biden’s action today is shameful and corrupt,” U.S. Steel CEO Dave Burritt said in a statement posted to social media site X. “He gave a political payback to a union boss out of touch with his members while harming our company’s future, our workers, and our national security.

“The Chinese Communist Party leaders in Beijing are dancing in the streets. And Biden did it all while refusing to meet with us and learn the facts. … We intend to fight President Biden’s political corruption.”

A competitor in Cleveland gets involved

Mr. Biden’s opposition to the deal was initially viewed as a bid to win union votes, but has emerged as a decision driven by a complex picture of personal loyalties and a belief in a protectionist “Made in America” policy that experts say signals an expanded view of presidential authority to block foreign investment.

“There’s not any public information to indicate that there’s a legitimate national security issue, or at least one that can’t be mitigated comfortably,” said David Plotinsky, a former Department of Justice official charged with reviewing foreign investment, in an interview before the decision was announced.

“If the White House blocks, I think it’ll be based on a genuine, sincerely held policy view by Joe Biden, based on years of very close relationships with the union.”

Advertise with us

Because of the president’s direct influence over the regulatory review that took place during a contested election year, some experts said Nippon and U.S. Steel could have legal standing to argue that the verdict was politically motivated.

Members of Congress with direct oversight of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the U.S. — a federal panel known as CFIUS that was created to screen deals for national security risks and deliver a recommendation to the president — are considering a probe along similar lines, although challenges to the committee are rare and almost always unsuccessful.

“Unlike virtually every other regulatory review that exists in the United States, because CFIUS is under national security authorities, there are very few remedies for the parties if they think that CFIUS has come to a bad substantive conclusion,” said John Kabealo, a Washington attorney who has represented clients before the committee.

The proposed deal came after a bidding war last year sparked by Ohio-based competitor Cleveland-Cliffs.

U.S. Steel in August 2023 said that it received “multiple, credible bidders” for the company, and that it had turned down Cleveland-Cliffs’ $7.3 billion takeover bid.

Advertise with us

A second all-cash bid from privately held Sewickley-based Esmark Inc. soon followed; interest was also reported from ArcelorMittal, a Luxembourg-based multinational, and Charlotte, N.C.-based Nucor Corp.

In December 2023, Nippon and U.S. Steel announced their deal, which included an agreement for an all-cash transaction of $55 per share, representing an equity value of approximately $14.1 billion plus the assumption of debt, for a total value of $14.9 billion. The transaction was unanimously approved by the boards at Nippon and U.S. Steel.

Cleveland-Cliffs opposed the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon with fiery public statements, meetings with key regulators and behind-the-scenes lobbying, which some experts said was surprisingly effective.

The union had exclusively backed Cliffs during the 2023 bidding process for U.S. Steel, and Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves continued to use that as leverage to try to unravel the deal with Nippon in 2024.

Union President David McCall, meanwhile, refused to negotiate with the Japanese steel company’s executives and remained unmoved by every pledge and commitment. The United Steelworkers backed Mr. Biden in both of his races for president — including in 2024, just days after he came out against the U.S. Steel-Nippon deal.

Advertise with us

Had U.S. Steel accepted Cliffs’ offer in 2023, the joint company would have been one of the few suppliers to Detroit automakers such as General Motors and Ford, sparking monopoly concerns. It also would have consolidated the United Steelworkers union, which represents 14,000 Cliffs employees and 11,000 at U.S. Steel.

‘This matter is far from over’

County Executive Sara Innamorato, who has not spoken publicly about the deal since she took office, initially declined to comment Friday because the county regulates U.S. Steel for air quality and is involved in lawsuits against the company.

She later released a statement calling for “a path forward for steel operations in the Mon Valley.”

“Ownership should invest in the workers and honor the collective bargaining agreements now and in the future; be a good community partner with the residents of the Mon Valley, and work with county and local government to build a future where everyone can thrive; and invest in new technologies and infrastructure on site to modernize the campus, put local people to work, and improve air quality,” she said.

Gov. Josh Shapiro, who never publicly endorsed the deal, said a new plan must be put in place to ensure job security for the workers at U.S. Steel.

Advertise with us

“I expect U.S. Steel to uphold their commitments to Western Pennsylvania, refrain from threatening the jobs and livelihoods of the Pennsylvanians who work at the Mon Valley Works and at U.S. Steel HQ and their families, and work collaboratively to ensure the future of American steelmaking takes place right here in our Commonwealth,” he said in a statement.

“I also expect any other potential buyers to demonstrate the strong commitments to capital investment and protecting and growing Pennsylvania jobs that Nippon Steel placed on the table during my continued dialogue with their leadership.

“This matter is far from over — we must find a long-term solution that protects the future of steelmaking in Western Pennsylvania and the workers who built U.S. Steel and built this country.”

Lt. Gov. Austin Davis said he lived through the historic collapse of the steel industry in Western Pennsylvania “while leaders in Washington did nothing,” and that he fears it’s happening again.

"That is unacceptable,” he said. "Now that President Biden has blocked this deal, we need to find a long-term plan for keeping steel production in the Mon Valley and protecting Pennsylvania workers' livelihoods. No more statements and fired-off social media posts — the workers and their families need to hear a plan.”

Advertise with us

The Japanese steelmaker said that it had a plan — and that its investment would bolster the domestic sector.

The fourth-largest global producer of steel promised $2.7 billion in facility upgrades, including at least $1 billion in Western Pennsylvania. It pledged not to cut jobs and to keep headquarters in Pittsburgh.

The only certainty now is that the next phase of the controversial merger will likely be played out in a courtroom.

Madaleine Rubin, Steve Bohnel and Hallie Lauer contributed to this report.