Some Allegheny County Council members said Friday they were concerned about the long-term economic health of the Mon Valley, after President Joe Biden announced he was blocking a merger of U.S. Steel with Nippon Steel because of national security concerns.

Council Member Bob Macey, a Democrat who represents District 9 — which includes the Mon Valley and multiple U.S. Steel facilities — said he is worried  U.S. Steel might leave the region if the merger doesn’t happen.

Mr. Macey said that Mr. Biden is living in the past and not acknowledging a global economy, including for steel production. U.S. Steel’s board of directors has to consider not only employees but company shareholders, and that means a move elsewhere in the country is possible, he added.

That means not only the loss of more than 3,000 jobs in the Pittsburgh region, but a huge blow to contractors and vendors, and also local businesses that rely on the workforce in the Mon Valley and nearby, he said.

Advertise with us

“If their whole program is to destroy the Mon Valley and the Pittsburgh region, then they’ve done a good job at this,” Mr. Macey said of the president’s decision.

Council President Patrick Catena, a Democrat, said he also had concerns about Mr. Biden’s decision.

Mr. Catena said Japan is an ally and he was comfortable with the provisions in place under Nippon. If the merger doesn’t happen, he worries whether there are viable alternatives from the federal and state government.

“What is the Plan B to save steel in the Mon Valley?” Mr. Catena said.

At-large Council Member Sam DeMarco said: “It is sad that the final act of the Biden administration is the abandonment of an industry and workforce that built the nation. Our last hope is that incoming President Donald Trump will do better by the men and women of Western Pennsylvania’s legacy industries.”

Advertise with us

The debate on whether to support the merger with Nippon divided county council in 2024. In June, Mr. Macey and Mr. Catena both opposed a resolution that would have stated that council opposed a merger of U.S. Steel with Nippon.

In an 8-6 vote, those two members were joined by Mr. DeMarco, Suzanne Filiaggi, Dan Grzybek, Bethany Hallam, Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis, and Anita Prizio, in opposing the resolution. Jack Betkowski, David Bonaroti, Nicholas Futules, John Palmiere, Robert Palmosina, and DeWitt Walton voted to support it. Paul Klein was absent.

The resolution had no practical effect, but it showed where council members stood on the proposed merger. Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato said in a statement Friday that the merger decision lies with the federal government’s jurisdiction, but that she would work with whoever owns U.S. Steel to invest in Mon Valley communities.

“Ownership should invested in the workers and honor the collective bargaining agreements now and in the future; be a good community partner with the residents of the Mon Valley, and work with county and local government to build a future where everyone can thrive; and invest in new technologies and infrastructure on site to modernize the campus, put local people to work, and improve air quality,” the county executive said.

In January, Mr. DeMarco, a Republican, and Mr. Walton, a Democrat who worked for the United Steelworkers of America, debated the merger at length.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeMarco said he supported the merger with Nippon because of the investments the Japanese company would make in facilities, including modernizing them so there was less environmental impact. He added that workers would be in a better position in future years because of Nippon’s larger size and better fiscal outlook.

But Mr. Walton said he was concerned about Nippon’s commitment to union workers, and what would happen when the current contract with union members terminates. Mr. Walton added that U.S. Steel would be sold or merged with some company to maintain operations, but that under the pending agreement with Nippon, the company had no obligation to honor collective bargaining agreements or pension plans.

Mr. Walton’s argument convinced Mr. Futules, a Democrat who represents much of the Allegheny-Kiski Valley, to support the resolution opposing the deal.

Mr. Futules said that, like other members, he relied on Mr. Walton’s knowledge of the company and the industry, given that the latter worked for the United Steelworkers for nearly three decades. Protections for workers, whether it be annual raises or other provisions, are important when a collective bargaining agreement expires, he said.

But he added that he shares Mr. Macey and Mr. Catena’s concerns that U.S. Steel could leave the region if some assistance or deal doesn’t happen. When the steel industry declined in Pittsburgh about 40 years ago, it took decades for communities like Homestead and Braddock to start recovering, Mr. Futules said.

Advertise with us

“I would hate to see this place close down in the next couple of years because of this. Because they could move south very easily, and leave the Mon Valley,” Mr. Futules said.

This story was updated to include comments from Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato.