Inside U.S. Steel’s mills on Friday, ideas for the company’s future ranged from hedge funds buying up assets to a fractured sale to domestic competitors.
At the company’s Downtown headquarters, however, the conversation remained squarely on plans for litigation.
“The complaint’s ready to go,” a top investor said.
After losing in the court of public opinion, Nippon Steel will now have to try its case in an actual court to save its embattled takeover of U.S. Steel. Its argument will hinge on allegations that political interference compromised a regulatory review of the $14.9 billion transaction, which was announced in December 2023. President Joe Biden blocked the deal Friday, citing national security issues that some experts said could have been mitigated easily.
The companies will also try to sway Donald Trump, who has repeatedly said he opposes the deal, adding to the list of Biden executive orders for the president-elect to overturn after his inauguration Jan. 20.
But the legal case is more pressing.
Read More

U.S. Steel’s board planned to vote on litigation this weekend, and a lawsuit could be filed as early as Monday, according to two people familiar with the plan.
“We intend to fight President Biden’s political corruption,” CEO David Burritt said in a statement Friday.
‘Bad for the Pittsburgh economy’
In court, the companies could claim that the Committee for Foreign Investment in the United States — a federal panel known as CFIUS that screens deals for national security risks and delivers a recommendation to the president — denied them of their right to due process by not allowing for a full exchange of information.
That argument won a rare appeal for a Chinese company in 2014 whose purchase of American wind farms was blocked by President Barack Obama. That case, one of the only examples of litigation with the committee, ended in a settlement.
“It's possible that we would never get to a decision in this situation, either,” said Alexis Early, an attorney who advises companies on foreign investment and regulation. “There's riper fruit in the litigation context against CFIUS here than in usual cases. But there are also a lot of ways that this could get buried in process.”
Before her career in law, Ms. Early had a front row seat to steel’s demise in the 1980s.
The Pennsylvania native saw the foundry where her parents met shuttered and the aluminum plant where her father worked sold for parts. U.S. Steel could now be destined for a similar fate, she said.
“It's unfortunate the way the executive branch — the committee, the White House — have handled this,” she said. “None of this is improving U.S. economic security.”

It also doesn’t come as a complete surprise. Growing up in the early 1980s, Ms. Early said she remembered Japanese businessmen coming to central Pennsylvania looking to buy various steel facilities. “And there were protectionist concerns then,” she said.
Now a partner at a major Washington firm, Ms. Early is in touch with the broader Japanese investment community that has absorbed the U.S. Steel saga as a cautionary tale.
“I could foresee them making fewer investments, or making smaller investments, or making passive investments, where they can't bring their technological insight to bear to collaborate. And that would be bad for the Pittsburgh economy,” she said.
Lawyers rarely advise clients to appeal national security determinations, given how classified the decisions can be. But the review of Nippon’s takeover was atypical by all accounts — influenced by public statements from Mr. Biden and other officials, as well as by a series of leaks that thrust agency disagreements into the spotlight, experts said.
“If ever there were a case where the parties could mount a meaningful challenge on both procedural and substantive grounds, this would be it,” said John Kabealo, a Washington attorney who advises foreign companies on regulatory reviews.

Heads down, back to work
In the meantime, an uncertain workforce plans to get back to work.
“If I knew what the next steps were, for sure I’d tell you how I feel, but as of right now I just continue to go to work and it’s business as usual,” said Troy Stephenson, a 27-year employee at U.S. Steel’s Irvin Works.
That’s what they did in September, when a Labor Day promise to oppose the deal from the Democrat presidential candidate, Vice President Kamala Harris, triggered a Downtown rally the next day that ended minutes before Mr. Biden’s plan to block the deal was leaked.
Intense efforts since then to change his mind were ineffective, and some blamed Pennsylvania officials for not doing enough.
“If ever there were a poignant example of the decline of civic leadership in Pittsburgh, this is it,” said Mark DeSantis, a former Washington lobbyist-turned-entrepreneur who sold his own Pittsburgh startup to a Japanese firm this year.
When the deal was reached in December 2023, Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey called it “a betrayal” of the workers who built America. Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato declined to take a public stance, as did Gov. Josh Shapiro. State Sen. Wayne Fontana, a Democrat whose district covers most of Pittsburgh, finally spoke out in support of the deal the day before Mr. Biden’s block.
Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, a Westmoreland County Republican who had chided the Democratic governor for not taking a firmer stance on the deal, said Friday that it was time to move past finger pointing and work together to protect Pennsylvania jobs.
“We have to fix this,” she told the Post-Gazette. “I'm hoping that President Trump takes a second look at this — at the concessions to the union — because they've changed so much since when this first started.”
Nippon Steel promised to “protect and grow” U.S. Steel with $2.7 billion in plant upgrades and a 10-year production capacity commitment that could be enforced by the federal government.
On Friday, Ms. Ward acknowledged that might not be enough to flip Trump. But she said she plans to emphasize to him the need for investment in Pennsylvania.
“It’s a scary prospect of three or four years down the road all these jobs disappearing,” she said. "I'm going to do my best to try to gather the right people and ask for an opportunity to work with the Trump administration.”
That could include a collaboration with Pennsylvania’s newest Republican in Congress, Sen. David McCormick. State leaders may have other tools to keep jobs here, too, such as the Department of Community and Economic Development, the governor’s action team, and tax incentives.
"I don't think it's too late,” Ms. Ward said. “I think that we just have to pull up our bootstraps and explore every possible avenue to keep U.S. Steel in Pittsburgh. We're going to keep fighting.”
Making U.S. Steel great again?
The United Steelworkers union said it stands ready to scrutinize new suitors and remains confident a stable balance sheet will be enough to keep operations afloat. Mr. Shapiro said he expects other potential buyers to put up the same commitments as Nippon Steel. He warned U.S. Steel to “refrain from threatening the jobs and livelihoods” of Pennsylvania steelworkers and committed to “work collaboratively” to keep the industry here.
Mr. Biden said that blocking Japan’s investment means “U.S. Steel will remain a proud American company.” More than 100 new steel and iron mills have opened in the U.S. since he took office, he said, without stating how many were built by American companies.

In the past year alone, Japan’s Softbank propped up a new autonomous vehicle company in Pittsburgh with a $1 billion investment, while Mr. DeSantis sold his artificial intelligence startup to the Japanese tractor maker Kubota. Nippon owns and operates existing steel mills in Pennsylvania and West Virginia, and other Japanese companies own joint stakes in several companies, including a defense contractor that powers American fighter jets.
If Mr. Biden’s decision stands, it would send a message to other domestic steel companies that they may have a limited number of buyers, research analyst Gordon L. Johnson said.
“They won't allow outside guys to come in and participate. That's bad for evaluations,” he said.
Mr. Johnson said there’s still hope that Trump could reverse the decision, and that U.S. Steel could try to force his hand by announcing plant shutdowns and job cuts.
“Some people think Trump will come in and save everything,” said Richard Tikey, vice president of the USW local in Clairton. “He said that he wants to make U.S. Steel great again.”
Trump doesn’t have the same pressure of USW loyalty as Mr. Biden, and many of the union workers who supported the deal also support the president-elect. They tried to change his mind on the campaign trail but were seemingly unsuccessful, as Trump put out a new statement of opposition in December.
While Vice President-elect JD Vance has warned that foreign investors are essentially “tariff jumping” by buying their way into the American market, others see such deals as proof that protectionist measures are working. Either way, the Biden administration appears to have lost an opportunity to control the same industry it vowed to be protecting.
“If you want to have government intervention and industrial policy to promote domestic steel capacity, the way to do that was through the mitigation agreement and approving a transaction,” said Geoffrey Gertz, a former White House official now at the Center for a New American Security.
“By taking that off the table, you now no longer have the tools of industrial policy, and you're left with the vagaries of the open market, which point towards bankruptcy for U.S. Steel."






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.