Tom Casciola began Cecil’s fourth oil and gas ordinance hearing with a piece of advice he received on his first day as township supervisor, some 31 years ago.

“Zoning is to protect me from you,” a colleague told him. “My rights to use my property to its fullest have to be contained on my property. My rights don’t extend past my property line.”

Municipal governments have police forces and road departments, Mr. Casciola said in September, but their main function and responsibility is zoning. It’s how they define what kind of place they want to be. Mr. Casciola called it a civics lesson, delivered to a township that has seen its share of them in the 20 years since the first Marcellus Shale well was completed in nearby Mt. Pleasant Township.

Range Resources Corp., the company that drilled that well paving the way for nearly 15,000 hydraulically fractured gushers that followed, held a ceremony to commemorate the occasion last month and unveiled a plaque that credited the Renz well with “leading to an American Energy Revolution and transforming Washington County.”

Advertise with us

If that sounds grandiose, it’s also hard to dispute.

Cecil Twp. Supervisor Chairman Tom Casciola listened during a hearing on a proposed oil and gas ordinance requiring a setback of 2,500 feet between a well pad and structures, effectively closing off the township for future well pads on Wednesday, Sept. 4, 2024. (Justin Guido / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

What happened there 20 years ago is bigger than Washington County, which now accounts for about 15% of Pennsylvania’s natural gas production. It’s also bigger than Pennsylvania, since more than 75% of the gas produced here is piped to other states or liquefied and sent abroad, tipping the energy balance and geopolitical scales in Europe and Asia.

It’s certainly bigger than Cecil, home to a cluster of oil and gas headquarters at Southpointe, but also a place that has grown more residential and less patient with being in the middle of a fracking revolution.

On Monday, its board of supervisors seems poised to enact what would become the strictest zoning ordinance among gas-producing municipalities. If it passes, it could mean no new wells will be permitted in the township. The ordinance’s anchor is a 2,500 foot setback, or no-drill zone, between buildings and oil and gas sites, and 5,000 feet from schools and hospitals.

“I think it's the most serious issue this township has ever faced,” Mr. Casciola, Cecil’s chairman, said during the township’s last public discussion on the topic in September.

Advertise with us

More distance, more separation

Cecil is a collage of intersecting experiences. Many oil and gas industry professionals call it home. There is a country club and golf course in Cecil where some of them socialize but whose board has said it would never allow drilling on the property. At a public hearing in June, some residents held signs urging the supervisors to “Do the right thing.” One man wore a hat that said: “Marcellus over Moscow.” Range’s Director of Public Affairs and Cecil resident Laural Ziemba calls the township home.

So does Janice Blanock, whose son Luke died at the age of 19, three years after he was diagnosed with Ewing sarcoma, which his parents suspect was linked to the shale gas industry. It was partly her activism — she has shared her story at countless public hearings, often bringing rooms to tears, and in 2019 traveled to Harrisburg to confront former Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf — that may have pressured Mr. Wolf to direct the Department of Health to study the health impacts of shale gas development. The studies, performed by the University of Pittsburgh and published last year, did not find a link between Ewing sarcomas and proximity to oil and gas infrastructure. But they found other correlations, including increased asthma exacerbations and a raised risk of lymphoma among those living near the industry’s operations.

The studies came with a recommendation: that oil and gas sites should be at least 2,500 feet from people’s homes. It was the same distance recommended by the state grand jury convened by then-Attorney General Josh Shapiro a few years before that.

Some anti-fracking advocates and impacted residents have soured on Mr. Shapiro as governor, seeing no movement on the setback front from his administration and, instead, viewing his partnership with another Cecil-based company, CNX Resources Corp., as a betrayal. As part of that partnership, CNX has been monitoring and publicly disclosing its air emissions at several well pads and compressor stations over the past year. Based on that data, the company recently declared its operations to be “safe and inherently good for the communities where we operate.” It was meant to be an answer to the Pitt health studies and hundreds of other studies that looked at air pollution and public health impacts from shale development. Part of CNX’s bargain with Mr. Shapiro was that the governor would hold off on pushing for increased setbacks.

The grand jury recommendations and the Pitt health studies have been cited at one township meeting after another. They also form the basis for a petition filed by the Environmental Integrity Project and the Clean Air Council last month, in which the two nonprofit advocacy groups asked the state to enact no-drill zones of more than half a mile around homes and protected areas.

Advertise with us

“There was a grand jury investigation. They came up with a setback,” Cecil supervisor Cindy Fisher said during the hearing in September, justifying the proposed 2,500 foot buffer. “It wasn't arbitrary, it wasn't random, it was specific, and it was for a reason.”

Whatever happens in Cecil on Monday is unlikely to stay confined there.

“One of the features of municipal government [is], not only is plagiarism not bad, it is actively encouraged,” said Jodi Noble, township manager of Chartiers, speaking at the Marcellus Shale Coalition’s annual conference in Erie in September. “So what you see is one township adopts something and then it proliferates.”

Max Junker, an attorney with Babst Calland who also serves as solicitor for Franklin Park, Bell Acres and O’Hara’s zoning hearing board, said that there’s renewed interest in municipalities taking stock of the past decade or two and tightening up their rules.

“Everybody that already has a zoning ordinance that regulates oil and gas is looking to expand and provide more distance, separation.”

Advertise with us

Trailblazer or outlier?

Cecil has always been a trailblazer in this respect.

A township of 26 square miles, it was one of the first in the state to pass a shale gas ordinance in 2010. The document was mostly concerned with setting noise limits and requiring companies to notify the township and nearby residents of their plans for this deeper-in-the-ground and supersized-on-the-surface method of extraction.

At the time, drilling was permitted as close as 200 feet from homes as per environmental regulations designed for the conventional oil and gas industry that has been operating in the state since Edwin Drake drilled the first commercial oil well near Titusville in 1859.

In 2011, Cecil amended the ordinance to include a 500-foot setback.

John Smith, an attorney with Smith Butz who was Cecil’s solicitor at the time, recalled how momentous that was for the township.

Advertise with us

“We were like, ‘Wow, look how protective we are! We moved it farther away than anyone else in the commonwealth.’” he said recently. “And now you look at that and say, ‘that’s ridiculously too close.’”

Cecil was only a few months ahead of the times in that respect. In early 2012, the Pennsylvania Legislature passed Act 13, a sweeping overhaul of environmental regulations governing oil and gas extraction that expanded the required buffer from 200 to 500 feet across the state. The law also decreed that townships couldn’t isolate oil and gas development to certain districts, as they might do with a cement plant or a grocery store. Instead, they had to allow it everywhere, in areas zoned residential, commercial, industrial and agricultural.

Mr. Smith, representing Cecil and six other townships in the state, sued the state in a landmark case that went all the way up to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which eventually overturned the parts of Act 13 that dealt with local zoning.

This shifted the goal posts for municipalities that wanted to assert control over the where, if not the how, of shale development. They couldn’t ban it outright, but they could and — township supervisors have argued, were obligated to — control where it was allowed in order to protect public safety, quality of life, and character of their townships. They also had to balance the interests of mineral owners — those who stood to benefit financially from the exploitation of the gas.

“You have to let them drill because they’re making money for the community, they’re making money for people [in the township],” said Andy Tullai, who was chairman of Union Township, Washington County, until 2014.

Advertise with us
Homes with Range's Augustine George Pad in the background. (Tim Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Tullai had a front-row seat to those tradeoffs when he lived on Cardox Road, a street that bordered the edge of Trax Farm where EQT Corp. had a well pad. His home was about 650 feet away from the pad and what he remembered was the deep, low-frequency rumble from the motors driving the drill bit. It was hard to sleep and impossible to tune it out, he said.

He remembered how EQT had tried to accommodate some of those concerns and how the company offered residents $50,000 to put up with it and sign a health waiver.

It was all too much for him. In mid-2014, Mr. Tullai and his wife sold their house (it sold in three days after multiple offers despite the proximity to the well pad, he noted) and moved across the county line to Jefferson Hills.

When, the following year, EQT filed for a permit to build a well pad in Jefferson Hills, Mr. Tullai’s former neighbors from Cardox Road came to the public hearings and talked about what it was like to live that close to a working shale pad, with its loud noises, smells, traffic and other disturbances. Jefferson Hills was among the few to deny a conditional use permit to a gas company in 2015. When EQT sued, challenging the borough’s reliance on the testimony of residents from Union, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court found no problem with using their experience to inform the decision.

“This is a precedent-setting case that confirms the importance of citizens’ testimony and points to the vital role local governments play — and the power they can exercise — in protecting public health, safety, and welfare during the permitting process,” the Environmental Integrity Project wrote in its comprehensive survey of oil and gas ordinance activity in 2020.

Advertise with us

When the group released an update in 2023, it noted that West Deer, Allegheny County, and Rostraver, Westmoreland County, had also denied conditional permits to companies that wanted to build well pads, in part based on testimony from out-of-town residents.

Mr. Tullai now lives in a Ryan Homes development, a site he chose in 2014 to ensure there would be no drilling within at least half a mile.

“The further away, the better you are,” he said.

Learning lessons

There are many different flavors of oil and gas ordinances. Collier Township in Allegheny County requires oil and gas applicants to perform an environmental impact study. Murrysville is one of an increasing number of municipalities that want to see a noise management plan. Potter Township in Beaver and Hopewell Township in Washington specifically prohibit oil and gas development in residential districts, according to the Environmental Integrity Project’s report. Townships have placed oil and gas overlay districts on their zoning maps. Most permit it as a conditional use, meaning companies must get approval for each new well.

“Let’s draw a valuable lesson [from] Cecil Township’s experience with fracking,” Victoria Austin, a West Deer resident, said during the township’s Sept. 18 oil and gas ordinance hearing.

Advertise with us

She was clicking through a slideshow with pictures of natural gas dehydration units and condensate tanks — features that would be permitted without public input under West Deer’s proposed ordinance.

“None of these structures will add to the value of your home and property. None of these structures will make you and your family's lives safer or healthier. None of these structures will enhance the quality of your life. None of these structures will make West Deer more attractive to potential homeowners or residents,” she said.

West Deer supervisors had been considering revisions to their oil and gas regulations. They’ve vacillated between keeping the current 650-foot setback and 1,000 feet, before settling on 750 feet, to the dismay of many residents testifying at this and previous hearings. The township solicitor later said the 1,000 feet was a typo and was never in consideration.

Residents who spoke — all were in favor of more distance, not less — warned that the township would be left behind as neighboring municipalities pass stricter ordinances. They pointed to Cecil’s proposed 2,500-foot setback as hard-earned wisdom.

When the supervisors voted 3-1 to pass the ordinance, the crowd booed and yelled “Shame.”

Advertise with us

Dave Harrison, a longtime West Deer resident and one-time township supervisor, sat in the back holding a manila folder with signatures from leaseholders who didn’t want further restrictions on the industry. He said there were nearly 1,500 of them, but many were too uncomfortable to speak at public hearings because of the intensity of the opposition.

“I hear people say they're not against fracking,” he said. But Mr. Harrison believes that widening the setback requirement is a backdoor way of kicking oil and gas out of the township.

Two decades of changes

In the past 20 years of fracking in Pennsylvania, the process has advanced so much that companies can drill for miles in any direction from a single well pad.

“I call them mini-industrial complexes,” David Schlosser, then-president of exploration and production at EQT said in 2018, talking about well pads that could host dozens of wells.

Residents of Cecil draw on this accomplishment to argue that the five well pads already permitted in the township are enough for companies to suck up all the gas they want and for mineral owners to get paid. Or, they can reach below the township from outside of its borders, they argue.

Advertise with us

“There are people in the industry and people outside of this township that say, ‘It's a ban.’ It can't be a ban when you already have five well pads,” Ms. Fisher argued in September.

Just as fracking has changed during its two decades in Pennsylvania, so has Cecil. Its population, more than 15,000 according to Census data, has grown by more than a third during that time. The number of housing units increased by 63%.

It has had a front row seat to how the oil and gas industry has unfolded in Pennsylvania, bringing jobs, noise, tax revenue, truck traffic, and donations to local charities and fire departments. It has brought down the price of natural gas for consumers, paid millions in royalties to landowners, and made life miserable for some who live next to well pads and the sprawling web of compressor stations, pipelines and natural gas processing plants, spawning a movement of local activists who wear the NIMBY label proudly and think their townships should, too.

“Cecil is certainly a major outlier,” said Blaine Lucas, an attorney with Babst Calland who represents Range Resources in Cecil and has battled townships across the state on oil and gas matters.

Mr. Lucas said there is a significant number of townships with slightly increased setbacks, along the lines of 650-750 feet, and a few with 1,000 feet. But he’s not aware of any that have tried to go as far as 2,500 feet.

Advertise with us

“The issue isn’t so much the setback distance; it’s the effect of the setback distance that might constitute a ban,” he said.

In June, Cecil resident Mark Litzel acknowledged in his public comments that the township may be sued over the issue.

“Maybe it’ll hold up in court and maybe it won’t,” he said. “I want it to be as tough to do this in Cecil as in Peters and South Fayette.”

Mr. Lucas declined to say whether Range would challenge the ordinance as exclusionary if supervisors approve it on Monday. But he confirmed that no township has been sued for passing an ordinance that was perceived as too strict. No company has sued the City of Pittsburgh, which banned fracking in 2010, because no one is eager to drill there.

A part of the landscape

The creep in the setback distances is clearly registering with pro-industry lawmakers. In early October, state Sens. Camera Bartolotta, R-Washington, and Gene Yaw, R-Lycoming, said they plan to introduce legislation to withhold impact fees from “any municipality that unreasonably limits or prohibits future development of natural gas within the municipality.”

Advertise with us

When asked if there’s any legal method for a township to decide that it has had enough drilling within its borders, Mr. Lucas said he doesn’t believe so.

According to an analysis of location data available from the FracTracker Alliance, an environmental advocacy group, nearly 1.5 million Pennsylvanians live within half a mile of oil and gas infrastructure.

Almost 1,000 schools are within that radius. In Washington County, half of the population was within 2,640 feet of a well or processing site when the analysis was done a few years ago. The percentage has likely increased since then as the county’s population and the industry have grown.

In Cecil, housing developments have mobilized groups to study fracking and other township ordinances, visit well sites, hire lawyers, distribute signs and mobilize hundreds of people to come to township meetings. Kara Shirdon and Michelle Stonemark, two landowners who live closest to Range’s Augustine well pad broadcast their experiences at township meetings and on social media.

In July, Ms. Stonemark said she was moved by the long line of residents asking the board of supervisors to enact the strictest ordinance possible to keep oil and gas drilling away from people’s homes. It is 500 feet away from the house she and her husband built.

“I was nearly brought to tears thinking about what would it be like if all of you were here in 2017,” she said. “What I wouldn't be dealing with on a daily basis. I've been fighting this battle for 10 years. I've been asking for this forever.”