Sens. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Sherrod Brown of Ohio wrote to U.S. Steel CEO David Burritt late Wednesday questioning how he will benefit from the Pittsburgh company’s politically volatile sale to Japan.
The letter, which the United Steelworkers shared with members on Thursday, parrots criticisms levied by the union since the $14.9 billion takeover by Nippon Steel was announced last December, including that Mr. Burritt would receive a “$72 million golden parachute.”
The payments to top executives and board members “demonstrate a repulsive conflict of interest in which U.S. Steel executives can enrich themselves at the expense of U.S. Steel workers,” the Democratic senators wrote.
They sent a detailed list of questions to address “the extent to which these incentives are driving the transaction despite its risks.”
Mr. Brown has opposed the deal since it was announced, while Ms. Warren had not previously weighed in.
U.S. Steel responded Thursday by saying the letter was full of “inaccuracies and mischaracterizations” and pledged to respond with “factual information on how this multibillion dollar investment from one of our strongest allies strengthens domestic steelmaking and secures thousands of union jobs for many years to come.”
Read More
Earlier in the week, the company told employees “we will not let the USW International leadership distract us from closing the pending transaction with Nippon Steel,” according to an internal memo shared with the Post-Gazette.
The company said that union leaders knew there would be executive compensation payments when they supported a sale to rival bidder Cleveland-Cliffs last fall.
“The purchase of the company by anyone would trigger these provisions under U. S. Steel’s existing compensation plans, which were approved by our Board of Directors… years ago,” the internal communication states.
“The idea that U. S. Steel is diverting money away from investing in its facilities to its executives ignores the fact that the buyer, in this case Nippon Steel, ultimately makes these compensations payments, not U. S. Steel.”
The company further claimed that “USW leadership is hurting their own membership in their attempts to thwart a lifetime opportunity with Nippon Steel.”
Mr. Burritt said in September that the company might be forced to close plants and abandon the Pittsburgh region if the deal is blocked — a move that would threaten thousands of Pennsylvania jobs.
The senators in their letter called such threats “unjustified and unfair” given the company’s strong financial performance in recent years. “U.S. Steel was not in distress when it first received an unsolicited bid, and it is not in distress today,” the senators wrote.
Nippon Steel declined to comment on the letter, which comes as presidential candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump continue to oppose the sale. Most recently, Ms. Harris said it’s critical that U.S. Steel remains American owned, echoing a pledge President Joe Biden first made to steelworkers in April.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.