A critical arbitration hearing between U.S. Steel Corp. and its United Steelworkers union kicks off Thursday in Philadelphia, though few details are expected to immediately be made public.

The hearing is closed to media, and neither side has said much about what sort of case they plan to make. A three-attorney panel must decide whether the iconic Pittsburgh steelmaker violated the successorship clause of its labor agreement by agreeing to sell itself to Japan’s Nippon Steel Corp. in December.

U.S. Steel said in a statement that it plans to present “clear and compelling evidence that agreements with the USW have been met.”

USW president David McCall said in a video address that U.S. Steel “violated our contract by not having the ultimate parent sign on,” a reference to Nippon Steel’s plan to structure U.S. Steel under its North American subsidiary.

Advertise with us

“We'll give you more updates after the arbitration is done, but we need our unity and our solidarity to stick together to make sure we protect our future,” Mr. McCall said.

The union, which has said the $14.9 billion deal threatens jobs and national security, is expected to argue against the sale in its entirety, although technically the hearing is only to resolve specific grievances filed in January related to successorship.

The successorship agreement has three prongs: A buyer must recognize the USW union as the bargaining representative, assume all USW agreements, and provide “reasonable assurances that it has both the willingness and financial wherewithal” to honor those existing commitments.

Nippon officials have publicly promised as much, and have pledged to pour an additional $1.4 billion into union facilities, as a further show of their commitment.

“We have been clear from the outset that Nippon Steel intends to honor the basic labor agreement between U. S. Steel and the USW and assume all existing agreements between both parties,” the company said in a statement. “We are confident that it will be acknowledged that Nippon Steel has complied with the legal requirements outlined in the Basic Labor Agreement, and we look forward to reaching a mutually beneficial resolution with the USW that drives shared success for generations to come.”

Advertise with us

But negotiations between Nippon and the USW have stalled, leaving the arbitration process as one of the most concrete steps toward closing the deal, which remains subject to two federal regulatory reviews. Analysts are split on how impactful the hearing will be. A verdict isn’t expected until the end of September.

Here’s what to know about the process:

The three arbitrators are attorneys with years of experience litigating labor issues. They are Gil Vernon, Terry Bethel and Samantha Tower.

Ms. Tower grew up in Pittsburgh and her father worked for years as a lead arbitrator for U.S. Steel and the USW. Mr. Vernon is the former president of the National Academy of Arbitrators. Mr. Bethel was managing editor of the Ohio State Law Journal and previously chaired Indiana's Public Employee Relations Board.

They will likely try to find a compromise that satisfies both sides, without fundamentally altering the deal Nippon reached with U.S. Steel, three analysts familiar with the process said. Others cast the outcome as far more uncertain.

Advertise with us

“This thing could go in 10 different directions,” said Chris Masciantonio, a former U.S. Steel executive who now runs a steel consulting firm. “Nobody knows the outcome.”

“I’m guessing they’re going to try to find some common ground,” he added.

One change that could help satisfy the union would be to require Nippon Steel to directly oversee U.S. Steel, rather than using its subsidiary, Nippon Steel North America. USW leaders have said that the subsidiary would make it impossible to enforce profit sharing.

U.S. Steel doesn’t typically publish the results of arbitration, but may be more forthcoming given the degree of public scrutiny on this decision.

The union said in a letter to members this week that it will “continue to keep everyone informed.”

Advertise with us

Political opposition to the deal has somewhat quieted amid larger shifts to this year’s presidential election, although Gov. Josh Shapiro did clarify last month that he has “serious concerns” for the impacted workers.

Kamala Harris and her running mate Tim Walz have not commented on the sale. They are expected to tour Pennsylvania this week en route to the Democratic National Convention.