The next major fight in the contested U.S. Steel takeover will play out in front of arbitration lawyers in August, but in the meantime, there’s no shortage of speculation over how recent political shifts could affect the sale.

The strongest threat could come from JD Vance, the outspoken Ohio senator who Donald Trump recently tapped as his running mate.

“Vance seems to be more of a wildcard than some of the others,” said Chris Masciantonio, a former U.S. Steel executive who now runs a steel consulting firm.

But he also said the political shakeups — from the attempted assassination of Trump to President Joe Biden exiting the race — have on the whole lowered the attention on one specific business transaction.

Advertise with us

“There are questions today that are more important for the country than whether U.S. Steel was purchased by Nippon Steel,” Mr. Masciantonio said. “So, I don't know if politically it's as important of an issue as it was when it was first announced.”

Mr. Vance has consistently said that a sale to Japan’s Nippon Steel would threaten national security. He pressured Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen to oppose the deal, and called on the Securities and Exchange Commission to investigate whether U.S. Steel misled shareholders by not accurately conveying the “significant political obstacles and regulatory risks the merger faces.”

Mr. Vance also has criticized Nippon Steel’s limited business in China. This week, Nippon sold its 50% stake in Chinese steelmaker Baosteel, saying the move was unrelated to the U.S. Steel deal and had been discussed nearly a year before the bidding last fall.

On the other side of the ballot, Vice President Kamala Harris, the likely Democratic nominee for president, is not expected to make the sale a political issue, according to interviews with several analysts.

She has already received an endorsement from the United Steelworkers union, which opposes the sale. Mr. Biden, who dropped out of the race, could still block the sale before the November election, although analysts say that no longer seems like a priority.

Advertise with us

“I don't think this is a big election topic,” Wolfe Research analyst Timna Tanners said.

In April, Mr. Biden promised to keep U.S. Steel American owned during his only visit to Pittsburgh this year. At the June presidential debate, however, Mr. Biden said nothing about the sale. Trump, who had previously pledged to block the sale, said only that his tariffs had saved the American steel industry.

“These winds of leadership change will likely ratchet up the narrative and rhetoric surrounding the deal. Still, I do not expect that to impact the substance or timing of the deal,” said Bill Greenwalt, senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and the former deputy under secretary of defense for industrial policy.

Nippon has so far shown no signs of backing away from the deal. This month, it brought on former U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo as an adviser to help win over leaders in Washington.

“We must take decisive steps to expand our manufacturing base in partnership with our closest allies,” Mr. Pompeo said in a statement distributed by Nippon. “I’m proud to be working on behalf of a deal that provides the best path forward to not only revitalize an iconic American company, but also to strengthen American supply chains and protect American jobs.”

Advertise with us

Sen. Rand Paul, R-Kentucky, also signaled his support this week, writing in an opinion piece that blocking the deal would be “extremely bad policy.” He said decades of Japanese investment in Kentucky has spurred the state’s economy, generating thousands of jobs at places like Toyota.

The effort to convince Washington comes as Nippon and U.S. Steel continue their charm offensive in Pennsylvania with billboards and television ads. So far, they’ve found support in Sam DeMarco, chairman of the Allegheny County GOP.

If Trump is elected, “I would reach out to his team to ensure that he was properly briefed on the details of the transaction and why many in this region feel that it's the best thing,” Mr. DeMarco said.

Nippon has still not made firm commitments to the Western Pennsylvania region, but the company says those will come after federal reviews and the arbitration hearing, which could force certain decisions. A spokesperson said Nippon is confident that the August hearing — designed to resolve union grievances — will be a win-win.

The timing of a ruling from the three-attorney panel could be tricky though, with a decision coming just weeks before the election.

Advertise with us

Nippon is banking on some of the political fervor dying down after November. This week, it successfully pushed a national security review until after the election — a move proponents described as a surprising but very positive sign.

“This is nothing but good news,” Mr. Masciantonio said. “They filed the initial documents when everything was controversial and emotional. Maybe now that things have settled down they’ll get a fair review.”

Rival bidder Cleveland-Cliffs is still making noise on the deal, despite its plan to buy Canadian steelmaker Stelco for a reported $2.5 billion, which analysts said would exhaust resources and tighten antitrust concerns. CEO Lourenco Goncalves told investors Monday that he would still pay $29 per share for U.S. Steel.

That price is “absurd,” said Ms. Tanners, the Wolfe Research analyst. “There's no way [U.S. Steel] would sell itself at that value. … And now with Cliffs buying Stelco — assuming that goes through — they would basically own all blast furnace production in North America.”

Evan Robinson-Johnson: ejohnson@post-gazette.com and @sightsonwheels