With more than a thousand jobs threatened by a proposed Energy Department rule, families packed into a community college Monday evening to show their support for the local industry and to hear some assurance from U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly.

They left feeling a bit flat.

“I'm a little disappointed,” said Ed Weber, 45, a steelworker who has spent the past 13 years at Cleveland-Cliffs’ Butler Works. “When he started wrapping it up, I was like ‘Wait, we're not done already are we?’ ”

“It just felt like we were here for a campaign rally,” said Carlo Morando, 33, who has been at the mill for the past nine years.

Advertise with us

Both men, wearing red to show solidarity with the United Auto Workers union, said they were hoping for firmer assurances that their jobs would be safe.

An Energy Department rule now under final review was designed to improve power efficiency across the country’s electrical grid. It would transition the steel made in Butler for distribution transformers toward an alternative that would likely need to be imported.

The department, which first proposed the rule in January 2023, has reviewed thousands of pages of comments and met with unions, manufacturers and utility companies as part of the rulemaking process.

In response to that feedback, “adjustments have been made,” Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm said at a hearing last month, adding that the final rule will come out before June.

A spokesperson told the Post-Gazette by email that the final rule will be “responsive” to the needs of American businesses and workers, while creating an energy grid that is “reliable, efficient, and affordable.”

Advertise with us

“Any long-term solutions must allow for the ability to maintain and grow a secure domestic supply of electric steel and transformers and strengthen domestic workforces,” the spokesperson said.

Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro made his own visit to Butler last week, telling the community that the steel jobs have been saved, in part because of his advocacy.

“His optimism is a result of engaging directly with the federal government,” spokesman Manuel Bonder said in a statement.

But union officials and many workers remain unconvinced.

Mr. Morando said there’s still “a lot up in the air” and a feeling of “gloom and doom” throughout the plant.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kelly, a Republican, also isn’t banking on the governor’s optimism. He said there was talk of canceling Monday’s town hall but he opted to forge ahead, noting that promises of good things can “evaporate.”

Mr. Kelly opened the event with a fiery declaration before yielding the floor for a prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance.

“This is the future of the United States of America,” he said. “I am tired of us shipping jobs overseas and hoping that somehow we'll get a benefit from it. So it's time for us to stand up.”

He continued the patriotic theme by calling steel the best product ever made in America and cautioning that all will be lost if foreign competition is allowed to take over. Mr. Kelly also took at aim at the Biden administration for allowing the rule in the first place.

“They have fingers in both ears and they’ve kept their mouth shut,” he said.

Advertise with us

Aaron Steinheiser, Butler Works’ general manager, said energy department representatives have been out to visit the facility.

“We appreciate the fact that DOE has listened to us … and has taken the time to really dig into what we do,” he said.

“We're hopeful that this final ruling will provide us a path for the continued use of our product and that we can save our plant, our jobs, our town, and … our country.”

Although the proposed rule is now in the final review stages, Mr. Steinheiser said “we as a group need to stick together and continue to fight this.”

At one point, he passed around samples of the amorphous metal that the energy department has proposed as an alternative.

Advertise with us

“Quite honestly, it's damaged already, and I tried to be very careful with it,” he said, holding up what looked like a sheet of aluminum foil.

Improvements to Butler Works have been on hold for over year, he said, since the rule was first proposed — and workers have dealt with uncertainty for just as long.

The loss of the Cliffs mill would be devastating to the Butler community, said Stacy Lu, a nurse whose husband, Matt, works at the plant. Many workers come straight out of high school, carrying on the tradition of their parents and grandparents, she said. They still remember when the Pullman plant closed in the 1980s.

Although Mr. Kelly has proposed legislation to block the energy department rule, he said after the event that there’s a more bootstrap solution: “The public has to complain.”

“The public has to challenge them, and the public has to be the most influential voice,” he said, noting that the rulemaking process is separate from legislation.

Advertise with us

For some in attendance, the packed room was proof enough that such a movement is underway.

“I didn't feel that this was going to be as much of a resolution to the problem as it was trying to show our community is sticking together to make a change, to make things better,” said Mike Uram, 50, who has worked half his life at the Cliffs plant.

“Until D.C. sees these small communities trying to stand up, they're just going to keep steamrolling over people,” he said. “So we needed this, so that people can see that these lives that are affected are real families.”

Evan Robinson-Johnson: ejohnson@post-gazette.com and @sightsonwheels