Larry Mitko worked 34 years of his life at Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. in Aliquippa, where mills stretched for miles and company carpenters built company homes.
He retired early, at age 50, confident that his pension would provide. But within a few years, J&L sold and shuttered, eliminating 8,000 jobs and gutting Mr. Mitko’s monthly payments. When he heard the news Monday that U.S. Steel could be headed in the same direction, Mr. Mitko’s first reaction was anger.
“I'm not quite sure how our lawmakers would even let that go through,” he said.
Then, he started to worry for the employees.
Nippon Steel Corp. agreed to honor all existing labor agreements in its winning bid for U.S. Steel — a $14.9 billion cash offer and 142% premium that analysts said the Japanese steelmaker wouldn’t have paid if it didn’t want all of the company’s assets.
But a few miles from its glimmering Downtown offices, U.S. Steel’s three remaining operations in Allegheny County are dated and dirty. They would cost billions to modernize, the company has said. Based on the history that guided his own life, Mr. Mitko doesn’t expect Nippon to make the investment.
Read More
“I could see that. But I don't believe it. You don't know what the road ahead is going to be,” he said.
“We thought when LTV purchased J&L, it was going to be a big improvement, and it went downhill until it went totally bankrupt.”
Steelmaking once was the dominant enterprise throughout Pennsylvania, employing more people than any other industry, while fueling an industrial revolution that built the nation’s infrastructure and clinched its success in World War II.
But for the past 40 years, the local story of steel has been one of closures and layoffs. The region’s only possible new mill is being built by a Brooklyn firm with Chinese roots. It just so happens to be slated for the same J&L site where Mr. Mitko worked.

“This is a region that has dealt with contraction in the manufacturing labor force for decades,” said Christopher Briem, a regional economist at the University of Pittsburgh’s Center for Social and Urban Research. “Generations of steelworkers have had to adjust and change.”
At one point, those changes meant thousands of young workers left Western Pennsylvania, leaving abandoned homes and one of the oldest populations in the country in their wake.
Today, Mr. Briem said, there are more opportunities to pivot to new manufacturing jobs and learn new skills.
Companies themselves are also pivoting. In 2019, U.S. Steel embraced a new way of making steel that uses electricity and recycled scrap rather than traditional blast furnaces. The change came at a fortuitous time as the federal government embraced tariffs and poured billions into domestic manufacturing efforts to rebuke China and chase climate targets.
Many observers expect Nippon to help the U.S. in that effort, though union leaders and politicians swiftly and strongly opposed the idea of a foreign takeover.
“There's a symbolic point here of a Japanese firm buying U.S. Steel, which seems to have triggered a lot of folks,” Mr. Briem said. “But it's actually not that strange. They offered a lot of money.”
Japan dips its toe in the water
Japanese companies have invested in Western Pennsylvania for the past 40 years, with mixed success.
Sony came to Westmoreland County in the 1980s, building huge tube televisions that “were like, two feet by four feet and weighed 7,000 pounds,” said Pittsburgh attorney Dennis Unkovic, who represents several Japanese companies.
Toshiba bought Westinghouse Electric Co. in 2006, making a bet on nuclear energy that would end a decade later in bankruptcy for Westinghouse and embarrassment for both pioneering companies and their home nations.
Nippon’s first American foray, a small stake in Wheeling-Pittsburgh Steel, also ended in bankruptcy, as did Japan’s 50% stake in National Steel Corp. (U.S. Steel had tried to buy National the year prior, 1983, but was blocked by regulators who worried about monopolization. Twenty years later, after National declared bankruptcy, U.S. Steel bought what was left of its assets.)
Japanese investment has spurred Pittsburgh’s tech revolution, too. This year alone, Softbank gave Stack AV $1 billion to build autonomous trucks, and Mitsubishi forked over $500 million to help Coherent make semiconductors.
"The economic relationship between Japan and the United States is as close today as it's ever been," Mr. Unkovic said.
For John Tumazos, that’s a positive shift.
The 68-year-old steel analyst expects Nippon to pursue improvements and projects that U.S. Steel lacked the resources or will to complete. “The Japanese are more patriotic about America than we are,” he said.
But if Pennsylvania wants a share of that wealth, he said it will have to actively compete with other states. Arkansas offered hundreds of millions of dollars in tax incentives to U.S. Steel’s Big River Steel Works, the largest economic development in that state’s history.
Mr. Tumazos grew up in Homestead, where his father, Charles, worked 27 years as a machinist, making gears for U.S. Steel’s rolling mills.
“He was a little more educated than the average steelworker,” Mr. Tumazos said. “They offered him jobs in management, but he would never take them. He didn't play golf, and I don't think he wanted to go around glad-handing customers. He preferred to make a physical product.”
U.S. Steel closed Charles’ shop along with several mills in 1982 as the country began to slide toward greater reliance on cheap production overseas. To Mr. Tumazos and other observers, that process is only just starting to reverse itself.
“It is a late recognition — partly driven by the pandemic and it being hard to get face masks from China — that we need to make our own things,” he said.
Made in the U.S.A.?
Even under foreign ownership, U.S. Steel would still make steel in the United States, for the United States.
Chief Executive David Burritt promised as much to investors the day he announced the sale.
But that might not be enough for the Biden administration, which pledged to scrutinize the deal as it continues to champion domestic manufacturing. National Economic Advisor Lael Brainard said Thursday that the purchase could potentially hurt national security and supply chain reliability, even though Japan is an ally.

In the same statement, she said, “We welcome manufacturers across the world building their futures in America with American jobs and American workers.”
Republican critics of the deal have made a similarly contradictory point.
“Trade protections can and should induce foreign investment that expands domestic production and creates American jobs,” Sens Josh Hawley, of Missouri, J.D. Vance, of Ohio, and Marco Rubio, of Florida, said in a Tuesday letter. Instead of seeing the Nippon deal in that light, they found it to be “out of step with those goals.”
In Arkansas, officials were far more optimistic.
“This pending transaction shows how attractive our region is for companies who want to invest in a robust workforce and utilize our regional, multi-modal transportation network,” said Rep. Rick Crawford, the Republican chairman of the Congressional Steel Caucus.
President Joe Biden came into office pledging to restore American manufacturing.
In his first address to Congress, in April 2021, he said: “There is simply no reason why the blades for wind turbines can’t be made in Pittsburgh instead of Beijing.”
Nippon’s investment could help make that dream a reality, with a little help from Tokyo.
Evan Robinson-Johnson: ejohnson@post-gazette.com and @sightsonwheels.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.