Federal antitrust regulators suspect something nefarious is going on in Appalachia’s oil and gas fields.
They called it a “dense and tangled web of co-investments, joint operations, and other methods of coordination between and among natural gas producers and investors” and “a tight-knit set of players rife with entanglements and a history of suspicious ventures and information exchange.”
The comments by Federal Trade Commission chairwoman Lina Khan and the other two seated commissioners, are part of an agreement and consent order released on Monday that clears EQT Corp. to acquire fellow Appalachian gas producer Tug Hill Corp. and pipeline operator XcL Midstream.
Downtown-based EQT first announced the $5.2 billion deal in September, projecting it would close by the end of last year.
But the deal was held up by the FTC, which requested more details and was focusing on what kind of power would be given to Quantum Energy Partners, the Texas-based private equity firm that has Tug Hill and XcL in its portfolio.
EQT planned to pay Quantum $2.6 billion in cash and up to 55 million shares of EQT stock for the assets, which would have made the private equity firm one of the largest shareholders of the nation’s top natural gas producer.
The deal also came with EQT’s backing for a board seat for Quantum’s CEO Wil VanLoh.
By late October, Mr. VanLoh had already backed away from the board seat to clear the antitrust hurdles. EQT said in a regulatory filing that the condition was pulled “out of an abundance of caution and to ensure compliance with Section 8 of the Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914,” which prohibits directors and officers of a company from sitting on a competitor’s company board.
Still, Quantum reserved the right to request a seat at some future point.
The agreement announced on Monday goes much further than that. It prohibits any Quantum officer from seeking a board seat at EQT or at any of the top seven Appalachian natural gas producers for 10 years — the term of the agreement. It also requires Quantum to sell its EQT shares by some undisclosed date and, in the meantime, to keep them in a voting trust that effectively flips Quantum’s image of itself as “more than an investment firm; it is a partner for progress.”
The FTC wants no such partnership. Its order is aimed at “effectively rendering Quantum's ownership passive pending the sale of its EQT shares,” the agency wrote in an analysis document accompanying the agreement and order.
This is the first case in 40 years that enforces the so-called interlocking directorate prohibition (Section 8), the agency said.
Quantum, the FTC said, is a direct competitor of EQT. Besides Tug Hill and XcL Midstream, it has a number of other portfolio companies that secure land rights and drill for gas in Appalachia, including Hg Energy and Stone Hill Minerals. In 2021, Quantum also made a large investment in Antero Resources, one of the largest gas producers in West Virginia, through its Capital Solutions Fund.
If allowed to sit on EQT’s board, the FTC was concerned about Quantum’s access to EQT’s confidential and competitive information — where it plans to lease and drill, how much it is willing to spend to do it — coming to believe that the deal was illegal as structured.
The agreement and consent order, it said, “signals the antitrust risks of excessive influence and anticompetitive information exchange.”
EQT, in a statement on Monday, said it was pleased the antitrust review was done and that it expected the deal to close within the next seven days.
Joint ventures
Shortly after President Biden’s administration took office, corporate lawyers began sending out client alerts warning of an increased appetite for antitrust litigation and enforcement. They drew on comments from FTC and Department of Justice officials who signaled they would be bringing new life to Section 8, and using it to delve into private equity’s role on corporate boards.
That could be a tougher pill for the oil and gas industry than for some others. Private equity is the lifeblood of wildcatters and companies hoping to prove a new sweet spot or a better technology to coax more oil and gas out of the ground. It’s where experienced management teams go after they sell their companies to a Chevron or an Exxon and want to do it all over again.
Many of the production hot spots in U.S. shales are already delineated and leased up, so the game becomes more about trading acreage or forming joint ventures to develop an area of common interest.
Joint development agreements are as common in the industry as they might seem puzzling to those outside it.
In 2015, Pennsylvania’s Attorney General filed a lawsuit against Chesapeake Energy and Anadarko over their partnership which the state claimed shortchanged landowners by eliminating competition for leases and royalties. The state alleged that the companies split a portion of the state into two parts, with Chesapeake assigned to one, and Anadarko the other. If Chesapeake secured a lease, Anadarko had the option to partner on it, and vice versa, but the effect for the landowners was having one company offer instead of two. In 2021, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court said the state couldn’t use consumer protection laws to make its claims.
It turns out EQT and Quantum had a joint venture as well. In 2020, they formed The Mineral Company which was a vehicle for buying mineral rights that would be used by EQT to drill for gas.
“Under the arrangement, Quantum supplies most of the funds and EQT agrees to provide a right of first refusal to [The Mineral Company] before acquiring mineral rights in a specified region. If TMC buys the rights, EQT produces the gas and both EQT and Quantum profit,” the FTC explained in case documents. Two Quantum employees were involved in managing the joint venture’s operations, one of whom also works with other natural gas companies in Appalachia, the FTC said.
Concerned with the flow of proprietary information between the various entities, the FTC has also required EQT and Quantum dissolve this joint venture as part of the settlement.
“Capital discipline”
The agency even took a swipe at what has been a sacred phrase in oil and gas company earnings calls over the past several years -— “capital discipline.”
It refers to companies choosing to focus on producing more cash rather than just more gas by limiting their drilling programs.
Investors demanded as much after years of funding record-breaking production growth while losing money. At first, no company wanted to be the first to say it would slow growth but executives eventually started talking publicly about a need for the entire industry to rein in production before prices tank so much they’ll be put out of business.
In case documents, the FTC quoted a text from an unnamed EQT executive to Tug Hill’s CFO in January 2022: “If there is discipline by producers, prices could be $3.50-$5 in 2023+ in our view. Just takes minor discipline by the remaining privates.”
The agency wrote that “the net effect of this strategy, however, reduces output and keeps prices higher than they would be but-for this strategy.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.