Two environmental groups filed a lawsuit Thursday against Shell Chemical Appalachia LLC for “repeated and ongoing violations of the Clean Air Act (and) the Pennsylvania Air Pollution Control Act” at its Beaver County Shell Petrochemical Complex.

The groups brought the suit under the Clean Air Act, which allows citizens to file legal actions to compel the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to take action on alleged violations.

“The EPA has not commenced and is not diligently prosecuting a civil action in federal or state court or in litigation before the Environmental Hearing Board to require Shell to comply with the Clean Air Act or the Pennsylvania Air Pollution Control Act,” the complaint said.

“Shell’s persistent law-breaking must end,” said Joseph Minott, executive director of the Clean Air Council, in a press release announcing the suit. “The community will not tolerate dangerous pollution events that risk the health of families across Beaver County and beyond.”

Advertise with us

The action filed Thursday morning in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania was previewed in two notices of intent to sue that were issued in February and that kicked off a 60 day period for the defendant to respond.

The environmental groups — the Environmental Integrity Project and the Clean Air Council — gave Shell the required 60-day notice on the grounds that the company violated the federal Clean Air Act, the Pennsylvania air-quality law, and the state permits under which it is allowed to emit specific quantities of some contaminants.

Since the Shell Polymers Monaca plant officially announced it had commenced commercial operations on Nov. 15, 2022, the plant has exceeded state permit limits for volatile organic compounds, nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide, according to records from the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. The plant is also charged with violating state limits on flaring unwanted gasses at various times between June and September last year.

“Shell received $1.6 billion in taxpayer subsidies from the state to build this plant. The very least this international corporation can do is to follow the law and not make Pennsylvania taxpayers breathe in their illegal pollution,” said Sarah Kula, attorney for the Environmental Integrity Project.

In a statement, Shell spokesman Curtis Thomas said the plant is currently shut down as the company works to fix issues identified with the high pressure flare system.

Advertise with us

“We are continuing to work rapidly to improve facilities and operations to address these issues in conjunction with the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection,” he said. “When there is an issue, we work to fix it. We learn from those issues and work to improve so that we can be the good environmental steward, neighbor, and business partner this region wants and deserves.”

Shell’s volatile organic compound emission budget was exceeded as a result of flaring, which Mr. Thomas said was “related to the complexities of commissioning brand new systems and equipment that make up one of the largest construction projects in the country.”

According to the suit, plaintiffs — which include community members who live near the plant or are impacted by it — are concerned about pollution and its impact on their health.

“These members see the plant’s flares and smell odors from the plant and alter or restrict their daily activities in response,” the suit states. “In some cases, members have suffered headaches or felt nauseous when smelling odors from the plant. ... (They) go outside, recreate, garden, and enjoy their properties less due to the illegal pollution.”

One plaintiff has chosen to delay starting a family over health concerns about living near the plant, the suit reads.

Advertise with us

“Some members fear they may be forced to move away from their current home due to impacts they and their families experience from illegal pollution from the plant.”

The plant, built to produce 1.6 million metric tons of plastic pellets per year, has received permits from the state that allow it to emit 159 tons of fine particulate matter and 522 tons of volatile organic compounds per year — amounts that would make it the second-largest emitter of those volatile organic compounds in the state.

Shell’s exceedances are based on self-reported data and the company has since recalculated its emissions retroactively, citing a test performed in January that showed one of its enclosed high pressure flares had a higher rate of destroying hydrocarbons than previously calculated. The DEP and the environmental groups that filed the lawsuit have not accepted this method as valid.

Post-Gazette business news: business@post-gazette.com