EQT Corp. has come out swinging with a new letter to Toby Rice that accuses him and his family of promoting their own interests over those of the natural gas producer’s shareholders.
The sharp-tongued reply to Mr. Rice’s nomination of nine directors to EQT’s board and his effort to become the CEO of the Downtown-based firm also arrived with a concession — Jim Rohr, a 23-year veteran of EQT’s board and its chairman will retire this year.
Mr. Rohr has been a particular target of the Rice campaign, though he categorically denied being pressured by it during an interview on Wednesday.
“That was my decision,” he said. “I went on the board when the market cap of the whole company was a few hundred million [dollars].”
It’s been a good run, Mr. Rohr said. “Now it’s time for me to retire.”
Asked if he had this timeline in mind when he assumed the chairmanship of the oil and gas company last year, Mr. Rohr declined to comment.
Read More
“The proxy is about next year,” he said. “I’m not. And that’s my decision.”
Two other longtime directors, both with more than a decade on the board, are not seeking re-election at the company’s annual shareholder meeting scheduled for July 10. They are Lee Todd and Bray Carey.
Instead, EQT is nominating three new directors: Valerie Mitchell, CEO and founding member of Corterra Energy; James McManus, who led Energen Corp., and Janet Carrig, a former executive at ConocoPhillips.
With this shakeup, the company is attempting to answer some complaints lodged by Toby Rice, Derek Rice, a group of former Rice Energy Inc. executives, and at least two hedge funds that support their efforts. The group has alleged that EQT’s board doesn’t have enough directors with oil and gas industry experience and too many directors with long tenures.
In a statement released on Thursday, Toby and Derek Rice said the board shakeup is a good, yet “reactionary” move and is not enough.
“As we and other shareholders have been saying for many months, the problem at EQT is that the leadership team lacks the vision, ambition and execution capability to deliver on the promise of EQT’s outstanding assets,” they wrote.
To answer the rest of the claims made in the Rice team proxy statement, EQT used much sharper language.
“The board should not be a friends-and-family club, and it is not in the best interests of all EQT shareholders for the company to become a family business,” wrote the independent members of the company’s board in a letter to Toby Rice on Wednesday.
With Danny Rice, former CEO of Rice Energy Inc., already on the board, the letter said, “We fail to see why the company needs two brothers with similar backgrounds and experience when we could benefit, by contrast, from directors with a variety of direct, large-company experience, as offered by the EQT nominees.”
The Rice team called this accusation disappointing and said again that it was only after hearing from EQT shareholders that it launched the takeover effort and nominated its slate of candidates to the board.
EQT’s letter painted those nominees as unqualified and conflicted.
It also accused the Rice brothers, who own the Rice Investment Group, of trying to secure business contracts with EQT for their portfolio companies, which the current board said would complicate their independence.
For a personal burn, the letter noted that Toby Rice was not made CEO of Rice Energy before that company went public in 2014 — he became its president and COO. “We are not aware of anything that would cause us to reach a different conclusion than your own family members,” the board members wrote.
While EQT welcomed “constructive disruption,” the plan outlined by the Rice team would instead slow the progress that the company has made over the past two quarters and destabilize the business, the letter said.
EQT also announced Wednesday that it would choose to use a universal proxy card — a concept previously embraced by the Rice team — to enable shareholders to vote for any combination of the 12 directors nominated by EQT and the nine nominated by Rice, where Danny Rice is the overlapping nominee.
Shareholders would see on the proxy card which directors are endorsed by which group and would be able to choose up to 12.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.
Updated on 10 a.m., May 9, 2019.
Correction: This article was updated reflect the correct title of EQT’s board nominee Valerie Mitchell.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.