Larry Cain is a “we” kind of guy.

“We’re playing our rivals,” Mr. Cain, 61, says on his way to a high school basketball game.

“We just milk cows,” he says modestly, and it’s not clear if he’s talking about himself and his son Devin Cain who run the Cain Farm in Bethesda, Ohio, or the hundreds of farmers and landowners he once shepherded into a lucrative arrangement with Rice Energy Inc.

When Canonsburg-based Rice announced in June 2017 that it had agreed to be acquired by EQT Corp., Mr. Cain had another kind of “we” moment.

Advertise with us

“We need to talk,” he texted Toby Rice, COO and co-founder of Rice Energy.

That night, he got a call — a difficult call. Mr. Rice didn’t come out and say he didn’t want to sell the company, Mr. Cain recalled. He talked about doing what’s best for the shareholders and how EQT offered $6.7 billion.

“He would have been perfectly happy building the next Exxon,” Mr. Cain said.

The Ohio farmer felt jolted by the sale. He was a Rice enthusiast through and through — gushing to Dan Rice, the BlackRock hedge fund millionaire and father of the three brothers who founded Rice Energy, about how he had raised such wonderful kids; and opening up his farm to local reporters to show how well the company was taking care of his land: “I can grow corn right up to the well pad!” he marveled.

So when brothers Toby and Derek Rice decided late last year to mount a campaign to unseat EQT’s management and board, and to take over the Pittsburgh company, Mr. Cain volunteered as a character witness.

Advertise with us

“He should have run our public relations effort,” Jamie Rogers, former CFO of Rice Energy, said recently.

Farm property of Larry Cain, a dairy farmer in Bethesda, Ohio who has two oil and gas well pads on his farm. (Anya Litvak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The farm and the gas rush

One recent evening, when Larry Cain and his sister got to talking about the most impactful people in their lives, their list was topped by two men: their father and Toby Rice.

Mr. Cain’s father, Glenn Cain, bought what is now known as the Cain Farm just before going off to serve during the Korean War era. When he returned, Glenn settled into the same life that now belongs to Larry and his son Devin.

Cows are milked at 4:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. Calves are fed, manure is shoveled, and farm improvement projects done in between.

Advertise with us

The farm meant everything to Glenn Cain.

He built his home on it, decorated the walls with large aerial photos of the acreage through the decades. He farmed well into his 80s, helping manage the farm until weeks before he died last summer. The land was so precious that when oil and gas prospectors would come knocking, he always turned them away.

In 2011, a few years after the oil and gas land rush came to Pennsylvania, the wave headed west. Land brokers convened farmers in school auditoriums and promised a windfall.

Larry Cain and a few others lingered in the back, feeling uneasy. “They were offering us a lot of money for something — we didn’t know what we had — and asking you to sign a 20-page document,” Mr. Cain said.

Some people signed right away, he recalled, handing over a portion of their future royalties to lawyers.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cain couldn’t do it.

In fact, he had nothing to sign over. The farm belonged to his father, and Glenn Cain’s stance on leasing had been firm for decades.

But the wave was coming just the same. Mr. Cain and a handful of other nearby landowners decided to form a committee to learn more about it. Mr. Cain became its “self-appointed volunteer chair.”

“I knew nothing about oil and gas when it started. Absolutely nothing,” he said.

They rented space at the fire hall and the middle high school, holding monthly meetings with invited speakers who talked about what to expect when fracking comes to town.

Advertise with us

Gatherings attracted hundreds of people. At one point, rumors of oil and gas company workers infiltrating the meetings prompted the group to institute a sign-up sheet at the entrance.

Mr. Cain decorated a small apartment just off his home with parcel maps and learned how to monitor well results. He parsed information from public company earnings calls to glean where wells were being drilled and which ones were successful.

With only a few dozen wells drilled in the Utica Shale in Ohio at that time, he was searching for sweet spots at the same time as the oil and gas companies. Mr. Cain began to trade intelligence with them.

By early 2012, the Smith-Goshen landowners group was a known quantity with more than 30,000 acres combined. Zero of those acres were guaranteed. Any of the owners could have walked away.

Mr. Cain was peddling little more than a scout’s honor when he began to reach out to oil and gas companies.

Advertise with us

An unlikely friendship

He called more than 30 companies — EQT among them. The Pittsburgh company was not interested, but about a dozen others were. Toby Rice asked to make a presentation to the landowners’ committee.

Neither side was too impressed.

“I sat here thinking, here’s a 20-some-year-old guy, going to just spend his dad’s money and go back to playing baseball,” Mr. Cain said.

Mr. Rice later confessed to Mr. Cain that he didn’t think much of the landowners’ group either. “There’s no way this guy has 30,000 acres,” the Rice executive reportedly told a landman who came along for the Ohio trip.

Advertise with us

They stayed in touch. “We developed a friendship,” Mr. Cain said. “I don’t even know if it was a friendship. I would just give him a call and see if he had time to talk.”

Mr. Cain had a network of people like that.

Mr. Cain’s father, Glenn Cain, bought what is now known as the Cain Farm just before going off to serve during the Korean War era. When he returned, Glenn settled into the same life that now belongs to Larry and his son Devin. (Anya Litvak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

When a new well was drilled near his farm, he’d drive over to take pictures of the flare. Then he’d send the images and videos to industry contacts for analysis. Did the flame look like there are natural gas liquids in the well, he’d ask? Does it seem to be gushing at high pressure?

In early October 2012, Gulfport Energy, the main operator in Belmont County at the time, began flaring a massive well. Mr. Cain and his family took turns compiling videos of it. On Oct. 9, Mr. Cain sent the images to a handful of companies, as if to say, “This is what you can expect if you drill here.”

Gulfport had sent a press releasing touting the results of its latest gusher that same Monday morning.

Advertise with us

Shortly after, an e-mail arrived from Mr. Rice. It said, cryptically, “What’s the plan?”

Mr. Rice said the company was ready to do a deal and told Mr. Cain to pick a day to come to the office to talk details. Mr. Cain picked Tuesday.

A relative unknown

“It was amazing to see their level of sophistication,” said Mr. Rogers, the former Rice CFO, recalling those meetings with the landowners’ committee. “Once we saw the potential and magnitude of this group, there was no plan B.”

Rice was a relative unknown at the time, he said, and leasing with this group would nearly double its land position. The move would make the company big enough to take it public a year later, Mr. Rogers said, demonstrating to investors that Rice had enough drilling inventory to last up to a decade.

Advertise with us

It was the rare situation when the stakes might have been just as high for the company as for the landowners.

“This was the whole company for us,” Toby Rice later said of the deal in a speech before the St. Clairsville Rotary club in 2014, according to The Associated Press. “This would have set us back five years on the Marcellus development if this didn’t work, so this was a very big stroke for us.”

To get it, Rice had to compete with companies like XTO — as in a division of the world’s biggest energy company, ExxonMobil. The competitors had the money, the name recognition and the tickers on the New York Stock Exchange.

Rice was selling vision and relationships, Mr. Rogers said.

‘Can you milk?’

Advertise with us

In 2012, as his marriage ended, Mr. Cain had immersed himself in the leasing process, traveling to industry trade shows, digging through news stories, carrying the responsibility for hundreds of landowners.

“Can you milk?” became shorthand for his son Devin to take over farm duties. For a time, when the phone rang at the house of fellow committee member Tony Gregor, his children would shout, “There’s Larry calling again.”

In the 48 hours before the deal was with Rice signed, Mr. Cain said he was awake for 44 of them. The deal the committee negotiated was objectively impressive — $6,250-per-acre bonus payments, 20 percent royalties on produced gas with no gas treatment or transportation costs deducted from the payments.

Glenn Cain signed an oil and gas lease — his first.

“Once we saw the potential and magnitude of this group, there was no plan B.”

Jamie Rogers, former CFO of Rice Energy

Hundreds of landowners snaked a line outside of Ohio University Eastern while the Rice brothers and other company executives sat inside writing checks.

Advertise with us

“People were coming up to the table with tears in their eyes,” Mr. Rogers recalled. “I’m initiating wires that are paying off people’s mortgages.”

The company dispensed more than $200 million in lease bonus payments.

Mr. Cain holds those days as an emotional memento.

“Where would we be if we had not taken that deal?” Mr. Cain wondered recently, chewing it over with a Sloppy Joe sandwich at a restaurant in Bethesda.

“Where would Rice be?” he added.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cain said he wanted to talk about the inefficiencies that he witnessed first hand when EQT replaced Rice on his farm. But his thoughts kept returning to the days when Rice loomed large over the community, and to Toby Rice in particular.

He reminisced about April 2013 when Mr. Rice made it a point to pose for a picture with every landowner behind a huge cardboard check that had four dollar signs in the amount field and his signature in the bottom right corner.

Later, Mr. Rice collected the pictures into a posterboard presentation that hung in the company’s Ohio office.

When EQT took over, the sign ended up smooshed in half and disposed of. A former Rice employee fished it out of the trash and brought it to Mr. Cain’s house. Mr. Cain put it in the leasing war room.

It’s not that he blames EQT for redecorating the office, he says. It just feels like the connection is being erased.

Advertise with us

A tumultuous year

“To the Rob McNallys, we’re just a name on a check,” he said, referring to EQT’s CEO — the one that Toby Rice is vying to replace.

Mr. Cain can’t help but process the tumultuous year that EQT has had since the merger — with several leadership changes, disappointing financial reports and the looming proxy battle — through that lens.

The Smith-Goshen Enrichment Fund is a case in point.

This community improvement fund was the brainchild of the leasing committee, a way for some landowners to give back to the community and deal with the tax liability of their newfound wealth.

Advertise with us

The fund began with a $25,000 check from Rice Energy. When EQT bought Rice, Mr. Cain bragged, Toby Rice chose to remain on the fund’s executive committee and kept his cell phone number on its brochures. The gas executive and his wife also wrote a personal $10,000 check.

At last year’s fundraiser — held in a large equipment shed on the Cain farm — Mr. Cain was delighted to see a $10,000 contribution from EQT.

“I don’t fault them [that it’s] not at the level of Rice,” he said. “It’ll take time to build that relationship.”

Mr. Cain said he’s actually been surprised by the extent of EQT’s involvement in the community, with contributions to the local fire department and participation at local events.

But just as quickly, he can contrast EQT doing something good with Rice going above and beyond — like it did with Marcellus Mania, the annual Rice-themed carnival that had attractions like an ice cream truck, live camels for petting, barbeque and lots of company merchandise. And the obligatory oversized check to first responders.

His retirement savings

Mr. Cain doesn’t play the stock market. And he wasn’t playing when he invested nearly his entire retirement savings pot into the Rice IPO in 2014.

“We believed in Rice and the leadership,” he said, against the advice of his accountant who continues to nudge toward a more diverse portfolio.

As a newly minted EQT shareholder after the acquisition, Mr. Cain traveled to Pittsburgh for the company’s annual shareholder meeting in June.

No one even shook his hand, Mr. Cain marveled. He was the only shareholder in attendance. Not like the Rice events, where the Rice brothers would hang around with dozens of “people like me” who showed up.

“They all came in the same door at 8 a.m. and they all went out the same door” after adjournment 10 minutes later, Mr. Cain said.

What Mr. Cain had come to expect from a “partnership” — the word he uses most often to describe Rice — with an oil and gas company isn’t meshing with how a large corporation, especially one under attack from its shareholders, tends to behave.

It’s hard to say how the startup culture of Rice would have translated to the realities of being a much larger company like EQT.

Much has been made of this point by both the Rice brothers and the company establishment, with predictably divergent views.

Mr. Gregor, who ended up suing Rice over a mineral dispute, said that company had already lost some of the familiarity it once had as it got bigger and closer to the sale. More people were hired. More attorneys were handling matters, he said.

“It started to feel maybe like it wasn’t a family company anymore,” he said. “Like it does with EQT right now,” he added.

A sign on Mr. Cain's farm property. (Anya Litvak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The future of Belmont County

There are many things on the line for Mr. Cain in the EQT proxy battle that has been unfolding over the past several months and that will likely culminate in a vote at EQT’s annual shareholder meeting in July.

Krazy Train and Razin Kane are two of them.

The two well pads on the Cain farm, which have 11 wells between them, are marked by EQT signs. A decorative rock at the access road entrance is etched with Rice Energy’s blue fire logo.

Belmont County was important to Rice Energy, Mr. Cain said. He worries it’s just a sideshow for EQT, whose core area is in southwestern Pennsylvania and northern West Virginia.

As he monitors trucks meandering through his corner of the Buckeye state, Mr. Cain wonders if it could all “come to a grinding halt.”

The hundreds of lease signatories didn’t want a company to sit on their land, controlling it but not taking gas out. “We wanted drilled and produced,” he said

In EQT’s 2019 budget, Ohio Utica wells constitute around 15 percent of the Pittsburgh company’s activity.

During an interview with the Post-Gazette after a recent call with investors, the Rice brothers said that if they are successful in gaining more control at EQT, they would also steer the company toward its core Marcellus areas — which is what existing management is doing.

But Mr. Cain sees hope in the Rices’ connection to Belmont County. So he’s continued listening to company earnings calls — hoping soon to hear a familiar voice.

“EQT is a good company,” he said after the company announced its capital budget in January. “Just be a better one with Toby as CEO.”

“Of course,” he said. “This is the opinion of a dairy farmer.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.