HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania environmental regulators will formally study a citizens petition to establish a statewide cap on carbon dioxide emissions that could, if adopted, reduce climate warming gases and change the economic order in a state long defined by its fossil fuels.
The proposal is an ambitious bid by lawyers representing 192 petitioners from environmental organizations, businesses, municipalities, schools and faith groups to cut down on — and eventually nearly eliminate — emissions of the powerful greenhouse gas in all sectors of the state economy.
The Environmental Quality Board voted Tuesday to accept the petition for review. The board’s policy gives it only narrow reasons to reject petitions at this stage.
The 20-member board is made up of the heads of state agencies, members of the General Assembly and representatives of a citizens advisory council.
An evaluation by the state Department of Environmental Protection will consider the proposal’s environmental, economic and legal implications and is expected to take months.
John Dernbach, an environmental law professor at Widener University in Chester, Pa., and one of the petitioners, said state government will now have to give “serious, detailed, comprehensive” consideration to a holistic proposal for regulating greenhouse gas emissions.
Read More
“Today is a big step forward for Pennsylvania,” he said.
Sixteen major state business and industry groups had signed a letter urging the board to take no action on the petition — possibly indefinitely or at least until the board members could explore the implications of “such a sweeping environmental regulatory program that would affect Pennsylvania’s entire economy.”
State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry, cited the letter and argued that the petition violates state law and the state constitution by, among other issues, instituting what amounts to a tax without the approval of lawmakers.
“I don’t think there is any evidence that this regulation reshaping the economy would have any measurable impact on the climate,” he said.
Attorney Robert McKinstry, who presented the petition, said if Pennsylvania emissions reach net zero by 2052, as the petition recommends, global carbon emissions will be reduced by about 1 percent.
There is broad scientific consensus that human actions, especially burning fossil fuels, are warming the planet with devastating repercussions that are both apparent and worsening: deluges, heat waves, rising seas, crop failures.
The proposed cap-and-trade program would set a shrinking limit on how much carbon can be released by everything from power plants to coal mines, industrial manufacturers to motor vehicles.
It would create economic incentives for companies to make further carbon cuts and earn valuable allowances they could sell to others.
The petitioners estimate revenues from the program could be $1.6 billion a year — enough to “solve Pennsylvania’s chronic budget deficits for decades to come” and prevent most of the state’s nuclear plants from closing prematurely — but they say the carbon allowances to be bought and sold are more like timber sales on state lands or garbage fees at landfills than taxes.
“Climate change is the most serious long-term problem facing this planet,” Rep. Greg Vitali, D-Delaware, said before the vote. “Study after study … indicate we are simply running out of time. This simply is a study. That’s the responsible thing to do.”
DEP’s next step is to prepare a report and make a recommendation on whether the board should approve the petition. Generally, such reports are due within 60 days, but DEP officials said they will require an extension.
The review will cover the proposed regulation’s effectiveness and economic impact as well as “whether it would put Pennsylvania businesses at a competitive disadvantage and whether there are alternatives for more cost-effective or productive means forward than are within the proposal,” DEP’s energy programs director David Althoff said.
If DEP recommends rejecting the petition, it will have about 45 days to make its case to the board for why state rules shouldn’t be changed. If DEP recommends accepting the petition, it will have six months to develop proposed regulatory changes.
The petitioners aimed to make the second option easy by submitting a 250-page draft of regulations it hopes the state will adopt, detailing the structure and specifics of the cap-and-trade program.
DEP can also pick a middle path, proposing to change regulations to address greenhouse gases in another way.
“Ultimately, our evaluation and recommendation is not a binary yes or no,” DEP Secretary Patrick McDonnell said.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.