U.S. Steel Corp.’s sudden Sunday afternoon announcement that it has launched a strategic review of the company’s options in light of “multiple unsolicited proposals” for the company was decoded a few hours later by rival U.S. steelmaker Cleveland-Cliffs.
The Ohio-based company revealed that it had made an offer to buy the Downtown-based firm on July 28 and had just learned on Sunday that its target wasn’t interested. So it decided to go public.
The offer on the table is currently valued around $7.4 billion. It includes a payout of $17.50 in cash and 1.023 shares of Cliffs stock for each share of U.S. Steel stock, a premium of 43% as of Aug. 11, the company said.
“Notwithstanding the compelling economic terms of Cliffs’ offer, it was rejected as being ‘unreasonable’ by the Board of Directors of U.S. Steel via a letter Cliffs received today, August 13, 2023.” the company wrote in a statement. “As such, Cliffs feels compelled to make its offer publicly known for the direct benefit of all of U.S. Steel’s stockholders.”
U.S. Steel then responded to Cliff’s public announcement with another salvo, by publishing the letter that it sent to its suitor.
In a statement sent out around 7 p.m., the company said Cliffs refused to sign a nondisclosure agreement that would allow U.S. Steel to do the due diligence required to assess if the proposal is fair to its shareholders.
Read More
The letter, signed by U.S. Steel President and CEO David Burritt, said U.S. Steel wanted the nondisclosure agreement “so that we could have further clarity on several key issues, including valuation of the stock component of your proposal, regulatory risk and timing as well as the prospects for the combined company.”
He said the company had talked with Cliffs’ lawyers about its concerns and was surprised when, on Aug. 11, Cliffs said it would not sign the agreement unless U.S. Steel agreed to “headline price” of the deal in advance.
“As you well know, our board — or any board — could not, consistent with its fiduciary duties, agree to a proposal of which 50% is represented by your stock without conducting a thorough and completely customary due diligence process, to evaluate the risks and potential upsides and downsides inherent in the transaction, including the stock component,” Mr. Burritt wrote. “Doing otherwise would be tantamount to accepting a price without knowing what it in fact represents.”
The revelations spilled into Monday when Cliffs filed documents with the Securities and Exchange Commission disclosing the text of four letters exchanged between the two steelmakers, starting with Cliff’s original offer on July 28, U.S. Steel’s response Aug. 7, and the two subsequent correspondences.
The documents suggest that Cliffs wanted to move quickly, assuring U.S. Steel that the deal would clear regulatory hurdles and urging the Pittsburgh firm to agree to the financial terms while it does its research.
U.S. Steel wrote it needed to do the research first. On Aug. 7, it sent Cliffs a draft mutual non-disclosure agreement.
“The draft will look familiar,” Mr. Burritt wrote. “It is substantially similar to the form of NDA that our companies previously signed on two separate occasions.”
The back and forth began when U.S. Steel released a cryptic statement around noon on Sunday disclosing that it received “multiple unsolicited proposals” and has hired Barclays Capital Inc. and Goldman Sachs & Co. LLC as financial advisers, along with several law firms to assist in reviewing them.
“U.S. Steel’s board and management team are committed to maximizing value for our stockholders, and to that end, we have commenced a comprehensive and thorough review of strategic alternatives,” Mr. Burritt had said in a statement.
Lourenco Goncalves, chairman, president and CEO of Cleveland-Cliffs, then made his appeal directly to U.S. Steel shareholders, saying he plans to “ramp up capital returns to shareholders and implement a dividend upon completion of the transaction.”
According to the World Steel Association, Cleveland-Cliffs ranks 22nd globally as measured by steel production last year. U.S. Steel ranked 27th.
Combining the two companies would put the resulting firm among the top 10 steel manufacturers in the world, Cleveland-Cliffs said. China is the world’s leader in steel production.
More importantly, Mr. Goncalves said, the proposal has the full backing of the United Steelworkers Union, which represents 14,000 workers at Cliffs and 11,000 at U.S. Steel.
The Downtown-based union vowed in writing to “unequivocally endorse such a transaction.”
“The USW feels that Cliffs is the single steel producer in the best position to ensure that U.S. based manufacturing remains strong in this country,” wrote the union’s international president Thomas Conway in a letter to U.S. Steel dated Aug. 3.
He praised Cliffs for expanding the union workforce when it acquired AK Steel, and ArcelorMittal USA in 2020.
With the transfer of AK Steel’s sprawling Butler works facility north of Pittsburgh, Cliffs became one of the county’s largest employers, according to data compiled by the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry.
Mr. Burritt, in his note, said U.S. Steel received multiple offers ranging from some of its production assets to the company as a whole.
“The board is taking a measured approach to considering these proposals, including seeking more information in order to evaluate proposals that are preliminary and subject to ongoing due diligence and review,” Mr. Burritt said.
In its letter, released around noon, U.S. Steel said it would not make any other statements about the strategic review until it is finished or until such time that it is required to make disclosures. There is no timetable for the review, according to the company.
On a call with analysts last month, Mr. Burritt said the company is “extremely well positioned for what we believe will be the best American steel market in a generation and to capitalize on global trends of deglobalization, decarbonization and digitization to build a stronger, more resilient and more profitable U.S. Steel.”
The 122-year-old firm had 22,740 employees worldwide at the end of last year, which includes 3,700 in southwestern Pennsylvania where U.S. Steel operates its Clairton, Edgar Thomson, and Irvin plants, as well as the company’s corporate office.
The Pittsburgh company’s stock on Monday jumped 25% from its previous close following news that U.S. Steel’s assets are in play. Cliff’s stock also opened higher, albeit not nearly as much.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.