Between the 58th Carnegie International, Pittsburgh’s Eradicate Hate Summit and an upcoming round of fall applications to review, Judith O’Toole’s calendar as the Fine Foundation’s new executive director has been pretty busy. This, coupled with a new team member and the absence of the organization’s co-founder, Milton Fine, seems to usher the foundation towards a new era.

Ms. O’Toole, 69, is the third executive director of the foundation and the first one to work without co-founder Mr. Fine, who died in March 2019.

Based in Pittsburgh, the Fine Foundation supports projects in arts and culture, Jewish life and science and medicine. It was founded in 2007 by Sheila Reicher Fine and Milton Fine and has since provided more than $35 million in grants to over 350 nonprofits in the Pittsburgh region.

New staff also includes Michael Smith, who began as the Fine Foundation’s operations and program officer in early September.

Advertise with us

“Right now Mike and I are in a phase where we're meeting a lot of people, we’re listening, we're trying to really understand what the issues are that nonprofits are facing right now that we can be the most supportive that we can be,” Ms. O’Toole said this month.

Ms. O’Toole also said she and Mr. Smith are currently in learning mode as they work to help the Fine Foundation be one of empathy and “open to the day-to-day issues that our grantees face as well as the big picture.”

“We've both been on the other side of the table requesting funding, so learning about what it's like to be on this side of the table, I think we're both excited about the ability to work through many organizations instead of just one organization in terms of supporting the multiple missions of the organizations that we support and that's really gratifying,” Ms. O’Toole said.

Ms. O’Toole is a familiar name in the Pittsburgh museum scene and comes to the foundation with a background in museum directorship.

A native of Minneapolis, Ms. O’Toole attended Penn State University as a graduate student of art history. She developed an interest in museum work after she realized she could work with objects, art history and people. Since then, her career in museums has spanned around 30 years.

Advertise with us

In 2018, after 25 years as director/CEO, Ms. O’Toole retired from the Westmoreland Museum of American Art in Greensburg. Only three months later, she was contacted by the Mattress Factory for the position of acting director.

For four months, Ms. O’Toole helped “stabilize the institution and then figure out what would be the next stages for it,” she said. Following her stint with contemporary arts, Ms. O’Toole was the interim executive director of The Frick Pittsburgh for nine months in 2019.

“I've been really grateful for the opportunities that have come my way and this one seems really such a great capstone to my career,” she said of her place with the Fine Foundation.

After being recruited in an executive search, Ms. O’Toole started working at the Fine Foundation in late March.

“So I seem to, in my retirement, be in positions of transition and The Fine Foundation is a bit in transition,” Ms. O’Toole said, noting Mr. Fine’s absence.

Advertise with us

Despite this, Ms. O’Toole said Ms. Fine, chairperson of the Fine Foundation, has been “our guiding spirit” as the foundation enters a new phase.

Mr. Fine was the driving force of the foundation, “so his vision for philanthropy really guided us then and, of course, he was there to ensure that,” Ms. O’Toole said. “Now we are looking to how we operate the foundation under his vision but in new times.”

Mr. Fine’s vision lives on in the 58th Carnegie International, an exhibition of contemporary art that brings the work of international artists to Pittsburgh and which opened on Sept. 24.

“Milt was a significant collector of contemporary art and he believed in the power of art to change lives so his contribution toward the endowment of the International was his way of ensuring that this exhibition would continue to come to Pittsburgh or be organized in Pittsburgh and that Pittsburghers would benefit from the exposure to this great art,” Ms. O’Toole said.

Additionally, winners of the Fine Prize, which was created as a gift by the Fine Foundation in 2008, were announced with the exhibition’s opening.

Advertise with us

Earlier that same week, both Ms. O’Toole and Mr. Smith attended the Eradicate Hate Global Summit hosted in Pittsburgh.

The summit grew out of the Tree of Life attack in which a gunman killed 11 worshippers in the synagogue in 2018.

“Jewish life is an important category to the Fine Foundation so both Mike and I are in learning mode about how we support Jewish life in Pittsburgh and this conference is one of those ways,” Ms. O’Toole said.

Mr. Smith, 38, began in early September.

Originally from the Boston area, Mr. Smith, of Marshall, got his start in nonprofit work at Franciscan Volunteer Ministry in Camden, N.J. After receiving his master’s degree in English at Boston College, Mr. Smith eventually moved to Pittsburgh to pursue a Ph.D. in English at Duquesne University.

Advertise with us

Through networking and connecting with others at the organization, Mr. Smith began working at the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust, first as a grant writer before eventually making his way up to assistant director of institutional giving.

Mr. Smith learned of the Fine Foundation as it had granted funding to the Cultural Trust’s festivals. Since then, he was taken by their work, appreciating the thoughtfulness and deliberation the foundation put into their grant-making.

“It was just a kind of a no-brainer,” Mr. Smith said about how he jumped at the chance to interview for the operation and program officer position. “The position was open and I went ‘Oh my gosh. Grantmaking, arts and culture and I can do this a little bit wider scope. I'm going to jump at it.’”

In a move away from his work at the Cultural Trust, Mr. Smith said the Fine Foundation’s focus is on the Greater Pittsburgh region, rather than a single location.

“Grantmaking allows you to kind of touch more people's lives and help more organizations succeed, which I think was always really interesting to me,” Mr. Smith said.

Advertise with us

“Pittsburgh has a fantastic history of support from its institutions and from its private grantmakers,” he said. “Especially in arts and culture, they are so supported institutionally and with its audiences… There's a territorial nature to people from Pittsburgh and I think they support their own and they really like the stuff that comes from here and that's exciting.”

Though applications are invite-only, the foundation’s two-person staff is readying for the influx of proposals ahead of their fall selection cycle. After sorting through applicants, Ms. O’Toole and Mr. Smith will select ones that best align with the foundation’s mission to present to the October board meeting.

Similarly, Ms. O’Toole, who has a home Downtown, called Pittsburgh an incredible city full of creativity and intelligence.

“I think it's really an exciting time,” Ms. O’Toole said. “The difficulty for us is really honing in on where we can really make a difference. What projects are appropriate for us to get behind? Which ones can be the most effective in the various areas that we're interested in?”