The Justice Department is suing to block Penguin Random House from acquiring its smaller rival Simon & Schuster, alleging that the proposed merger would harm American authors and consumers by shrinking an already highly concentrated market and ultimately decreasing the quantity and variety of books.

The department alleges that the deal would allow Penguin Random House, already the largest book publisher in the world, to exert “outsized influence” over which books are published and how much authors are paid. While the market for book publishing should encourage the two publishing houses to compete to acquire manuscripts, offering authors higher advances and sweetening the terms of their contracts, the proposed merger would eliminate this crucial competitiveness, the government alleges.

The complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia on Tuesday, alleges that the nearly $2.2 billion deal would grant Penguin Random House control of nearly half of the market for acquiring publishing rights to anticipated top-selling books, which would leave individual authors with fewer options and less power to negotiate deals.

With less competition, authors would be paid less for their writing, government lawyers argue, in turn diminishing the number and variety of books available to consumers.

Advertise with us

“Books have shaped American public life throughout our nation’s history, and authors are the lifeblood of book publishing in America. But just five publishers control the U.S. publishing industry,” Attorney General Merrick Garland said in a news release Tuesday. “If the world’s largest book publisher is permitted to acquire one of its biggest rivals, it will have unprecedented control over this important industry. American authors and consumers will pay the price of this anticompetitive merger - lower advances for authors and ultimately fewer books and less variety for consumers.”

In a memo to staffers Tuesday, Simon & Schuster president and CEO Jonathan Karp said both publishers are committed to fighting the lawsuit and bringing the deal to fruition.

The companies “strongly disagree with the DOJ that this transaction will harm competition and believe firmly that there is no basis for these claims,” Mr. Karp said.

He emphasized that the Justice Department is not alleging the transaction would harm competition in the sale of books. According to the complaint, the government’s case centers on the potential harm it would have on American workers and, ultimately, consumers.

Markus Dohle, the chief executive of Penguin Random House, said the goal of the combined company is to expand the company’s array of imprints “that will operate independently and autonomously and will continue to compete vigorously among themselves and with outside competitors.”

Advertise with us

Daniel Petrocelli, vice chair of O’Melveny & Myers and Penguin Random House’s lead trial attorney, said that “DOJ’s lawsuit is wrong on the facts, the law and public policy.”

“The publishing industry is strong and vibrant and has seen strong growth at all levels,” he said. “We are confident that the robust and competitive landscape that exists will ensure a decision that the acquisition will promote, not harm, competition.”

The antitrust challenge comes roughly a year after the announced merger, when Bertelsmann SE, the parent company of Penguin Random House, agreed to buy Simon & Schuster from its parent, ViacomCBS.

The publishing houses represent two of the five most dominant players in the United States, known as the “Big Five.” They generally command larger marketing budgets, have a deep catalogue of successful older titles and operate on a much larger scale, allowing the publishers to spread the risk of investing in authors over more titles and offer larger advances to secure the most promising book projects.

According to its website, Penguin Random House publishes 70,000 digital and 15,000 print titles annually. Simon & Schuster publishes about 2,000 titles a year.

Advertise with us

Critics of the proposed merger contend that fewer publishers means fewer potential buyers for authors’ proposals and manuscripts, leading to further homogenization in the reading world.

The publishing industry has experienced significant changes in recent years as online retailers helped shift consumer behavior away from brick-and-mortar bookstores. The rise of streaming services, podcasts and audiobooks has also reshaped the media landscape.

The pandemic, too, has left its mark on media consumption, as people stayed at home, craving stories and pastimes to pursue. In 2020, print book sales in the United States had their best year in a decade, reaching 751 million units, up 8.2% from the year prior, according to market research company the NDP Group.