The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission has denied Erie native Matt Barnes’ application for a license to run a business arranging limousine rides in Pennsylvania.
The decision follows a recommendation in October by an administrative law judge to deny the license after finding Mr. Barnes’ company — Walten Point Productions — was unfit to operate in the state. The rejection also follows a settlement this summer with the Pennsylvania attorney general’s office under which Mr. Barnes agreed to change his business practices.
Mr. Barnes, who applied for the license in September 2019, called the PUC’s decision a “huge win.”
“Our customers win either way because during this process we determined the federal government doesn’t require us to have this license anyhow, which ultimately gives us the ability to still serve customers in PA regardless if the PA PUC issues us this license or not,” Mr. Barnes wrote in an email.
The decision, he said, “can still be appealed or further petitioned either way also.”
The PUC declined to comment specifically on Mr. Barnes’ statement.
“The commissioners’ order is very clear,” spokesman Nils Hagen-Frederiksen said in an email. He noted that the judge’s recommendation had cited the relevant sections of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Code requiring transportation brokers to have a license.
Mr. Barnes has had run-ins with the PUC in the past.
In 2016, the agency fined another of his companies — Barnes Professional Limousine Service — for exposing passengers to unsafe conditions. In 2018 and 2019, the PUC’s investigation and enforcement division recommended fines against the company for operating in the state without a certificate. The company paid the fines in September 2019 “under protest,” PUC records show.
In December 2019, the Pennsylvania attorney general sued Mr. Barnes, alleging he broke consumer protection laws. The lawsuit followed a story in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that detailed numerous allegations from customers who said they were charged exorbitant hidden fees.
Under a settlement with the AG’s office announced this August, Mr. Barnes agreed to change business practices and pay restitution plus a civil penalty that was suspended unless the settlement terms are violated.
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.