For three decades, retirees have clung to the so-called “4% rule” as gospel — the idea that withdrawing 4% of their nest egg each year would keep them financially secure for life.
Now, its creator, financial researcher Bill Bengen, says it’s time for an upgrade.
Mr. Bengen’s new analysis, laid out in his recent book “A Richer Retirement: Supercharging the 4% Rule to Spend More and Enjoy More,” raises the safe withdrawal rate to 4.7% — a 17.5% pay raise for retirees.
That means for a $1 million portfolio, retirees who were sticking to the rule and only withdrawing $40,000 per year can still be safe withdrawing $47,000 per year.
On Sept. 18, Squirrel Hill financial adviser James Lange is bringing Mr. Bengen here for a free public event at the Courtyard by Marriott Pittsburgh University Center in Oakland to talk about what the change means.
Mr. Lange believes the revised rule could be life-changing, giving retirees permission to spend more freely on experiences that enrich their lives — such as vacations and family gatherings — instead of holding back out of fear of the well running dry.
Read More
Post-Gazette: What factors do you think prompted Bill Bengen — the originator of the 4% rule — to raise his recommendation to 4.7%. And do you agree with his reasoning?
Mr. Lange: In his original analysis published in 1994, Bill assumed a portfolio of only large capitalization U.S. stocks and U.S. government bonds. In his updated analysis, he assumes a more diversified portfolio, which is a larger factor than any changes to the economy.
Bill did retirees an enormous service by updating his analysis. He recognized that today’s investors have a significantly more diversified portfolio than when he published his original research in 1994.
PG: You feel like the updated 4.7% withdrawal rate empowers retirees to live more fully and confidently about withdrawing more money?
Mr. Lange: Millions of retirees and financial advisers have been following the classic 4% safe withdrawal rate rule. The updated analysis in effect gives retirees permission to withdraw an additional 17.5% annually without significantly increasing the risk of running out of money.
I am hoping most retirees will take this advice to heart and start withdrawing the additional 17.5% from their portfolio. I am not suggesting retirees use this money to buy things. I am a strong advocate for using this money to pay for new experiences, which is consistent with recent happiness studies.
PG: In what ways have you seen retirees reward themselves with experiences?
Mr. Lange: For example, my clients are very familiar with my 101-year-old father-in-law who sponsors an annual vacation for his entire family, including children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren. What a legacy!
My daughter has a sense of clan that will be with her for life. The family is already making plans to continue this tradition even after my father-in-law passes.
But there are multiple other ways to offer family support, for instance, helping grandchildren with their education, or helping their children contribute money to their retirement plans. Another popular choice is to support their favorite charities more generously.
PG: Do you think this is a permanent shift in safe withdrawal thinking, or more of a reflection of today’s market and interest rate environment?
Mr. Lange: As long as retirees have a well-diversified portfolio and stay within the reasonable assumptions [Mr. Bengen] provides, they can safely rely on withdrawing an extra 17.5% of their portfolio every year for the foreseeable future.
PG: How might this change affect retirees’ risk of running out of money, especially during periods of market volatility or high inflation?
Mr. Lange: Fortunately, the updated 4.7% benchmark takes into account periods of market volatility and/or high inflation.
As long as retirees have a well-diversified portfolio and stay within the reasonable presumptions Bill provides, they can safely rely on withdrawing an extra 17.5%.
PG: Does the higher withdrawal rate make sense for all retirees, or only those with certain investment portfolios, spending habits, or life expectancy?
Mr. Lange: A well-diversified portfolio with many asset classes is safer than a portfolio consisting of just U.S. large stocks and U.S. intermediate government bonds. So, even if you don’t adhere exactly to his recommendations, I still think you can withdraw a greater percentage from a well-diversified portfolio.
If a retiree chooses to spend less money, they will be more likely to leave a larger inheritance, or it could give them a cushion to spend more later. If a retiree chooses to spend more money now and they are unwilling to cut their spending in the event of a downturn, they will increase the risk of running out of money.
Life expectancy is a critical issue. Individuals may have a shorter or longer life expectancy than 30 years. A retiree with a 10-year life expectancy can safely withdraw 13.42% of their money. But for married couples, the more critical issue is planning for the surviving spouse to live as comfortably as when both spouses were alive. The real question becomes how long will the survivor of the couple live?
PG: Would someone with a pension or rental income have more flexibility to adopt a higher withdrawal rate?
Mr. Lange: If someone has additional income, whether it is a pension, rental income, or more likely Social Security, they will add that income to their 4.7% withdrawal from their portfolio.
PG: What specific signs should a retiree look for that it’s time to cut back?
Mr. Lange: I fear health costs for many retirees will go up significantly. If health care costs constitute a large percentage of their spending and they can’t comfortably make other cuts, they should consider not spending all of that extra 17.5%.
Want to see an “In Conversation With” Q&A with a local business figure? Send suggestions to business@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.