When it comes to retirement planning, Robert Fragasso has seen it all.
With decades of experience guiding clients through the financial maze of their golden years, the chairman and CEO of Fragasso Financial Advisors in Sewickley knows what works — and what can unravel even the best laid plans.
In this candid “In Conversation With” interview, Mr. Fragasso shares his strategies for stretching your nest egg through a balanced portfolio and reasonable withdrawals of 4% to 5% annually.
He also sounds the alarm on the biggest threat to a retiree’s financial future — large, impulsive withdrawals for luxury items and lavish events.
“When a client says he or she is withdrawing a meaningful amount for a special one-time event, like taking the family on a cruise or the wedding of a granddaughter, it hits the portfolio in a manner that often cannot be mitigated,” Mr. Fragasso said.
In one particularly sobering case, Mr. Fragasso recalls a former client who ignored his advice and drained her savings to buy a second home in Florida. The outcome was a harsh financial reality check.
Read More
Post-Gazette: Can you share an example of someone who made a big-ticket purchase in retirement that ended up jeopardizing their financial security — even after getting advice to the contrary?
Mr. Fragasso: Some years back, a widowed client said she wanted to buy a home in Florida while keeping her house in Pittsburgh. I did the calculations and advised her that she could not afford to do both and needed to choose.
I asked her — why a house in Florida? And she replied that she wasn’t meeting eligible men in Pittsburgh. I told her she would hurt herself by doing this. That was too final for her, and she reacted by moving to another adviser who said “Sure, why not do that?”
I saw her accountant some years thereafter who advised that she had spent down her money and was living on Social Security and in one modest house in Florida.
PG: How do one-time, large withdrawals — like paying for a grandchild’s wedding or a family cruise — impact a retiree’s long-term financial security? Are clients often surprised by the ripple effects?
Mr. Fragasso: Retirees usually withdraw a set amount and/or sporadic amounts from some accumulated personal and retirement plan savings. Taking a large withdrawal from that asset pool reduces the amount of assets available to generate income and may cause the retiree to unexpectedly run out of capital if adjustments aren’t made to those withdrawals. That is termed “running out of money before running out of breath” versus the more desirable reverse.
PG: Have you worked with clients who’ve regretted major discretionary spending in retirement? If so, what can others learn from those situations?
Mr. Fragasso: Yes, we’ve encountered clients who have made that mistake in not calculating the impact of the withdrawal before doing so. They come to us after the fact once they realize they are in trouble. It is much more painful to correct the error rather than anticipating it before it happens. And that usually requires significant adjustments to income withdrawals and lifestyle.
PG: How do you help clients balance the emotional impulse to spend on meaningful life events with the financial reality of maintaining income through an uncertain lifespan?
Mr. Fragasso: The initial desired amounts for gifting, and income needs are a starting point. If the calculations work with those numbers, the client can move confidently forward with the proposed actions.
If the numbers don’t work, that discussion will require adjusting the amount of the gift and/or the amount of needed lifetime income.
Remember that inflation looms large in that calculation. If you doubt that, consider what you needed 20 years ago and what you must have now to live comfortably.
That difference came primarily from inflation and the average retirement period is about 20 years. Don’t assume you will spend less during retirement, as you will spend the same, but just on different things.
PG: What role does timing play in making large withdrawals? For example, taking money out in a market downturn versus a strong market? How do you help clients navigate that risk?
Mr. Fragasso: The ideal is to gift during up-market periods. Doing so when markets are depressed removes those assets from the potential recovery that has always occurred after a downturn.
If it is necessary to withdraw during a market downturn, take the needed capital from the less volatile portion of the portfolio or from savings. That way it is less likely that the gains from an upturn will be negatively impacted.
PG: Over the years of working with retirees, what habits or mindset have you seen in clients who successfully sustain their nest eggs while still gifting and enjoying a fulfilling retirement?
Mr. Fragasso: Removing emotionalism from the decision is mandatory. Your investments and financial security are a business and must be treated so. The gifting intent can be handled, but it must be done in the most efficient and assured manner.
Considering the effects of taxation lessens the cost of giving. Some examples include gifting from an IRA under mandatory distribution rules directly to a charity. Another is gifting appreciated securities to a lower-tax-bracket family member rather than selling, incurring tax consequences and gifting cash.
Want to see a conversation with a Pittsburgh business leader? Send suggestions to business@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.