Sydney Sweeney’s internet takeover — with an assist from American Eagle Outfitters — has sparked a political firestorm online.

Some say Ms. Sweeney’s ad campaign with the Pittsburgh-based teen clothier has racist undertones, while others praise it as signaling an end to “wokeness.”

But while social media users can’t seem to stop talking about the “White Lotus” and “Euphoria” star’s ads, marketing experts are watching to see whether the publicity that has brought attention to the brand ends up helping or hurting it in the long run.

The campaign titled “Sydney Sweeney has great jeans” initiated an online debate over race and beauty standards. One promotional video features a blonde, blue-eyed Ms. Sweeney, saying “my jeans are blue” after explaining that “genes are passed down from parents to offspring, often determining traits like hair color, personality and even eye color.”

Advertise with us

Some social media users claim the messaging fuels eugenics and white supremacist ideology. Others say that’s an overreaction. A new Economist/YouGov poll found that 12% of respondents find the ad “offensive,” while 39% deem it “clever.”

With Ms. Sweeney’s modern-day western movie “Americana” scheduled to release on Aug. 15, the added attention might not be so bad for the Emmy-nominated actress. 

And what some might assume is a PR nightmare for American Eagle, industry experts say actually, for the most part, has turned out to be a blessing in disguise. In short, the retailer took a risk — and it’s paying off — for now.

“Negative publicity still drives sales,” said Melanie Querry, founder of Spots and Dots, a marketing and advertising agency headquartered in Downtown. “I think the pros actually outweigh the cons.”

Stock price surge

American Eagle’s stock price soared the day President Donald Trump offered a resounding endorsement of Ms. Sweeney and her ad campaign.

Advertise with us

Long term? “It might bring in more people who follow Trump to go and buy those jeans, but it may also have turned off people who are more on the left side,” said Ryan Garvey, professor of finance at Duquesne University. “So it can go both ways.”

American Eagle’s stock price had been trending downward for some time. In a May earnings call, CEO Jay Schottenstein said he was "disappointed" with the company’s first quarter performance. At the brand level, American Eagle comparable store sales were down 2% and intimates brand Aerie’s declined 4%.

In May, investment firm J.P. Morgan had a neutral rating on the company’s stock, saying it believes that long-term, American Eagle will have solid sales growth, but cited concerns that “consumer choppiness” over the past six months could force the company to take markdowns on some of its products.

As with many other retail brands, market uncertainty as a result of tariffs is hitting American Eagle. The company partners with apparel manufacturers that operate over 300 factories in more than 20 countries, according to its website.

“We continue to take steps to mitigate the impact of tariffs, using all levers at our disposal as it makes sense for our business,” Mr. Schottenstein said during the earnings call.

Advertise with us

Ahead of Ms. Sweeney’s campaign’s launch, American Eagle’s leadership hoped its advertising would drive sales as fall — a critical time of year for the brand — rolls around and students return to school.

“We want to be clean and mean for back-to-school,” Jen Foyle, president and executive creative director of American Eagle and Aerie, said in May. “It's our Super Bowl season.”

As the ad’s controversy fades from the public eye, the company’s stock will likely revert back to trending downward, Mr. Garvey said. Future sales reports are expected to paint a fuller picture.

“[Trump] has the ability to move markets when he talks,” he said. “But it’s yet to be determined how things are going to play out.”

Sofia Gray, a former American Eagle employee at the Grove City Outlets, said the controversy is making her think twice about where she’ll buy her next pair of jeans.

Advertise with us

“It’s made me want to shop there less,” Ms. Gray said. “It throws me off.”

Mike Giunta, chief creative officer at marketing agency GH Advertising, Downtown, said brands should not be entirely afraid of controversy and leaning into “edgy and provocative” advertising.

“There’s nothing that waters down a good campaign more than trying to make everybody happy,” he said. “We’re competing for eyeballs and you want something that’s gonna break through.”

Social media buzz

Of course, after an ad hits social media, there’s not much that can be done to control it.

“Once an ad is out there, it’s really not yours anymore,” Mr. Giunta said. “It only takes one person to elevate something these days with social media … they can assign values to your brand or your commercial that were not part of your intentions.”

Advertise with us

Although buzz about the American Eagle ad campaign has been beneficial for the South Side-based clothing retailer in the short term, ad professionals warn there is still a possibility of damage for the brand in the long run. 

“American Eagle’s got some short term traction, but beyond that, what I see is long term uncertainty,” said Paul Furiga, president of WordWrite, a Pittsburgh-based public relations firm.

Jenna Lo Castro, an associate professor of public relations, advertising and social media at Point Park University, said the focus should be on the lasting implications. “Brand image and reputation far outweighs a short-term sales lift,” she said.

For now, the extra attention has some benefits. The backlash is likely not enough to “harm” the product or the brand, even as people sharing their negative opinions on social media go viral, Ms. Querry said.

“You don’t want to launch anything that’s controversial,” she said. “But I’m here to tell you that in the end, it does drive extra exposure.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Lo Castro said we are in a “historical moment” where brands are taking positions on certain things, making it inevitable that an ad like this would incite a large-scale conversation.

“Brands are inherently political,” Ms. Lo Castro said. “It’s just kind of the role that they play within our culture and society.”

Responding to backlash

American Eagle did not directly address the criticism when defending the ad on social media. “Her jeans. Her story,” the company wrote. “Great jeans look good on everyone.”

“Silence is currently the strategy,” Ms. Lo Castro said.

“Their response was safe,” she said of the company’s statement. “I think it was concise and … lacked a thoroughness and responsiveness necessary for addressing an issue like this.”

Advertise with us

While not saying anything still generates discourse, Ms. Lo Castro said, she thinks there’s more to come. “I don’t think we’ve heard the last from American Eagle,” she said. 

Mr. Giunta said the statement from the company showed that they were expecting a response from the public. “They had their ducks in a row and were prepared for any reaction,” he said.

So far, American Eagle is handling the pushback “pretty well,” although it only takes one social media post for that to change, Mr. Giunta said.

“It was a very measured response,” he said. “They didn’t over explain or apologize … A lot of this controversy came out from other people making statements about it, nothing they made.”

Advertising professionals say Ms. Sweeney’s marketing campaign is a departure from American Eagle’s typical advertising. That has the potential to cause “brand misalignment.”

Advertise with us

“Their past campaigns have focused a lot on body positivity and inclusivity,” Ms. Lo Castro said. “If this is the direction they’re going in, I certainly think it’s going to shift how consumers see them.”

For Ms. Gray, 18, Ms. Sweeney’s ad seems to be targeting the wrong group. “It feels like they’re trying to appeal more to men than they are to women, even though they’re advertising women’s jeans,” she said.

That was a complaint heard in the past about clothing chains such as Victoria’s Secret and Abercrombie. 

Ms. Gray described the American Eagle ads she’s seen previously as “upbeat and girly,” while this one is more “serious” and “sexual.” 

That might have been the intention. Ahead of the campaign’s release, Craig Brommers, chief marketing officer, told Women’s Wear Daily that he expected the campaign to “push buttons,” describing it as “a little more sensual” than the company’s advertising has been in recent years.

Advertise with us

As analysts warn of the campaign’s risks, many see it as a learning opportunity for others in the industry. With companies and advertising professionals watching this unfold on the national stage, other clothing brands are "probably jealous,” Mr. Giunta said. 

“This is the brand everyone’s talking about right now,” he said. “It’s an opportunity for other brands to learn without actually being in the fray.”