Last week, Moody’s Investor Service downgraded U.S. government debt from its highest level, joining the other two big credit rating agencies, which had already made this move. The downgrade itself didn’t convey much new information: investors already know the ins and outs of the nation’s long-term fiscal outlook.

But the Moody’s announcement is one more sign that the U.S. needs to make some tough choices in the years ahead about taxes and spending. And at this point there seems to be little appetite in Washington to make those tough choices.

Moody’s, along with Standard and Poor’s and Fitch Ratings, is one of the world’s largest credit rating agencies. These companies rate various kinds of debt, such as corporate and municipal bonds, and the ratings tell investors the likelihood that the borrower will be able to pay back its debts.

The agencies also rate sovereign debt issued by national governments, including U.S. government debt, known as Treasurys. The federal government borrows money because it runs budget deficits, with revenues (primarily taxes) less than spending. The government borrows money by issuing a Treasury with a promise to pay back the money later, with interest, at a set point in the future. The borrowing can be short term or long term, with Treasurys ranging from one month to 30 years.

Advertise with us

Last Friday, Moody’s lowered the credit rating on U.S. Treasurys from AAA, the most credit-worthy, one notch lower to Aa1. This followed similar moves by the other two large rating agencies, which had both downgraded U.S. government debt from the highest level over the past 14 years. Moody’s cited high levels of debt, expected large future budget deficits, and increased economic uncertainty in announcing the downgrade.

Although this was a big story in the media, financial markets barely responded, with yields little-changed on Treasurys.

That’s because the downgrade wasn’t news to investors.

When Moody’s rates a local school district bond, for example, it is providing new and useful information to investors who don’t have the ability, time, or inclination to delve into the district’s finances the way the rating agency can. Therefore, a ratings change there can have a big impact on the interest rate that investors require to hold the security.

But U.S. Treasury markets are the most liquid in the world, drawing in sophisticated investors from all over the globe, and information about the U.S. government’s current and projected finances are readily available from myriad public and private-sector sources at the click of a mouse. The Moody’s downgrade just reaffirmed information that investors already had, with minimal impact on Treasury yields.

Advertise with us

While financial markets barely responded, the Moody’s downgrade is a signal that the U.S. needs to get its fiscal house in order.

U.S. debt held by private investors is now 99% the size of the economy (GDP), near a record high, although down from during the pandemic. More worrisomely, debt is projected to grow rapidly. The U.S. is already running big budget deficits, of around 6% of GDP, and they are set to increase in the years ahead.

The retirement of the baby boomers will lead to big increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare, tax cuts are coming under the Trump administration, and spending cuts are unlikely to make up the difference. In addition, Treasury yields have increased dramatically over the past few years, with much higher interest costs for the government.

According to the latest estimates from the bipartisan Congressional Budget Office, debt held by the public is set to increase to 156% of GDP by 2055 (see Chart 1). And this likely understates the problem as the CBO projections make some unrealistic assumptions, such as assuming that the tax cuts passed in the first Trump administration are not renewed when they expire at the end of this year.

Debt at that level is likely to “crowd out” private investment, leading to slower economic growth over the longer run. And rising interest payments on the debt will make it more difficult to fund other government priorities, such as defense, infrastructure, health care and education.

Advertise with us

The solution is obvious, but politically unpalatable: The federal government needs to either raise taxes, cut spending, or both.

Federal spending as a share of GDP is above its long-run average and climbing higher, although it is down from the pandemic. And revenues relative to the size of the economy are below their long-run average (see Chart 2). It’s not necessary to balance the budget — since governments live forever they never have to completely pay back their debts. That’s especially true for the U.S., which benefits by issuing Treasurys, the world’s safe-haven security, keeping interest rates here low.

But deficit rising more quickly than the economy expands will eventually mean weaker economic growth and less improvement in living standards over the long run. And that, in turn, could jeopardize the U.S.’s standing as the strongest economy in the world.

Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.