This holiday season is shaping up to be another good one for retailers.
With a solid job market, good wage growth and slowing inflation, consumers have money to spend, and PNC expects holiday sales to increase about 5% from 2023. With goods prices down slightly over the past year, the increase will come from higher volumes.
Although high inflation has been a problem for U.S. households over the past few years, they are generally in solid shape. Most importantly, the labor market is very good.
The unemployment rate is up slightly over the past year — it was 4.2% in November, up from 3.7% in November 2023 — but that is still well below the long-run average. Job growth remains good, with average monthly gains of 180,000 through the first eleven months of 2024, but businesses are still having some difficulties in finding workers.
This trend, combined with the fact that inflation has been slowing, means average wages have been increasing more quickly than prices for more than two years. Over the past year average hourly earnings are up 4% over the past year, compared to inflation of 2.6%. The labor market is the most important driver of consumer spending and the ongoing strength is a big positive.

Other factors are also positive for holiday sales. Strong growth in housing prices is a plus for homeowners, who are wealthier thanks to rising home values and more willingness to spend. Similarly, for higher-income households in particular, the big run-up in stock prices over the past couple of years has boosted household wealth and the willingness to make purchases.
Read More
Another factor that will support holiday spending in 2024 is good consumer balance sheets.
It is true that consumers have borrowed more in recent years, but at the same time incomes have been rising, making it easier for households to pay off their debts. Households took advantage of stimulus payments in 2020 and 2021 to pay off their high interest rate debt. And with interest rates at record lows in the aftermath of the pandemic they refinanced much of their debt at lower rates, allowing them to reduce their payments.
As a result the debt-service ratio — the share of after-tax personal income going to finance debt like mortgage, car, credit card and student loan payments — is lower than it was before the pandemic. It is also much lower than it was heading into the Great Recession in 2007, when households had taken on a lot of housing debt (see Chart).
There are some drags on consumer spending at the end of 2024. While on average wages have risen more rapidly than prices over the past couple of years, that is not true for all workers. In particular, much of the strong wage growth of the past few years has been for workers who have switched jobs in search of higher pay. This means that wage growth has been weaker for workers who have stayed with the same employer.
For some lower- and middle-income households the big increase in prices over the last few years has sapped their buying power. These households are also less likely to own their homes or stocks, so have not benefitted from higher prices for these assets. In addition, interest rates, although they have headed lower this year, are still much higher than they were a few years ago, making it more expensive for consumers to borrow.
Overall, PNC expects holiday sales in 2024 to be up more than 5% from last year. This compares to growth of around 4% in 2023 and 5% in 2022.
But while in 2022 and 2023 much of the growth in holiday spending was due to higher prices, that is not the case in 2024.
Goods prices are actually down slightly over the past year, meaning that the increase in holiday spending in 2024 will come entirely from higher volumes.
One trend that remains firmly in place is the increasing importance of online sales. PNC’s forecast is that e-commerce holiday sales will be up by 9% this year, compared to less than 3% growth for traditional brick-and-mortar retail. As shoppers get increasingly comfortable making purchases online, the e-commerce share of sales will continue to increase.
Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.