When Sara Minshull’s clients fell in love with an 80-year-old house in Ross Township recently, they didn’t expect a bidding war with 12 other buyers — or that they would win it by waiving the home inspection.
“My buyers really wanted it. They paid cash and waived all contingencies. And that’s how they got it,” said Ms. Minshull, a local Redfin real estate agent.
It’s the kind of gamble many Pittsburgh homebuyers are taking because in this city older houses — which can hide big-ticket surprises — make up the majority of what’s on the market and what people are buying.
In fact, the typical home sold in Pittsburgh last year was 68 years old, nearly double the national average of 36 years, according to Redfin, a real estate broker and mortgage originator based in Seattle.
Redfin found that Pittsburgh has the second-oldest housing stock among the 100 largest U.S. metro areas. Buffalo is No. 1.
The aging housing stock in both Pittsburgh and Buffalo reflect a common history.
Read More
Both cities grew rapidly in the early 1900s during America’s industrialization. But they both fell into decline in the second half of the 20th century.
“The need for construction fell off because the overall economy wasn’t growing and people weren’t trying to move to these cities anymore,” said Daryl Fairweather, an economist at Redfin.
An overstock of old houses from the turn of the century became a modern-day advantage.
“More recently, since the pandemic, Pittsburgh and Buffalo and some of these other Rust Belt cities have seen an increase in demand because of remote work,” Ms. Fairweather said.
“People can live in these places without needing to have a local job,” she said. “Because the housing is so affordable, they can get a much lower cost of living if they do that.”
In Pittsburgh, homes built in the previous five years sold for a median price of $460,000 in 2024 — more than double the $211,000 price of homes over 30 years old, Redfin said.
Redfin analyzed multi-list data on the age of homes bought between 2012 (as far back as the real estate company’s records go) and 2024. Newer homes in the analysis are considered less than five years old and older homes are more than 30 years old.
The homes people are buying are getting older across all types, according to Redfin. Condos are aging the most — to a median 38 years in 2024 from 26 years in 2012.

America’s housing stock overall is getting older, and it’s not because buyers prefer vintage homes. It’s because builders haven’t built enough new ones, said Sheharyar Bokhari, a Redfin senior economist.
“Without more construction, buyers are forced to chose from a pool of aging properties that present a new set of financial challenges, especially for those trying to save enough money to climb onto the property ladder,” he said.
“Older homes have aging systems, energy inefficiencies, and a steady stream of maintenance costs that can quickly add up after move-in.”
While waiving the home inspection might seal the deal in a hot market, it can also turn a dream home into a financial sinkhole.
Trouble could be brewing behind the walls. A roof might be nearing the end of its lifespan. The HVAC system might be outdated. A bad sewer line could cost tens of thousands to repair.
“There’s a lot of homes in this area that still have original slate roofs that have a life span of 100 years, give or take,” Ms. Minshull said.
You’re not likely to find a 10-year-old home in Squirrel Hill, but that doesn’t make the neighborhood less desirable, she said.
“Buyers tend to be less focused on the date the home was built — whether it was 1900 or 1925,” she said. “They are more focused on whether the home has central air, and what has been done to it in the last 100 years since it was built.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.