Pittsburgh apartments have been shrinking.

And if you’re living with roommates or raising a family, good luck finding enough space.

“The demographic in Pittsburgh is changing,” said Doug Kessler, a researcher at RentCafe, an apartment search website based in Santa Barbara, Calif.

As the classic two-bedroom, two-bathroom set-up has faded from favor over the past 10 years, Pittsburgh apartments have been getting smaller, according to a recent report by RentCafe.

Advertise with us

Indeed, more than two-thirds of new apartment units built here in the last decade have been studios and one-bedrooms designed for solo occupants.

“Pittsburgh has excellent universities and is attempting to become a tech hub,” Mr. Kessler said. “When people graduate from an institution, they prefer to stay in the same area of the institution they attended.”

Therefore, he asked: “Why build a large two-bedroom, two-bath when people don’t want that?”

The average size of a newly built apartment in Pittsburgh is now just 820 square feet — well below the national average of 908 square feet, according to RentCafe. Pittsburgh has seen the nation’s 10th biggest drop in average apartment size over the past decade, losing 116 square feet, which is about the size of a home office.

That means families and roommates hoping to split rent could have a harder time finding housing spacious enough to accommodate them, if they prefer newer buildings.

Advertise with us

“When you compare our market to others, traditionally Pittsburgh did not have newer more luxury buildings until recently — around the 2010s,” said Bryan McCann, senior vice president of capital markets at Colliers, Downtown.

He said the 25- to 35-year-old demographic that rents by choice prefers to live in smaller, more efficient units inside buildings that have social amenities like conference centers that allow them to work from home.

“You’re getting the trade-off for space within your unit for amenities within your building that you can take advantage of,” Mr. McCann said. “It’s a universal trend.”

But it’s a notable shift for Pittsburgh, he said.

“We used to be older, bigger, two-bedroom units,” he said. “That’s not what’s attracting the current renter base.”

Advertise with us

While apartments are getting smaller nationwide, in some markets — such as New York — they’ve actually grown slightly.

Tallahassee, Fla., is the No. 1 ranked city for largest apartments, measuring an average 1,130 square feet. Seattle, Wash. has the smallest apartments in the nation, measuring an average of 649 square feet, according to RentCafe.

Around 600,000 new apartment units were built in the U.S. last year, according to YardiMatrix, a real estate data and intelligence site. This year, 536,000 will come onboard, which represents 3% of the existing stock nationwide.

In Pittsburgh, about 1,000 new apartment units are in the pipeline for this year — just barely 1% of the existing stock. Next year, the number is projected to rise to 1,400, still only 1.4% of the total inventory.

“From a developer’s standpoint, anything north of 3% is aggressive growth,” Mr. Kessler said. “They use that number to determine if they will have the broad consumer base of people to consume the product. So, if you relate to 3% being aggressive consumer demand, what developers are seeing when they look at Pittsburgh is — it’s not a very robust number.”

Advertise with us

It’s not just Pittsburgh, he said. Cleveland has similar issues.

While Pittsburgh’s market for high-end rentals is not as strong as other cities, the Steel City does stand out for its affordable housing stock.

“One of the unique things about Pittsburgh right now is that in almost 95% of the country, it is cheaper to rent than it is to buy — assuming you can find a house.” Mr. Kessler said. “Well, in Pittsburgh, that’s the opposite.”

With the median price of a home in the Pittsburgh area at around $230,000, the monthly payment on a 30-year mortgage at 6.8% (with a 20% down payment) comes to about $1,200 a month.

“That’s less than the average rental price,” Mr. Kessler said.

Advertise with us

According to RentCafe, the average rent in Pittsburgh is $1,751. In Downtown, the average rent is $1,778, while Mount Washington averages $1,711. Other neighborhoods like Shadyside and Friendship have average rents of $1,755 and $1,667, respectively.

New apartment construction often occurs near universities and caters to young professionals on the go.

“People don’t want to spend 90% of their time in their house,” Mr. Kessler said. “They don’t want to be burdened necessarily by the house or the housing costs.”

Meanwhile, New York City apartments are notoriously small — but they’re actually getting slightly bigger, the report stated.

The average apartment size in Queens is now 702 square feet, an increase of 39 square feet, or 6%, over the past 10 years, according to RentCafe.

Advertise with us

Josh Fischer, managing director at Birgo Realty on the North Side, said Pittsburgh’s Class A apartment pipeline has shifted to smaller units and more amenities and shared living spaces to maximize renter value.

“In contrast, markets like New York are moving in the opposite direction, leveraging adaptive reuse of oversized office buildings to create larger, luxury-oriented residences ” Mr. Fischer said.

“Both trends reflect local realities,” Mr. Fischer said. “Pittsburgh is prioritizing attainability and scale, while New York is unlocking value through high-end transformation.”