Compass Real Estate — the nation’s largest residential broker — has been trying to play a version of gatekeeper by keeping new home listings private long enough for its own agents and clients to get first dibs.
But Zillow — the nation’s largest real estate portal — says it won’t play along.
In a recent move that sent a bombshell through the real estate industry, Zillow announced that starting May 1, it will blacklist any property that starts its life behind Compass’s “private” curtain.
“A listing marketed to any buyer should be marketed to all buyers,” Zillow said in an April 10 statement on its website. “Consumers should not have to wonder whether the home that might be perfect for them is hidden behind a gate they didn’t know existed.”
Zillow’s new standards require that any new listing put on a multiple listing service — a database where agents and brokers share information on properties for sale, such as West Penn Multi-List — be published on websites like Zillow within 24 hours of the start of a public marketing campaign.
But Compass has been keeping many listings off the multi-list services, making them private with limited accessibility — meaning the general public could not view the listing until Compass agents have a chance to market them to buyers for an exclusive period of time.
Read More
A Compass Real Estate spokesman declined to comment on how or if the company will respond to Zillow’s pledge to ban private listings on Zillow’s website.
But the battle between two giants in the real estate industry could reshape how houses are bought and sold in the U.S., since the outcome could determine who sees which houses and when, industry analysts said.
Compass Real Estate is the nation’s largest residential real estate broker by volume with over $231 billion in sales in 2024. The company has 174 agents in the Pittsburgh region, according to Compass.
In an email sent to Compass agents on March 26, Compass founder and CEO Robert Reffkin defended the private listings by saying “homeowners deserve more control over how their homes are marketed, and Compass agents have been on the right side of change.”
The National Association of Realtors appears to back Compass based on a new policy it introduced last month called “Multiple Listing Options for Sellers,” which allows owners to list their homes for sale in more limited, private ways than the broad multiple listing services.
Ironically, the NAR’s new policy will operate alongside its current Clear Cooperation Policy, which requires listing brokers to submit their listings to the MLS within one business day of marketing a property publicly, a policy designed to ensure fair competition.
A divided industry
Consumer advocates, meanwhile, are calling foul on private listings.
“Private listings are terrible for buyers, because they are denied access to those listings,” said Stephen Brobeck, a senior fellow at the Consumer Policy Center in Washington, D.C.
“It’s even bad in most cases for sellers,” he said. “The choice is between exposing your property to the broadest array of buyers, or restricting your property to a more limited set of buyers.”
Mr. Brobeck said a company could benefit from keeping listings in-house in order to increase the likelihood of its agents collecting a dual commission from both the sale and purchase of a single home.
Compass, however, has described its three-phase “private listings” as a way to give homeowners more control over how their listings are marketed.
The first phase begins with “Exclusive Listings,” which appear in search results on the Compass site, but are not directly advertised. “Coming Soon,” is the next phase, in which listings appear on the Compass site prior to appearing on the multiple listing service, which can last a day to several weeks. The third phase is when the listing goes live on all platforms, including the multiple listing service and Zillow.
According to Compass, one of the benefits of the three-phase marketing plan is that it hides some metrics, such as days on the market and price drop history, which tend to negatively impact interest in a home listing.
The industry opinion on private listings is divided based on business interests.
Zillow, being the nation’s largest online real estate marketplace, would stand to lose listings if brokers circumvented publicly listing their homes for sale. However, CoStar CEO Andy Florance, said portals like Zillow, NextHome and eXp Realty should remain neutral on private listings.
CoStar is the parent company of Homes.com, a fast-growing rival to Zillow. “Rest assured, if Zillow does block your listing it will still be seen on Homes.com,” Mr. Florance said in a letter to real estate agents.
But Zillow is far and away the largest and most influential real estate portal with 365.8 million monthly visits in 2024. Home sellers will likely have second thoughts about listing their homes privately if there’s a chance of being banned on Zillow.
Consumer advocates said there is a place in the real estate market for private listings for a small percentage of sellers — including celebrities and wealthy people selling expensive homes. The problem is that Compass is encouraging its agents to list everything privately, they said.
“Private listing networks limit buyer access to homes for sale and promote misleading, disadvantageous choices for most sellers,” said Wendy Gilch, a Franklin Park-based consumer advocate and Consumer Policy Center fellow. Private listing networks “would severely limit marketplace transparency and could well subject both buyers and sellers to manipulation by unethical brokers.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.