Noah and Taylor Parker had a clear plan to stay within their $250,000 budget when they set out to buy their first home.

They found exactly what they were looking for not too far from the Cranberry apartment they were renting — a $235,000 two-bedroom house with a half-acre yard for their two dogs to run.

Their monthly mortgage payment of $1,703, with a 6.62% interest rate, is nearly identical to the $1,700 they paid to rent a one-bedroom apartment.

“My max was going to be $250,000,” said Mr. Parker, 28. “I’m a very, very big budgeter. I don’t care to have the fanciest house in the neighborhood. If it’s got four walls, a roof and I can build equity, it’s got my name on it.”

Advertise with us

The Parkers’ story is one that’s increasingly common in this region and provides a prism into Pittsburgh's position as a national leader in affordable housing. A study out last week once again heralded Pittsburgh as having the nation’s most affordable housing market — where someone making the median income in 2024 would have spent 25.3% of their earnings to buy a median-priced home.

While the median home price nationwide sits at $420,000, Allegheny County’s median home price is $251,000. And the majority of home sales in the region fall in the $100,000 to $300,000 price range, according to West Penn Multi-List data.

Other areas of the country are not as fortunate.

Four of the five least affordable major metros are in California, according to the Redfin report released last week.

In Los Angeles, people making the median income in 2024 for that region — $92,994 — would have to spend 77.6% of their earnings on monthly housing costs if they bought the median-priced home there ($896,060).

Advertise with us

San Francisco was the next least affordable (76.2% of earnings), followed by San Jose (73.9%) and San Diego (67.3%). Rounding out the list was New York, where homeowners are spending 65.9% of their income on housing costs, according to Redfin, a Seattle-headquartered technology-based real estate brokerage.

Redfin based its affordability calculations on the median household income relative to each metro area.

Pittsburgh’s median income was $79,688, according to Redfin. Median incomes for the country’s least affordable metros were much higher — San Francisco’s was $159,316, for example, while San Jose checked in at $169,663, San Diego at $108,115 and New York at $96,128 — as was the cost of housing.

A first-time buyer’s market

Meanwhile, the mid-range housing market in Pittsburgh has strong demand.

West Penn Multi-List records show that in November, 474 homes priced between $200,000 and $300,000 were sold in 2024 and 455 homes in 2023.

Advertise with us

The second most popular price range for home sales here is $100,000 to $160,000, a range that recorded 338 home sales in November 2024 and 347  in November 2023, according to West Penn Multi-List.

A sizable chunk of this region’s housing stock remains accessible to first-time home buyers — a sharp contrast to the national housing market, said John Petrack, executive vice president of the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh.

“The fact that there’s so many properties available in that particular value range is important to the first-time buyer market,” Mr. Petrack said. “A larger percentage of the population can afford that value range. You have a larger pie, so to speak.”

That’s not the case everywhere. Nationwide in 2024, homebuyers needed to earn an annual income of at least $116,782 if they wanted to spend no more than 30% of their income on monthly housing payments for the median priced home, according to Redfin.

“That’s a record high and is $33,000 more than the typical household makes in a year,” the report authors said.

Advertise with us

“A rule of thumb in personal finance is that people should spend no more than 30% of their income on housing, though this rule has become harder to follow as housing costs have soared.”

Melissa Miller sold her six-bedroom home in Observatory Hill in December for $250,000 to a family eager to make it home, although some investors were eyeing it for multi-unit conversion.

“It broke my heart to sell it,” she said. “I love that house very much. But the people who bought it want it to be their family home to live in and enjoy, and that makes me so happy. I’m glad my house is going into family hands.”

Ms. Miller, 49, relocated to Bethel, N.Y., after retiring from her job as a social studies teacher at Franklin Regional High School in Murrysville. She bought the house — which came with a mother-in-law suite — in 2008 for $15,000 and renovated it over time.

Real estate agent Kay Barchetti at Compass Real Estate said she does a steady business with homes priced between $200,000 and $300,000 in the five counties around Pittsburgh in which she works.

Advertise with us

“It’s a real good price point for families buying for their college kids, for young executives and investors,” Ms. Barchetti said. “So, you have a lot of groups of people who like that price point around the city.”

Areas in and around the city of Pittsburgh where she finds most of her homes in that price range include the North Side, South Side, Mount Washington, Troy Hill and Reserve. She has a closing scheduled in Mt. Washington for a $165,000 house, and one in Observatory Hill for a $243,000 house, she said.

”It depends on the area,” Ms. Barchetti said. “I sell in the North Hills a lot. But my average sale in the North Hills is between $500,000 and $1 million. My average sale in the city is $200,000 to $300,000.”

Affordable? Or just old?

Pittsburgh’s affordability has a lot to do with the quality of houses here, said Chris Briem, a regional economist at the University of Pittsburgh.

“One of the ways Pittsburgh stands out is the age of the housing stock,” Mr. Briem said. “The city of Pittsburgh in particular has a very old housing stock compared to comparable urban cities.”

Advertise with us

Many areas have seen little growth, or outright decline, he said, adding that the region’s housing stock has an even higher level of disinvestment compared to others.

”Many areas outside the city as well have not seen much new housing construction and thus have old housing stocks compared to suburban areas elsewhere,” Mr. Briem said.

According to West Penn Multi-List, the median price for homes in the city of Pittsburgh last year was $235,000. The median price for homes in Allegheny County — including the city of Pittsburgh — was $251,000.

ReMax real estate agent Charlene Haislip said she had about a dozen transactions in Allegheny County last year, ranging from a $38,000 home sale in Homewood to a $690,000 sale in Monroeville.

“Every one of my years is different,” she said. “I have a pretty good range.”

Advertise with us

Denise Stover said most people she works with who are looking in the $200,000 to $300,000 range are first-time homebuyers.

“I always tell them you’re going to lose a few before you get one,” said Ms. Stover, a Compass Real Estate agent who works mostly in Murrysville, Irwin, Greensburg and Monroeville. “So, just be prepared.”

“You don’t want first-time homebuyers to run outside the gate wide-eyed and excited, and the first time we put in an offer and there’s multiple offers [and] we lose it, they wonder what happened,” she said.

The Parkers bought their home in Economy the same day it hit the market. There were no others bidders, they said.

“It was listed for $235,000. We bought it for $235,000. And it actually appraised for $240,000. So, we built automatic equity on it before it even closed,” Mr. Parker said.

Advertise with us

They only needed to repaint the rooms to colors they preferred before moving in. Their expenses have actually gone down because it cost more for electricity in the Cranberry apartment than in their 1,200-square-foot ranch-style house.

For now, the starter house is what they need — but it’s a far cry from their forever home.

“This is a stepping stone,” Mr. Parker said, noting that his job with Ford Motor Co. requires him to relocate periodically. “So, it’s definitely something that I bought to use as an investment until whenever they decide to move me.”