Pittsburgh’s real estate market hit a milestone that turned heads and made history about 30 years ago when a home in Shadyside sold for a staggering $1.1 million.
It was the first time a single-family home in the city sold for seven figures.
“Everyone was talking about it,” recalls longtime agent Roz Neiman, with Howard Hanna Real Estate.
Ms. Neiman said she had the opportunity to list the home on Braeburn Street a few years ago and it sold for $4.2 million — with no upgrades. “It had been kept pristinely,” she said.
One-million dollar home sales don’t cause jaws to drop anymore, but they are still relatively rare in this region. Million-dollar homes account for only 1.58% of Pittsburgh’s occupied houses, according to LendingTree, a personal finance website.
LendingTree ranked the nation’s 50 largest metropolitan areas to see where million-dollar homes are most plentiful and found that Pittsburgh is at the bottom of the list. At the top is San Jose, Calif., where 71.57% of the homes are worth at least $1 million.
Read More

While a million dollars might not stretch as far as it once did, in Pittsburgh it still goes a lot further than it would in some other cities.
“In California, for $1 million, you’ll get a three bedroom, two bathroom ranch that would sell for $250,000 to $300,000 here in Pittsburgh,” said Julie Welter, a Compass Realty agent in Upper St. Clair.
“Whereas in Upper St. Clair, you’ll get a minimum of 3,000 square feet, taller ceilings, beautiful woodworking and a beautiful home that is quite large and always with a home office,” she said.
Some of the factors behind the growth in million-dollar homes is linked to new construction, price appreciation and supply and demand. LendingTree found the share of owner-occupied homes across the country valued at $1 million or more stands at 10.57%. The number jumped 7.71% in 2022 alone.
Pittsburgh’s seven-figure home market, though small, is growing.
With more than a month left in 2024, agents here already have sold 360 homes worth at least $1 million in the region, nearly three times more than the 139 million-dollar homes sold in 2019, according to West Penn Multi-List.
Pittsburgh’s small luxury market
In the city’s luxury home market, $2 million has become the new $1 million, said Ms. Neiman.
“What used to be a million-dollar house is now $1.5 million or $1.8 million,” she said. “In west Shadyside, you will never find a $1 million house. It will be $2 million or more. And it will need a lot of work. In Murdoch Farms, you will never find $1 million. You will find a $1.8 million house, and it will need a lot of work.”
Ms. Neiman, who sells luxury homes in Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, Point Breeze and Fox Chapel, said houses are coming on the market higher than ever and they often need new kitchens, new bathrooms, heating systems and roofs.
“I showed a house yesterday for $2.4 million, and the people ran out of it because it needs everything,” Ms. Neiman said.
The pickings are slim for $1 million homes in the city, she said. A townhouse in Bakery Square will cost $1.3 million. An older house with no garage in Upper Lawrenceville will cost $700,000 or $800,000. But the buyer will need to gut it and likely spend another $800,000 on renovations, Ms. Neiman said.
Jacob Channel, a senior economist at LendingTree said Pittsburgh’s luxury market is smaller in comparison to others, but it’s actually not a bad thing to rank at the bottom of this list.
“In Pittsburgh specifically, when you’re spending $1 million or more on a house, it’s more likely to be a luxury house than not,” Mr. Channel said. “For example, I live in Brooklyn, New York, and a $1 million house here would probably be middle-class housing.
“Compared to some of those areas that are on the top of our list … you are probably going to get a whole heck of a lot more in Pittsburgh than you would in San Francisco.”
According to Lending Tree, metros with the highest share of million-dollar homes besides No. 1 San Jose, are San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Diego and Seattle.
Metros with the lowest share of million-dollar homes are Cleveland, Buffalo, N.Y., Louisville, Ky., Memphis, Tenn. and Pittsburgh.
‘The house they really want’
In Upper St. Clair, $1 million can buy you beauty or space — but rarely both.
Ms. Welter has two listings on the market for $1.1 million, which highlight the trade-off buyers make. One house has a pristine interior, but hardly any yard to speak of. The other house has a gorgeous 2-acre yard, but its interior comes with a to-do list of needed upgrades, including floors and bathrooms.
“The type of houses you’re going to get in the million-dollar range are going to be one or the other,” Ms. Welter said.
The buyers in this price range, she said, are typically doctors or executives from the oil and gas and health industries. They are usually high-income earners who have sold one or two houses in order to build up the equity needed for a seven-figure purchase.
“People buy their starter homes. They make money. They get the house that they really want later on,” Ms. Welter said.
Buyers typically finance seven-figure homes with a conventional jumbo loan, she said.
In 2024, the jumbo loan limit for single-family mortgages increased to $766,550. In high-cost areas like Alaska and Hawaii, the limit is approximately $1.15 million.
The only difference between a jumbo mortgage and a conventional mortgage is the dollar amount financed. Jumbo loans are used to finance real estate that is too expensive for conventional loans.
Home sales in all price ranges have been slower this year compared to prior years due to higher interest rates making homeownership more expensive. The 30-year fixed rate jumbo mortgage is currently 7.24%, according to Mortgage News Daily.
“We anticipate next year rates are going to come down,” Ms. Welter said. “That makes a huge difference as far as people’s buying power.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.