Libby Burris felt like the pandemic pause on student loan payments gave her some much-needed financial breathing room.

For nearly four years, the 35-year-old Butler County woman said she used the grace period to focus on keeping up with other essential needs that are costing more — including groceries and utilities.

“I was making my house payment, my car payment and paying my bills,” said the licensed professional counselor and Saxonburg resident.

Since student loan payments resumed for all borrowers in September, Ms. Burris is trying to fit the $300 school debt bill back into her monthly budget while juggling other costs — including the likelihood of needing to replace her car at some point.

Advertise with us

Like her, many student loan borrowers are feeling the squeeze. The Department of Education reports a national default rate of 12%, and the Pittsburgh region is one of the leading areas of the U.S. where student loan delinquencies are highest.

According to WalletHub, a personal finance website, Pittsburgh ranks fourth among cities with the highest student loan delinquency rates, partly because people here tend to take on more student loan debt.

“There’s a lot of expensive schools in the Pittsburgh area,” said Chip Lupo, a WalletHub spokesman. “And if you’re going for an MBA at Carnegie Mellon or a law degree at Duquesne University, you’re going to be paying off student loans of significant amounts for a long, long time.”

After a three-year payment pause on student loans during the pandemic, the U.S. Department of Education in October implemented another 12-month grace period in order to help borrowers transition back to regular payment mode.

During the 12-month “on-ramp” period, payments were technically required. However, nonpayment of the loans were not subject to any collections action.

Advertise with us

That’s now changing.

Since Sept. 30 — for the first time in four years — more than 43 million Americans with student debt totaling $1.5 trillion risk being reported as delinquent or defaulting on their loans and suffering damage to their credit if they don’t make their payments.

‘I don’t know when it’s going to be paid off’

Ms. Burris has been making payments since 2015 and still owes $79,000 for her bachelor’s degree in psychology from High Point University in North Carolina and her master’s degree in professional counseling from Carlow University.

“The payments I’m making on the student loans could be a whole car payment,” she said. “My car — a 2014 Kia with 130,000 miles — is paid off now, but the payment was $400.”

Squirrel Hill residents Ari and Tracy Rapport have been paying off student loans for so long they can hardly imagine life without them.

Advertise with us

“It’s sort of one of those things that I just can’t ever imagine what it will be like when it finally goes away,” said Mr. Rapport, 52.

They, too, were happy to get a break from making payments during the pandemic.

For them, it’s been over 20 years of monthly payments, deferments and just enough temporary reductions to keep them afloat when Ms. Rapport was temporarily unemployed as an elementary school teacher, and when Mr. Rapport’s income as a home energy designer was reduced at times.

“There wasn’t a time when we needed lower payments that we weren’t able to get it,” Mr. Rapport said, adding that their most recent combined payment amount was $500 a month.

He estimates his loan balance is about $15,000 and his wife’s is around $12,000.

Advertise with us

They haven’t let student debt hold them back from celebrating milestones.

“We were able to purchase a home in Squirrel Hill this year so our kids could walk to their schools, but it’s tight for sure,” Mr. Rapport said, referring to their 16-year-old daughter and fraternal twins, aged 14.

They each started out with about $40,000 apiece in student loan debt. They both received undergraduate degrees from Prescott College in Arizona. She majored in environmental education. He majored in dance and performance. They both went on to obtain master’s degrees.

Working as a teacher qualifies Ms. Rapport, 49, for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program, which cancels student loan debt for people working in the public and non-profit sector after 10 years of making on-time payments.

However, the couple recently learned that some of Ms. Rapport’s loans were private loans and did not qualify for the forgiveness program. After converting the private loans to federal loans, they learned that her payments will be reduced by 75%.

Advertise with us

“The principal is still there, but it enables us to pay a lower payment,” Mr. Rapport said. “I don’t know when it’s going to be paid off. But the lower payment is helpful.”

‘Pennsylvania is less generous when it comes to state aid’

WalletHub released its report, “Cities with the highest student loan delinquency rates,” to highlight where people have the greatest risk of credit score damage and other negative consequences.

New Orleans ranked No. 1 with a 3.04% delinquency rate in the third quarter this year; Chandler, Ariz., was No. 2 with a 2.55% delinquency rate; Bakersfield, Calif., was No. 3 with 2.38% delinquencies; Pittsburgh was No. 4 with 2.05%; and Baltimore was fifth with 2% delinquencies.

Education department data reports a national delinquency rate of 12.1% of of June 2024, significantly higher than WalletHub’s rates. The federal agency doesn’t break down delinquency data by cities or states.

“WalletHub’s ranking might be in the right order, but their student loan delinquency rates are based on an undisclosed methodology that doesn’t seem to match national data,” said Mark Kantrowitz, a nationally recognized expert on higher education funding.

Advertise with us

He said payments were technically restarted during the on-ramp period, but borrowers weren’t penalized for not making payments.

“During the on-ramp, a borrower who was delinquent was retroactively put into a forbearance every three months,” said Mr. Kantrowitz, author of “Who Graduates from College? Who Doesn’t?”

“They were technically delinquent, but then it was treated as though they weren’t. So, that’s what’s going on here.”

He said Pittsburgh borrowers face some circumstances that make them more vulnerable to being behind on their student loan payments.

“Pennsylvania is less generous when it comes to state aid. So, they are more likely to have borrowed and to borrow more money,” Mr. Kantrowitz said.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh residents often attend out-of-state colleges, which is more costly, and could lead to more use of debt, Mr. Kantrowitz said.

“So, if you have higher debt, even if you have similar income, your debt-to-income ratio is higher, and you’re more likely to struggle to repay your student loans,” he said.