It’ll be another month before anyone knows for sure what happened to millions of dollars deposited in retirement accounts that were controlled by a Sewickley employee benefits outfit, according to testimony Wednesday in federal court.

Youngstown, Ohio-based AMI Benefit Plan Administrators Inc., an independent fiduciary chosen by the court, is auditing at least 17 retirement and profit-sharing accounts that the U.S. Department of Labor in January alleged were embezzled and mismanaged by RiversEdge Retirement Solutions LLC. CEO Paul Palguta was also named as a defendant.

When the accounting is done, the U.S. Department of Labor will ask U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn Horan to distribute the money remaining in the 17 affected accounts, leaving individual plans free to pursue RiversEdge and Mr. Palguta for any missing funds, Labor Department Senior Trial Attorney Andrea Luby wrote in a Wednesday court filing.

In a January complaint, the Labor Department alleged that Mr. Palguta and RiversEdge embezzled at least $1.8 million between November and January from 17 accounts, and tried to conceal the shortfalls by shuffling money from other accounts. The department is seeking restoration of the money and to permanently remove Mr. Palguta from controlling the retirement and profit-sharing accounts he managed for a Gibsonia senior living complex, Vermont news organization, dental practice in Hawaii and hundreds of other small employers.

Advertise with us

It was uncertain whether more than 17 accounts were mismanaged.

“There might be more coming forward,” Judge Horan said.

Judge Horan, who presides in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, previously issued a temporary restraining order against RiversEdge, ending Mr. Palguta’s control and temporarily freezing accounts in which the Labor Department said funds were commingled. The restraining order was an emergency order, which generally lasts only a few weeks.

Wednesday’s hearing was for a temporary injunction from Judge Horan, which lasts longer than a restraining order and generally has more severe penalties for violations.

The Labor Department’s Ms. Luby said she would not object to unfreezing the accounts, which would allow plan sponsors to withdraw their funds and pick new managers.

Advertise with us

RiversEdge did not object to the restraining order or the pending temporary injunction the Labor Department is attempting to hammer out with other attorneys in the case. RiversEdge and Mr. Palguta have already turned over to the court $238,917 from a personal account and uncashed checks.

“I think we’ve met the threshold for a preliminary injunction,” Judge Horan said. “I want to get this resolved as quickly as possible.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com