The alleged meltdown of a Sewickley retirement plan administrator, who oversees hundreds of retirement plans and millions of dollars in assets, was felt last fall in Beaver County — where 120 current and former county employees now can’t get their benefits.

But a federal judge’s order Monday is the first step in restoring their access.

The Beaver County Deferred Compensation plan, a voluntary 457(b) retirement plan, which is separate from the county’s mandatory retirement plan covering 800 employees, had enrolled 120 people and held unknown assets generated by individual contributions since 2010, Beaver County Solicitor Garen R. Fedeles said. About 70 people with those accounts are current employees and all of the accounts are frozen as federal investigators sort out what they say is at least $8 million in missing or misappropriated funds.

U.S. District Court Judge Marilyn J. Horan on Monday removed RiversEdge Advanced Retirement Solutions’ President and CEO Paul Palguta as the third-party administrator of more than 240 retirement and profit-sharing accounts. Madison, Tenn.-based Receivership Management Inc. was named as Mr. Palguta’s replacement.

Advertise with us

It’s uncertain how much of the savings in individual accounts was insured, Mr. Fedeles said.

RiversEdge Advanced Retirement Solutions LLC was founded in 2009, and Mr. Palguta, who authorities said controlled at least 240 retirement plans, was described as a 25-year veteran of the retirement services industry in an online profile.

Federal law generally requires plan administrators to be bonded at 10% of the plan’s funds handled in the previous year, up to $1 million. The fidelity bond protects against theft and other illegal actions that result in losses.

But the law only covers Employment Retirement Income Security Act plans, and the Beaver County plan and others overseen by RiversEdge were not federally qualified, according to legal filings.

A Jan. 26 civil complaint filed by the U.S. Department of Labor in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania alleges that Mr. Palguta misappropriated or embezzled at least $8 million from retirement and profit-sharing plans that he administered for commercial apple growers, church groups, doctors’ offices and other small employers in Pennsylvania and elsewhere. The Labor Department is seeking restoration of losses and civil penalties.

Advertise with us

Things began to unfold in October when Mr. Palguta placed an order to buy shares for the Beaver County Deferred Compensation Plan. However, the plan did not have enough cash on hand to complete the order.

Homestead-based American Trust Custody, which serves as a retirement asset custodian and executes electronic fund transfers, informed Mr. Palguta of the shortfall and he said he would take care of it, according to court records. The transaction went through in November, a few weeks later, after $1.7 million had been deposited into the Beaver County plan account.

To make up for the shortfall in Beaver plan assets, federal investigators allege that Mr. Palguta siphoned $1.7 million from six unrelated plans, including $167,452 from a 403(b) plan operated by Charlottesville, Va.-based Christian Aid Mission; $223,123 from Etna-based Hampton Technical Associates’ 401(k) profit-sharing plan; $210,637 from the Hawaiian Island Dental 401(k) retirement plan, and other accounts.

The shifting money got the attention of American Trust, which began auditing RiverEdge’s accounts, according to court records. The audit revealed that RiverEdge’s corporate account had not received any cash from outside sources since at least 2017; all of the deposits were from retirement plans controlled by the company.

Mr. Fedeles, Beaver County solicitor, said it’s uncertain when the 120 current and former county employees will be able to access retirement benefits again.

Advertise with us

“We haven’t been given any kind of timeline,” he said.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com