Consumers and retailers are gearing up for the holiday shopping season, and after very strong gains in 2020 and 2021, and slower but still-solid growth in 2022, holiday sales growth is set to slow further this year.
PNC expects total holiday sales to be up less than 6% from last year, with about one-half of the increase from higher volumes, and the other half from higher prices. There will be a notable dichotomy in the industry, however, with online sales up by double-digits and very weak growth for traditional brick-and-mortar retailers.
The drivers for holiday spending in 2023 are mixed compared to the past few years. The biggest positive remains the very strong labor market. The number of jobs in the U.S. economy is up by about 3 million over the past year, with the average wage up by more than 4%. Given both more jobs and higher wages, labor market earnings in late 2023 are up by about 5% from the same period in 2022.
Inflation has also slowed, with prices overall up by about 3%.
As a result, household income, adjusted for inflation, is modestly higher entering the holiday season compared to 2022, allowing for increased spending this year.
Another positive is rising household wealth. Notwithstanding recent gyrations, stock prices in November are so far up about 15% from last year. Stock market wealth is particularly important for high-income households, who account for a disproportionate share of holiday spending. And house prices, after falling in late 2022 and early 2023, have bounced back and are up around 3% from a year ago. While housing wealth will add little to holiday spending this year, it won’t be the drag it was in 2022, when prices were falling, discouraging some purchases.
Read More
But there are some major negatives for holiday spending in 2023.
One is much higher interest rates.
The typical credit card interest rate is now almost 15%, up from around 13% last year and 12% in 2021. Higher interest rates will discourage many households from purchasing on credit.
Another drag will come from the October end of the pandemic-era deferment on student loan payments. Estimates are that the resumption of payments will cost households an extra $10 to $20 billion a month. While that’s a lot of money, it’s only about 1% of monthly consumer spending. Higher student loan payments will certainly impinge on some holiday spending, but will not be enough to prevent overall purchases from rising.
Then there’s continued high inflation (although that is fading). Through November overall consumer prices were up by about 3% from the same period last year. While this is higher than pre-pandemic inflation, it was much lower than the 7% inflation in both the 2021 and 2022 holiday seasons. Gasoline prices in particular are down — about 5% from this point last year even as they remain above their pre-pandemic level — and this will provide some relief.
But even as inflation has slowed, consumers remain uneasy about higher prices, and consumer confidence remains much lower than it was prior to the pandemic.
Another drag is the surge in spending that households have engaged in over the past few years.
After being cooped up in early 2020 with the pandemic — and with financial support from stimulus from the federal government and very low interest rates courtesy of the Federal Reserve — households have been on a buying spree over the past few years. Holiday sales increased a whopping 14% in 2020 and another 12% in 2021. Sales rose slightly more than 6% last season. As a result, many consumers are simply tired of spending and may decide to exercise a bit more restraint this year.
Almost all of the increase in sales will come from online retailers. PNC’s forecast is for 11% growth in online holiday sales compared to last year, but only a 2% gain for brick-and-mortar retailers, not even keeping pace with inflation.
In addition, holiday spending is shifting from goods to services, although it is tough to put numbers on the trend. With a much stronger post-pandemic rebound in goods spending relative to services, consumers are looking for experiences that they have missed out on over the past few years, such as travel, dining out and recreational opportunities. Services are likely to make up an increasing share of holiday purchases over the long run.
Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.