With gasoline prices sky-high and people watching their budgets, thrifty consumers might be tempted to apply for a gas-branded credit card to save a few bucks at the pump.
But that probably isn’t the best move.
Consumers could end up saving much more using a general purpose cash-back card.
Co-branded cards issued by BP, Shell, ExxonMobil and others typically offer a flat 5 or 10 cents off per gallon vs. cash-back cards that offer a percentage off purchases. As gasoline prices rise, so does the benefit of getting a percentage discount.
Pump prices in the Pittsburgh region were averaging around $4.20 a gallon for regular unleaded last week, costing $63 for a 15-gallon fill-up.
Paying with a gas-branded card (at 5 or 10 cents off per gallon) would shave 75 cents to $1.50 per trip.
Read More
But a rewards card paying 5% on purchases would save $3.15, or 21 cents per gallon — double to quadruple the savings with a gas card.
“Gas-branded cards really aren’t that great. At 5 or 10 cents off, the more gas prices rise the less meaningful that is,” said Ted Rossman, senior industry analyst at Creditcards.com. “I recommend getting a good general purpose cash-back card.”
In addition, he noted, with general purpose cards, motorists aren’t beholden to a specific brand of gas.
A number of issuers are paying a generous 5% cash back on gasoline purchases, Mr. Rossman said.
For consumers with warehouse club memberships, the Sam’s Club Mastercard and Costco Anywhere Visa card are two great options, he said.
Sam’s pays 5% back on up to $6,000 in gas purchases per year, while Costco offers 4% back on up to $7,000. The cards can be used at just about any gas station, not just at Sam’s or Costco.
Members who already buy discounted gas at the warehouse clubs can pump up their savings with a club-branded credit card, too.
Other options include the “Discover it” cash back card that gives 5% back on rotating categories — with gasoline purchases on tap for April, May and June — or the American Express Blue Cash preferred card offering 3% on gas and 6% on groceries, although it carries a $95 annual fee after the first year.
As a welcome offer, the Chase Freedom Unlimited and Chase Freedom Flex cards are giving new cardholders 5% cash back on gas (up to $6,000 in purchases) during the first year, plus the standard $200 back after spending $500 in the first three months.
Mr. Rossman said a good way to save even more is to combine discounts with a 5% rewards card and free gas company apps that offer a few cents off per gallon.
“You can stack the discounts. Use the rewards credit card and the gas station payment app. BP has one. Almost all of the major brands have one,” he said.
One reason some people stick to using gas-branded credit cards is because that’s all they can get.

Like most retail cards, gas cards are easier to qualify for than general purpose cards offered by big issuers.
“If you have a fair credit score, in the mid-600s, you probably will be able to qualify for a gas-branded card,” said Bill Hardekopf, an industry analyst with Moneycrashers.com. “In some cases you might even be able to get one with a lower score. With most of those general reward cards offered by big banks, you need good to excellent credit.”
Although retail cards are easier to get, the tradeoff is they tend to charge higher interest rates, which is a big downside for people who carry a balance.
According to Bankrate.com, gas-branded cards are charging an average of 25.8% annually vs. an average of 16.4% for all credit cards.
“It’s best to pay off in full, and on time, each month so you don’t get hit with very high interest rates … especially with the gas company cards,” Mr. Hardekopf noted.
Mr. Rossman added a word of caution about apps like Gasbuddy and Gas Guru that people use to help identify the best pump prices in their area.
“I recently used the apps to find the lowest gas price, but when I showed up, it was 90 cents higher than the app,” he said.
“In theory you could find a good deal, but in practice buyers should beware. It’s a lot of self-reported information and can be out of date.”
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.