2021 Lexus ES250 AWD F Sport: A Lexus that’s lacking?

Price: $49,435 as tested.

Conventional wisdom: Car and Driver likes the “creamy ride quality, attractive starting price, quiet, relaxing cabin,” but not that “even F Sport models lack athleticism, poky acceleration with base four cylinder, rear seatbacks don't fold to expand cargo space."

Marketer’s pitch: “Starting at $40,800.”

Advertise with us

Reality: How about: “The Lexus ES250. Where low price and luxury don’t really meet, but do kind of nod in passing.”

What’s new: You can finally get all-wheel drive in the ES. The model will get a refresh for 2022, with some new technology and suspension upgrades, plus a squintier front end (and you thought that wouldn’t be possible). New touchscreen infotainment will make that part of the experience more enjoyable as well, I’m certain. So the end of the model cycle could even mean a greater bargain.

Driver’s Seat: Usually when I get a Lexus sedan or SUV, my rear end is all primed for luxury and comfort, softness and suppleness. Well, here’s the ES250, marketed as entry-level luxury, but close to making the Camry look good in comparison. The 10-way F Sport heated and ventilated seats felt like something I’d enjoyed in a 2011 model; the coverings seemed uninspired and the padding just enough. It felt neither sporty nor luxurious, neither fish nor fowl.

It may not actually be beaten by the Camry, but the Venza seat would certain go cheek to cheek against it.

Up to speed: Getting the ES250 on the road didn’t dispel my notion that Lexus was phoning this one in. First of all, an ES250 (which designates a 2.5-liter four-cylinder?). A friend asked whether there even was such a model. The ensuing 203 horsepower is enough to move the sedan. Just.

Advertise with us

It gets to 60 mph in 8.1 seconds, according to Car and Driver. There’s a dial for Sport mode, but I think it’s like the spoiler on a 1983 Ford Mustang: simply for show. The ES250 is particularly lethargic pulling out onto a hill, but there’s a bit of a hesitation with almost every start. A chance to venture on highways north through Berks County did not make the drive experience feel any better. (A 3.5-liter ES350 V-6 or a hybrid version are also available).

Shifty: The 8-speed automatic transmission also brings a touch of Toyota — no real shiftability in this Lexus. You can move the lever or paddles to your heart’s content, but if you leave it in 6 at a stop sign, it’ll go back to first and proceed to run through the gears without you, stopping at 6.

On the road: The ES250 is fun-ish, but it’s not the reason to choose this sedan over any other. It rolls a lot in hard cornering, and the ride is smooth-y and not offensive.

Friends and stuff: Rear-seat passengers are treated to quarters both comfortable and roomy. Legroom is generous, and headroom is good. Footroom is a hair snug under the seat, but so much legroom makes that a moot point.

The back seat feels nicer than the Driver’s Seat, with a great shape and good headrest. Center passengers will be perched up, and their feet will have a bit of a hump, but the console doesn’t intrude badly. (Maybe buyers should hire chauffeurs with the money they save over a high-end Lexus.)

Advertise with us

Cargo space is a modest 13.9 cubic feet. And no folding down the rear seat.

Play some tunes: The ES250 features the Lexus touchpad operation system, plus buttons on the dashboard for different music sources and for up and down, plus buttons near the touchpad for map and menu, plus a dial for volume. Confusing to read about? Confusing-er to operate.

Sound from the system is pretty good, about a B-plus or an A-minus, which is also a lowish grade for a Mark Levinson special ($1,080 alone, or $2,900 with fancy navigation upgrades).

Keeping warm and cool: Buttons handle fan speed and air source, and toggles take care of temperature. There was plenty cool air to be had in the ES250 tested; I left the temperature at 74 degrees, four or five ticks higher than my usual choice.

Night shift: Interior lights are subtle but light things up nicely. Headlights do a good job as well.

Advertise with us

Fuel economy: Now here’s where the ES250 scores a few points. I averaged 28 mpg through my week’s test, a nice number for a normally powered sedan with an F Sport jazzing it up (even if it is more Kenny G than Ella Fitzgerald).

Where it’s built: Georgetown, Ky. — conveniently in the same plant as the Camry.

How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts the ES reliability to be a 4 out of 5. It received 5s until 2018.

In the end: We used to think the ES was a Camry with a Lexus badge slapped on it. But this ES could only hope to reach such heights. You might be able to get one for a “bargain” price, but if I want comfort, reliability, all-wheel drive and great fuel economy, I’d steer my money toward a Venza.

Scott Sturgis is a freelance auto writer; mrdriversseat@gmail.com.