This week: 2021 Mazda CX-5 AWD Carbon Edition.
Price: $33,910 as tested. Navigation SD card, $450; rear bumper guard, $125.
Conventional wisdom: Motor Trend likes the “fun driving dynamics, excellent interior and exterior design, impressive safety scores” but not the “limited cargo space, sometimes tricky infotainment.”
Marketer’s pitch: “After test driving the turbo, I just had to have it,” Mazda quotes an unnamed consumer on KBB.com.
Reality: Faster but not quite up to speed.
Catching up: Last week, we rode around in the Subaru Forester Sport, which takes its time getting from place to place but seemed to return the Forester to its competent handling days of yore.
Read More
What’s new: The Carbon Edition is all new. Like the Forester, bigger things are planned for the 2022 model.
Up to speed: The turbocharged 2.5-liter four puts the CX-5 into the hot-rod category. People have pretended it’s been there based on the fun-to-drive factor but normally aspirated Mazdas have never really been all that fast.
Horsepower is 250, and it motivated the small SUV to 60 mph in 6.1 seconds, according to Motor Trend.
I had to double-check that I really had an all-wheel-drive model, as full-on acceleration does mean the kind of wild up-front pull of a front-driver.
Shifty: The 6-speed shiftable automatic performs nicely. Sport mode can hold the vehicle in gear for far too long, so shifting through the console shifter becomes the preferred method of driving the wheels.
On the road: As mentioned, the test vehicle was all-wheel drive, but it didn’t feel like it. A whole bunch of pull came from the front when rounding the corners, just like when all-out accelerating.
Hill climbing is a downside to the CX-5. The engine makes an unfortunate whine, disturbing even when Mr. Driver’s Seat is deep in sound system testing mode, and this is most noticeable climbing long grades.
The CX-5 is also a little rough on the bumps. It rides nicely on smooth highways, but rough roads become unpleasant.
Driver’s Seat: The upgraded leather seats remind me of a Mustang. Unfortunately, it’s a 1965 Mustang they most remind me of. The leather strips, the rim around the front and sides — it has that classic look, but it just doesn’t add up to real comfort. At least it’s not the low-back bucket seat.
Fortunately, I did grow accustomed to it. It’s not uncomfortable all the time, but it became so on trips to King of Prussia and back.
The dashboard is typical Mazda basic black with silver trim. Nothing to write home about and certainly not overdone. Gauges are also clear if a little spare.
Friends and stuff: The rear seat offers an overall good position plus plenty of headroom, legroom and foot room in the outside corners. Sitting back, though, is not a comfortable prospect, and there’s no adjustment to the seatback.
The center seat loses legroom to the hump and the console, although the seat itself is not terrible. But the CX-5 is a skinny thing, so shoulder room for three is scant.
Cargo space is 30.9 cubic feet with the rear seat up and 59.6 when it’s folded, and that second number is about 20% shy of the Forester space (76.1).
Play some tunes: Mazda continues with its dial and button operation as it has for years and years. It functions nicely except for days when you feel like hunting here and there for something to listen to. The 10.25-inch screen is now standard on all CX-5s.
Sound from the system was pretty good until I discovered the Bose Stereo Mode, Centerpoint and AudioPilot. Those enhance the sound nicely and move this baby to an A.
Keeping warm and cool: A dial controls temperature, and buttons handle everything else. The heater vents are elongated pentagons, so directional control is a bit stiff.
Night shift: The headlights shine in a good place, but the overhead light is slightly bright.
Fuel economy: The CX-5 averaged about 24 mpg over 1,100 miles, which included about 200 of the usual Mr. Driver’s Seat circuit of exurban roads and highways. So these numbers are probably more true to life than my usual figures. Feed it only the best for all 250 horses, otherwise you’ll get about 10% fewer.
Where it’s built: Hiroshima, Japan.
How it’s built: Consumer Reports predicts the CX-5 reliability to be a five out of five.
In the end: I know I’m supposed to love high performance and fun driving, but the competence of the Subaru and the comfort of the seats make it the Mr. Driver’s Seat choice among these two. We’ll see how the 2022 refresh compares.
Of course, I’d like the Forester Wilderness much better with the turbo that it won’t have yet, and for that reason, all of these are quickly forgotten in lieu of the Outback Wilderness.
In the end: Here’s to weird little brothers. I may say I want great handling and acceleration, but I kind of like the Forester better.
Scott Sturgis is a freelance auto writer; mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.