Gus Faucher is the senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.

The federal government has gone on a borrowing spree in response to the COVID-19 crisis, with the national debt in May 2020 up by 25% from before the pandemic.

While high levels of government debt can sometimes be a drag on economic growth, the big jump in federal spending to combat the pandemic has been vital to the strong economic recovery that is underway. And with extremely low interest rates, the cost to taxpayers of paying for the debt has actually fallen.

The United States will eventually have to reduce its borrowing, but that can wait until the economy has fully recovered from the Viral Recession.

Advertise with us

Federal spending has increased dramatically because of the pandemic.

There was aid to businesses, both small and large; aid to state and local governments; three rounds of stimulus payments to many households; expanded eligibility for unemployment insurance and higher benefits; and support for the health care system to combat the pandemic and get people vaccinated.

Federal outlays rose 47% in fiscal year 2020 (which ended on Sept. 30), the biggest one-year increase since the Korean War, with spending projected to increase another 10% in the current fiscal year, according to the Office of Management and Budget. At the same time federal government revenues, primarily taxes paid, fell by 1% in fiscal year 2020 due to the recession, although they are projected to grow 4% this fiscal year.

With spending way up and revenues down slightly, federal government borrowing was a record $3.1 trillion in fiscal year 2020, more than triple the deficit in the previous year. This year the deficit is expected to increase further to $3.7 trillion. These are the largest budget deficits ever in dollar terms, but deficits during World War II were larger as a share of the size of the economy.

Because of this, debt held by the public rose to $21 trillion in fiscal year 2020, just about equal to economic output (gross domestic product) over the same period. And debt is projected to increase to 110% of GDP in fiscal year 2021; this would set a record, surpassing the 106% in 1946 as spending on World War II wound down.

Advertise with us

That sounds like a lot of borrowing, and it is.

But right now, interest rates are extremely low, in part because the economy is still weak, and in part because the Federal Reserve is pushing down both short-term and long-term interest rates to support economic growth. And those very low interest rates have reduced the cost of financing the federal debt. Net interest payments on the federal debt actually fell in 2020, despite the big increase in federal borrowing, because of a big drop in interest rates. And federal interest payments, as a share of the size of the economy, were much lower in 2020 than they were in the 1970s and 1980s, even with much more debt (see chart).

It made enormous sense for the U.S. to pile on debt over the past year to combat the recession that ensued from the pandemic, especially given very low interest rates.

With job losses of 22 million in March and April 2020, stimulus payments to households and increased unemployment insurance benefits prevented a total collapse in consumer spending, which makes up about two-thirds of the U.S. economy.

Aid to businesses, especially the Paycheck Protection Program for small businesses, allowed them to keep the lights on and avoid even larger layoffs during the recession last year. Now that the economy is recovering, those businesses are open and expanding to meet rising demand.

Advertise with us

And health care spending has allowed for the rapid vaccination of the American public, creating the conditions for a strong and long economic expansion.

This doesn’t mean that the U.S. can continue to pile on debt indefinitely, however.

Interest rates have moved somewhat higher in 2021 and will continue to increase as the economy recovers, raising the cost of financing the national debt. And extended high budget deficits could start to “crowd out” private sector borrowing that increases the country’s capital stock, makes workers more productive, and boosts long-run economic growth and household incomes.

Federal budget deficits relative to the size of the economy will decline over the next few years as spending programs related to the pandemic wind down and strong economic growth boosts tax revenues.

But budget deficits were already creeping up ahead of the pandemic, and the ongoing retirement of the baby boomers and rising spending on Social Security and Medicare will put further pressure on the federal budget over the next couple of decades.

Advertise with us

With a steadily growing economy the U.S. doesn’t need to balance its budget. But policymakers do need to make smart decisions about our priorities.

They should make investments in the economy that promote strong economic growth that benefits everyone; fund important objectives like national defense, support for the elderly and access to health care; and raise sufficient revenue through taxes that are fair and support growth.