Millions of Americans will see a drop in their auto insurance premiums as the pandemic slashes the number of vehicles on the road — but the cuts announced so far aren’t nearly enough, the Consumer Federation of America said Monday.

The refunds and credits announced by insurance companies in recent weeks reflect a dramatic decline in accidents and claims as millions of Americans shelter at home.

Still, the CFA and the Center for Economic Justice are calling on state insurance commissioners to step in to ensure that the refunds are fair by compiling data on premiums vs. claims. And they are urging states to follow the lead of Pennsylvania, which has told insurers they can’t raise premiums based on reduced credit scores due to COVID-19.

Most of the largest carriers — including State Farm, Allstate and Nationwide —  have announced rate reductions ranging from less than 10% up to about 30%. But reductions probably should be in the range of 40% to 50%, the consumer groups said.

Advertise with us

Americans on average spend about $1,000 to insure each of their vehicles, the groups said.

“Drivers are being hugely overcharged. Time is of the essence,” the CFA’s director of insurance, Robert Hunter, said in a conference call with reporters Monday.

The reduction most insurers are offering “is not enough,” said Birny Birnbaum, executive director of the justice center.

The two groups have been calling for rate cuts since mid-March, when government stay-at-home orders began to mount nationwide, pulling millions of vehicles off the road. Then consumers began pressing their carriers for relief.

“They called, they tweeted ... then the flood gates opened,” Mr. Hunter said.

Advertise with us

Even though most of the 35 largest auto insurance carriers have announced reductions, the amount of money and timing vary.

The CFA  graded each company based on their policies, with the highest scores awarded to companies that are giving premium refunds of 21% or more; covering at least part of March, plus April and May; and making immediate payments to customers.

Among the grades: State Farm received an A for promising an immediate refund of about 25% covering March 20 through May 31; Allstate received a B for a 15% refund on April and May premiums and for being among the first to offer refunds, while Erie Insurance — a big carrier in Western Pennsylvania — got an F.

“[Erie] claims to be providing customers with $200 million in relief but is actually only promising to cut rates sometime in the future,” the CFA said.

A spokesman for Erie Insurance defended the company’s policy.

Advertise with us

The planned reduction “represents an overall 5% discount for at least 12 months at renewal,” Matthew Cummings wrote in an email. “While [the CFA’s] report card evaluates the immediate impact on customers for March, April and May 2020, Erie’s decision to lower rates, once approved, is designed to offer more impactful relief to customers.”

In addition to the announced refunds, consumers whose cars are now largely parked at home should contact their carrier and ask for an additional reduction based on their particular circumstances, the consumer groups said.

“Consumers whose premiums were based on driving 1,000 miles a month but who are now driving 100 miles a month, for example, should get a lower premium.”

Motorists who are driving less and thinking about canceling their coverage entirely should reconsider, the CFA warned.

“You may need to go to the grocery store or the doctor’s, and you will want to be covered,” said Doug Heller, insurance expert at the CFA. In addition, drivers with a break in coverage will likely get penalized for that and end up with a higher rate when they try to get insurance again, he said.

Advertise with us

“We definitely don’t recommend people drop their coverage unless they are literally getting rid of their cars.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.