Consumer advocacy groups are accusing state auto insurance regulators of standing by as insurance companies reaped millions in illegal profits during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Consumer Federation of America and Center for Economic Justice say consumers are due millions of dollars in refunds from 2020 as miles driven, vehicle crashes and auto insurance claims fell dramatically while millions of Americans sheltered at home.

“In virtually every state, auto insurance premiums — by law — cannot be excessive,” said J. Robert Hunter, CFA’s director of insurance. “The inability or unwillingness of almost all state insurance regulators to enforce the law and protect consumers raises serious questions,” he said.

The CFA and CEJ released a report this week analyzing premium and claims results for 2020, including the “premium relief” offered by major insurers. According to the report, insurers should have returned $42 billion in excess premiums but returned only $13 billion.

Advertise with us

As a result, insurers overcharged policyholders by an average of roughly $125 per insured vehicle, the advocacy groups said.

According to the report, Pennsylvanians are due some $1.1 billion in premium relief.

State Farm, the nation’s largest auto insurer, said it was monitoring driving behaviors to ensure that rates reflected anticipated driving and claim volume.

“State Farm auto rates remain below pre-COVID-19 levels, although miles driven and claim volume have increased,” the company said in an email Thursday.

In April and May of 2020, most of the nation’s big insurers provided refunds or credits to consumers in response to the pandemic, but very little of the excess premium was returned after last spring, the advocacy groups said.

Advertise with us

They said California, Michigan, New Jersey and New Mexico were the only states to require premium refunds in the spring of 2020. And only California continued to require refunds.

“Most regulators did not take — and have still not taken — action to require the necessary premium relief from auto insurers,” the groups said.

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department said Thursday it was committed to ensuring that the effects of the pandemic are properly reflected in insurance rates.

“The department has strongly encouraged insurers to work with consumers throughout the COVID pandemic, and we have instructed insurers to incorporate its impact in their rate filings,” the agency said in an email.

It said it had approved roughly 170 “premium reduction, giveback or similar accommodation filings to the benefit of Pennsylvania’s policyholders,” adding that guidance it created to instruct insurers on how to file such accommodations to guarantee their expedited review and implementation was adopted by other states.

Advertise with us

The Consumer Federation of America’s report is available here.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.