Mutual fund owners who lost money when stocks took a dive last year will feel a double dose of pain when they realize — if they haven’t already — that they still owe capital gains taxes on funds that earned them no return.
It’s a frustrating scenario that has come up for a lot of mutual fund investors this tax season, and tax accountants are having to do a lot of explaining.
“Frankly, sometimes clients want to blame us. They think we are morons,” said James Lange, owner of Lange Financial Group in Squirrel Hill. “People are very unhappy. Nobody really explained to them that even though you had losses, you may still owe taxes.”
Taxes can take a big bite out of any returns an investor receives on an investment. But because of the way mutual funds distribute gains to all of its shareholders, a phenomenon can occur some years when shareholders are responsible for taxes on capital gains they did not actually receive.
This year happens to be one of those occasions.
During 2016 and 2017, stock markets had large gains and thus investors made money in their portfolios.
But 2018 was a down year for the market. The Russell 3000, which tracks the broad U.S. stock market, ended the year with a -5.24 percent return, while foreign stocks tracked by the MSCI World Index delivered a -14.09 percent return.
“Despite this, many of the largest mutual fund firms in the world, such as American Funds, Fidelity, MFS, and Janus Henderson, made large capital gains distributions last year, on which taxes will need to be paid,” said Bernard Carter, managing director of investments at Hapanowicz & Associates Wealth Management, Downtown.
How did this happen?
“Much of it has to do with the fact that stocks have been appreciating for 10 years,” Mr. Carter said. “Therefore, mutual fund portfolios contain securities with large unrealized gains. As investors yanked money from these funds last year, this forced the funds to sell appreciated stocks to meet redemption requests, thus resulting in capital gains.”
The last time this happened was in 2015.
It was a year when markets on the whole had seen pretty low returns or even negative returns. However, distributions from mutual funds that year were higher because in 2013 and 2014, capital gains had recovered from recession levels and mutual fund managers had no or little losses to offset the gains.
Mr. Lange said the industry calls this type of capital gain “phantom income” because the investor didn’t see it and didn’t receive a check for it. However, everyone invested in the fund must pay capital gains on it.
“You might have paid $100,000 for a mutual fund and it went down in value to $80,000,” Mr. Lange said. “A lot of people may have feared it would drop more and sold it.
“In order to pay them out, the mutual fund sold shares of highly appreciated assets and incurred capital gains,” he said. “That is one of the downsides of owning mutual funds.”
Denny Baish, a senior investment analyst at Fort Pitt Capital Group in Green Tree, said the firm starts anticipating negative returns from mutual fund companies in September when they typically begin reporting estimates of capital gains distributions.
“That gives holders of the funds an idea of the tax hit they could incur at the end of the year,” he said.
But December 2018 ended up being a particularly miserable month for stock investors due to the ugly Christmas Eve plunge, which could have deepened the pain.
Fort Pitt advisers took steps to protect clients from the tax hit.
In response to the lost value in mutual funds, Mr. Baish said the firm sold funds across the board in the fourth quarter, and did what is called tax loss harvesting.
The firm looked at mutual fund positions that had unrealized losses and sold the funds for less than the client paid for them to offset any gains they may receive from other holdings, such as dividend paying stocks and other mutual funds.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.